Home of the Brave

Salon.com Andrew O'Hehir

Home of the Brave isn't exactly a subtle or a delicate picture -- it's an old-fashioned Hollywood movie, at least in tone, that's being released like an indie -- but it has some terrific acting and comes straight from the heart.

New York Daily News Elizabeth Weitzman

While Mark Friedman's script is as unsubtle as Winkler's direction, their sincerity and the subject's sharp immediacy lend the film a certain power.

The Hollywood Reporter Michael Rechtshaffen

Timeliness is all very well, but the significant subject matter cries out for a defter directorial touch and a deeper complexity in regard to the characters and performances.

Los Angeles Times Sam Adams

The movie's mild-mannerness is especially disappointing when compared with such documentaries as "The War Tapes" and the excellent "Home Front," vivid and incisive explorations of post-Iraq anger and disillusionment that have gone largely unseen by a disinterested public. If Americans are suffering from Iraq fatigue, Home of the Brave will do little to rouse them.

ReelViews James Berardinelli

Had Home of the Brave presented credible stories about believable characters, it might have been a powerful drama.

Christian Science Monitor Peter Rainer

Home of the Brave is a milestone of sorts. But it's a formulaic, overacted piece of work that rarely delves deep.

TV Guide Ken Fox

Starts with a bang and ends in a long, protracted whimper.

Entertainment Weekly Lisa Schwarzbaum

Evenness of political keel, combined with a generic filmmaking style, is an artistic weapon way too puny for a successful assault on so tough, bruising, and crucial a subject.

Washington Post Stephen Hunter

The best thing about the movie is that it's interested in the soldiers, not the self-serving popinjays who seem to think the war is a big fat career-enhancing photo opportunity. The people who got shot at deserve most of the attention.

The New York Times Stephen Holden

As this cautious, politically evenhanded movie grinds along like clockwork, the fuse that should spark an emotional explosion fizzles after some sporadic hisses and sputters.

Village Voice Nathan Lee

As sincere as a three-legged puppy.

New York Post Lou Lumenick

The apolitical and well-meaning Home of the Brave is predictable and maudlin.

Premiere Ethan Alter

By straining to make a respectful war film for everyone, Winkler and Friedman have wound up with a toothless picture that won't satisfy anyone.

The Onion (A.V. Club) Keith Phipps

Whatever its model, the film is assembled from much poorer material, leftover parts of Lifetime movies and well-meaning indie films seen only on opening nights at some forgotten festival in Tampa.

Wall Street Journal Joe Morgenstern

Starts well with the stirring spectacle of young men and women, members of a National Guard unit stationed south of Baghdad, struggling to do their duty in an alien land of unfathomable danger. Once they return, however, wounded physically or shattered spiritually, the film turns didactic, contrived and occasionally ludicrous.