Home on the Range

The Onion (A.V. Club) Nathan Rabin

A sweet, raucously funny, comic Western that corrects a glaring historical injustice by finally surveying the Old West through the eyes of cows rather than cowboys.

Film Threat Kevin Carr

Has a wacky charm and a feeling like no other Disney film in recent years.

Christian Science Monitor David Sterritt

Old-style animation slows down after a snappy start, but it's lively enough to keep kids from fidgeting too much.

Seattle Post-Intelligencer Paula Nechak

Belongs to its trio of "bovine" voice talent -- Roseanne Barr, Dame Judi Dench and Jennifer Tilly -- who play with such tongue-in-cheek delight upon their public personas that it's hard to separate cow character from the celebrities.

Austin Chronicle Marrit Ingman

A good bet for family viewing. It's got a charming, simple plot, a smart Alan Menken score, and enough subversive humor to wring a chuckle or two out of Mom and Dad.

USA Today Claudia Puig

The visual effects are lovely to behold, and the songs by Bonnie Raitt, Tim McGraw and k.d. lang are fairly catchy.

Chicago Sun-Times Roger Ebert

It's only 76 minutes long, but although kids will like it, their parents will be sneaking looks at their watches.

The Globe and Mail (Toronto) Liam Lacey

Whatever the narrative shortcomings, these characters have the warmth of antique painted storybooks, unlike the eerie plastic simulation of Pixar characters.

Wall Street Journal Joe Morgenstern

Any shortfalls in Home on the Range a conventional but perfectly pleasant entertainment, have more to do with the ABC's of storytelling than with the D's of animation.

Variety Joe Leydon

An engagingly rambunctious toon Western that likely will attract herds of family auds, if not multitudes of teens and tweeners, to megaplex corrals.

Empire Olly Richards

Highly likeable, pleasantly unpretentious and plenty amusing.

Entertainment Weekly Lisa Schwarzbaum

The conservatively cheery artistic style suggests that the animation team has been reading Sundance merchandise catalogs.

LA Weekly Scott Foundas

The film skews young, to be sure, and it isn't as memorable as the new Disney classics of the early 1990s, but there's still plenty here to hold the interest of viewers of all ages: delightful performances (particularly by Dench, plowing Angela Lansbury terrain), zinging comic dialogue and a soundtrack that's a wealth of sonorous riches.

Chicago Tribune Michael Wilmington

Isn't good satire or good slapstick. It does have those lyrical, catchy Menken tunes, and the film perks up whenever Raitt or lang sing one of them. But much of this movie is deadly.

Los Angeles Times Kenneth Turan

What it really is is an unapologetic cartoon, a harum-scarum endeavor that's so comically frantic it wears you out as much as it entertains.

The Hollywood Reporter Frank Scheck

This amiable, Western-themed animated effort from the Walt Disney Co. is a clear attempt to return to the more lighthearted cartoon style that was so prevalent before its onslaught of stately musical epics.

New York Daily News Jack Mathews

An intended throwback to the halcyon days of colorful studio cartoons, more in the Chuck Jones style than Disney, and the animation of its characters and Western motif is fine. But the writing of co-directors Will Finn and John Sanford and their characterizations are embarrassingly bad.

TV Guide Angel Cohn

Although superficially an odd couple, the outspoken Barr and the restrained Dench work together surprisingly well and a steady stream of jokes aimed at both adults and kids keeps this genial entertainment galloping along at a brisk pace.

New York Post Lou Lumenick

So udderly mediocre.

San Francisco Chronicle Walter Addiego

This 76-minute Western tall tale isn't out-and-out bad, but strictly formulaic and an underachievement from the studio that made the dazzling "Snow White."

Chicago Reader J.R. Jones

Assorted movie in-jokes should keep parents tolerably entertained, and Alan Menken's songs mercifully favor western swing over the expected twang pop.

Miami Herald Christine Dolan

Good for some giggles. Especially if you're under the age of, oh, 8 or so.

Portland Oregonian Karen Karbo

Will best be enjoyed on DVD. You can pop it in for the kids and spend the next 90 minutes or so doing something else.

Philadelphia Inquirer Carrie Rickey

Despite lovely songs from k.d. lang and Bonnie Raitt (written by Beauty and the Beast composer Alan Menken), this range is about as serene as a hen party.

Washington Post Jennifer Frey

Charming as it can be, though, Home on the Range is still an overextended cartoon.

Boston Globe Ty Burr

Even older kids will understand that Pixar does it so much better, not because of their computers but because of an intelligent attention to script and character and craft. If the people running Disney don't understand that much anymore, maybe they should turn out the lights and go home.

The New York Times A.O. Scott

The best cartoons are built on the contradictory pursuit of meticulously arranged anarchy. But they never seem needy, or desperate for laughs, as Home on the Range does. The film seems hungrier for a pat on the head than a chuckle.

Washington Post Michael O'Sullivan

Comes across less as a fully realized work of storytelling than as a commercial for a corporation whose goal of entertainment has been replaced by that of making money.

Dallas Observer Robert Wilonsky

Should make about $750, which is how much they need to save the farm, but a little less than Disney CEO Michael Eisner needs to save his job.

Premiere Sara Brady

Suffocatingly boring.