Game Releases by Score

98
1.

Grand Theft Auto IV

Platform: Xbox 360
April 29, 2008
97
2.

Grand Theft Auto V

Platform: Xbox 360
September 17, 2013
96
3.

BioShock

Platform: Xbox 360
August 21, 2007
96
4.

The Orange Box

Platform: Xbox 360
October 10, 2007
96
5.

Mass Effect 2

Platform: Xbox 360
January 26, 2010
96
6.

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

Platform: Xbox 360
November 11, 2011
95
7.

Red Dead Redemption

Platform: Xbox 360
May 18, 2010
95
8.

Portal 2

Platform: Xbox 360
April 19, 2011
94
9.

Batman: Arkham City

Platform: Xbox 360
October 18, 2011
94
10.

Gears of War

Platform: Xbox 360
November 7, 2006
94
11.

The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion

Platform: Xbox 360
March 20, 2006
94
12.

Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare

Platform: Xbox 360
November 5, 2007
94
13.

Halo 3

Platform: Xbox 360
September 25, 2007
94
14.

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

Platform: Xbox 360
November 10, 2009
93
15.

Pac-Man Championship Edition DX

Platform: Xbox 360
November 17, 2010
93
16.

BioShock Infinite

Platform: Xbox 360
March 26, 2013
93
17.

Braid

Platform: Xbox 360
August 6, 2008
93
18.

Street Fighter IV

Platform: Xbox 360
February 17, 2009
93
19.

Fallout 3

Platform: Xbox 360
October 28, 2008
93
20.

Gears of War 2

Platform: Xbox 360
November 7, 2008
93
21.

Mass Effect 3

Platform: Xbox 360
March 6, 2012
93
22.

Rock Band 3

Platform: Xbox 360
October 26, 2010
92
23.

Guitar Hero II

Platform: Xbox 360
April 3, 2007
92
24.

Rock Band

Platform: Xbox 360
November 20, 2007
92
25.

Forza Motorsport 3

Platform: Xbox 360
October 27, 2009
92
26.

Batman: Arkham Asylum

Platform: Xbox 360
August 25, 2009
92
27.

The Walking Dead: A Telltale Games Series

Platform: Xbox 360
April 27, 2012
92
28.

Rock Band 2

Platform: Xbox 360
September 14, 2008
91
29.

Super Street Fighter IV

Platform: Xbox 360
April 27, 2010
91
30.

Dark Souls II

Platform: Xbox 360
March 11, 2014
91
31.

Halo: Reach

Platform: Xbox 360
September 14, 2010
91
32.

Mass Effect

Platform: Xbox 360
November 20, 2007
91
33.

Forza Motorsport 4

Platform: Xbox 360
October 11, 2011
91
34.

Gears of War 3

Platform: Xbox 360
September 20, 2011
91
35.

Far Cry 3

Platform: Xbox 360
December 4, 2012
90
36.

Assassin's Creed II

Platform: Xbox 360
November 17, 2009
90
37.

Bayonetta

Platform: Xbox 360
January 5, 2010
90
38.

Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter

Platform: Xbox 360
March 9, 2006
90
39.

Trials Evolution

Platform: Xbox 360
April 18, 2012
90
40.

Grand Theft Auto IV: The Lost and Damned

Platform: Xbox 360
February 17, 2009
90
41.

FIFA Soccer 12

Platform: Xbox 360
September 27, 2011
90
42.

FIFA Soccer 10

Platform: Xbox 360
October 20, 2009
90
43.

Portal: Still Alive

Platform: Xbox 360
October 22, 2008
90
44.

LIMBO

Platform: Xbox 360
July 21, 2010
90
45.

Mark of the Ninja

Platform: Xbox 360
September 7, 2012
90
46.

Super Meat Boy

Platform: Xbox 360
October 20, 2010
90
47.

Dead Space 2

Platform: Xbox 360
January 25, 2011
90
48.

Geometry Wars: Retro Evolved 2

Platform: Xbox 360
July 30, 2008
90
49.

XCOM: Enemy Unknown

Platform: Xbox 360
October 9, 2012
90
50.

Forza Motorsport 2

Platform: Xbox 360
May 29, 2007
90
51.

Metal Gear Solid HD Collection

Platform: Xbox 360
November 8, 2011
90
52.

FIFA Soccer 13

Platform: Xbox 360
September 25, 2012
90
53.

Rayman Legends

Platform: Xbox 360
September 3, 2013
90
54.

NBA 2K12

Platform: Xbox 360
October 4, 2011
89
55.

Borderlands 2

Platform: Xbox 360
September 18, 2012
89
56.

Call of Duty 2

Platform: Xbox 360
November 17, 2005
89
57.

Plants vs. Zombies

Platform: Xbox 360
September 8, 2010
89
58.

Rez HD

Platform: Xbox 360
January 30, 2008
89
59.

Castlevania: Symphony of the Night

Platform: Xbox 360
March 21, 2007
89
60.

Fable II

Platform: Xbox 360
October 21, 2008
89
61.

Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood

Platform: Xbox 360
November 16, 2010
89
62.

Left 4 Dead 2

Platform: Xbox 360
November 17, 2009
89
63.

Left 4 Dead

Platform: Xbox 360
November 17, 2008
89
64.

Dark Souls

Platform: Xbox 360
October 4, 2011
89
65.

Grand Theft Auto IV: The Ballad of Gay Tony

Platform: Xbox 360
October 29, 2009
89
66.

Fez

Platform: Xbox 360
April 13, 2012
89
67.

Burnout Revenge

Platform: Xbox 360
March 7, 2006
89
68.

Dead Space

Platform: Xbox 360
October 13, 2008
89
69.

Dark Souls: Artorias of the Abyss

Platform: Xbox 360
October 23, 2012
89
70.

Deus Ex: Human Revolution

Platform: Xbox 360
August 23, 2011
89
71.

The Walking Dead: Episode 5 - No Time Left

Platform: Xbox 360
November 21, 2012
89
72.

The Beatles: Rock Band

Platform: Xbox 360
September 9, 2009
89
73.

L.A. Noire

Platform: Xbox 360
May 17, 2011
89
74.

Peggle

Platform: Xbox 360
March 11, 2009
89
75.

Virtua Fighter 5 Online

Platform: Xbox 360
October 30, 2007
89
76.

NBA 2K11

Platform: Xbox 360
October 5, 2010
88
77.

Burnout Paradise

Platform: Xbox 360
January 22, 2008
88
78.

Shadow Complex

Platform: Xbox 360
August 19, 2009
88
79.

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3

Platform: Xbox 360
November 8, 2011
88
80.

Dishonored

Platform: Xbox 360
October 9, 2012
88
81.

Pinball FX 2: Marvel Pinball - Avengers Chronicles

Platform: Xbox 360
June 20, 2012
88
82.

NHL 10

Platform: Xbox 360
September 15, 2009
88
83.

BioShock 2

Platform: Xbox 360
February 9, 2010
88
84.

NHL 09

Platform: Xbox 360
September 9, 2008
88
85.

Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six Vegas

Platform: Xbox 360
November 20, 2006
88
86.

Super Street Fighter II Turbo HD Remix

Platform: Xbox 360
November 26, 2008
88
87.

Star Wars Pinball: Balance of the Force

Platform: Xbox 360
October 16, 2013
88
88.

The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition

Platform: Xbox 360
July 15, 2009
88
89.

Project Gotham Racing 3

Platform: Xbox 360
November 16, 2005
88
90.

Battlefield: Bad Company 2

Platform: Xbox 360
March 2, 2010
88
91.

XCOM: Enemy Within

Platform: Xbox 360
November 12, 2013
88
92.

Pinball FX 2

Platform: Xbox 360
October 27, 2010
88
93.

NHL 11

Platform: Xbox 360
September 7, 2010
88
94.

The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings

Platform: Xbox 360
April 17, 2012
88
95.

The Walking Dead: Episode 3 - Long Road Ahead

Platform: Xbox 360
August 29, 2012
88
96.

FIFA Soccer 11

Platform: Xbox 360
September 28, 2010
88
97.

Joe Danger: Special Edition

Platform: Xbox 360
December 14, 2011
88
98.

Battlefield: Bad Company 2 Vietnam

Platform: Xbox 360
December 21, 2010
88
99.

Need for Speed: Hot Pursuit

Platform: Xbox 360
November 16, 2010
88
100.

NBA 2K13

Platform: Xbox 360
October 2, 2012

Titles with fewer than 7 critic reviews are excluded.

Highs and Lows
Highest of the Month
  1. 67

    Out of Line

    • Release Date: Aug 18, 2021
    • Platform: Switch
Lowest of the Month
  1. 67

    Out of Line

    • Release Date: Aug 18, 2021
    • Platform: Switch