Episode Review: Game of Thrones, Season 8 Ep. 3

  • Publish Date: April 28, 2019
  • Comments: ↓ 9 user comments

Updated Monday 4/29

Game of Thrones, Episode 803: "The Long Night"
Original airdate: April 28, 2019 on HBO

Still image

Spoiler warning: This page may contain descriptions of events in this and previous episodes. Watch before reading.

For this final season of the HBO hit Game of Thrones, we are collecting reviews and impressions from professional TV writers for each individual episode, continuing with Sunday's extra-long "The Long Night," directed by Miguel Sapochnik. Check this site each Sunday night for reviews of the latest episode.

While we won't try to assign an overall score to each episode, we have grouped the reviews into rough categories based on critic enthusiasm, beginning with the most positive. Scores for individual reviews are displayed only in those cases where a reviewer has specifically indicated a score. (Those scores have been converted to a 0-100 scale when necessary to facilitate comparison.) "Recaps" are not included if they merely discus the plot details and fail to assess the episode's quality in any way. Click on any publication name to read the full review.

Great Extremely positive reviews

 

Dino-Ray Ramos
Deadline

Our patience was rewarded with an all-out brawl with some twists, turns and unfortunate casualties that have left our jaws on the floor. ... [Benioff and Weiss] know what the fans want and they delivered with this feature-like episode that included one of the most epic battles in the history of TV.

100

David Crow
Den of Geek!

As thrilling as any episode of television ever produced. ... “The Long Night” has the kind of existential dread of mass annihilation that is rarely seen on the small screen.

95

Laura Prudom
IGN

It delivered in ways we never could have expected. ... “The Long Night” is such a spectacular achievement in filmmaking - it certainly puts many of the MCU and DC movie universe’s climactic battles to shame, and could easily be measured against the intensity of the Helm’s Deep sequence in Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers - but I had to deduct points based on some of the contrivances of the plot.

100

Ed Cumming
The Independent

Game of Thrones season 8, episode 3 is a relentless hour and a half of battle that feels like twenty minutes, a series of sumptuous visual set-pieces linked by moments of tenderness. ... It is epic, gritty, profoundly silly, surprisingly camp – especially the smirking Night King, Darth Frosty himself – but in terms of spectacle, it is the equal of anything to come out of Hollywood.

 

Jeremy Egner
The New York Times

Sunday’s final clash was a masterpiece of tension and release, goose bumps and heartbreak, grandiosity and intimacy. It deftly mixed genres (horror, action, melodrama), shots and planes of action as it shifted from the chaos of the fighting in and around Winterfell to the claustrophobic terror of the crypts to the dragon dogfighting in the winter sky. ... It wasn’t flawless ... But in the end, despite the scale of the clash and the endless hype we’ve been hearing about the 55 nights of shoots that went into filming it, et cetera, the Battle of Winterfell actually exceeded expectations.

 

Verne Gay
Newsday

Yes, this was exhilarating and a spectacular technical achievement in its own right.

90

Josh Jackson
Paste

We got mostly what we all expected: en episode filled with battle scenes, the dead rising in the crypt and the Night King dying in the end. When you boil it down to “just when it looked like the battle was lost, Arya saved them all,” it does’t sound quite so epic. But this episode did everything it was trying to do. I will proclaim it to be very good.

90

Shane Ryan
Paste

Did I enjoy it? I don’t think so. It was a marvel, don’t get me wrong, but I can’t say I had fun, even though I absolutely couldn’t look away. I don’t even know the answer to the question of whether or not this was a “good” episode. I think so? The pure outrageous choreography of the whole thing, which apparently took 55 days to shoot, certainly paid off in terms of pure spectacle. But was it great storytelling or simply an exercise in provoking horror before a deus-ex-Arya reversed the narrative in a split second?

 

Sean T. Collins
Rolling Stone

Sequence by sequence, this thing was a marvel. Displaying a talent for combining the horror of war with the terror of zombie movies and slasher films, co-creators/co-writers David Benioff and Dan Weiss served up set piece after white-knuckle, seat-edge set piece. ... Still, for this show? An 80-minute battle in which zero A-list characters got killed, give or take a Mormont here or a Greyjoy there, is a rare pulled punch, at a moment when it seemed safe — right, even — for the audience to expect a knockout.

100

Michael Deacon
The Telegraph

It was a remorseless, punishing onslaught, not just for the combatants, but for the viewer.

100

Paul Dailly
TV Fanatic

There were so many payoffs during this eighty minute spectactular that it's hard to put into words how well it translated to the screen.

100

Hillary Kelly
Vulture

Game of Thrones abandoned itself five minutes into this episode, and I mean that in the best way possible.

Positive Positive reviews

 

Spencer Kornhaber
The Atlantic

I’m satisfied, but my eyes need a rest. No one predicted this twist: HBO spent millions of dollars on weeks of muddy stunt work only to have some production assistant drape Lady Olenna’s delicate muslin veils over the cameras. ... [But the] visual variability helped make “The Long Night” one of Thrones’s few front-to-back riveting episodes. ... It must be said, though, that much of the episode’s tension was bound up with nonsense worth yelling at the screen about.

75

Alex McLevy
A.V. Club

Honestly, a lot of what this episode did right had more to do with the scenes that surrounded the enormous melee than those hyper-edited clashes of swords. ... The blurry camerawork (quite literally at times) and rapid-fire editing meant that exchanges of blows that should have been viscerally thrilling were often muddied, good for capturing the mood but not much fun to watch.

75

Myles McNutt
A.V. Club

["Experts" review for people who have read the books] To be honest I didn’t really have any trouble seeing things or following the action, and I do think that there’s a scale to this thing (particularly in the landscape shots) that often took my breath away. But now that my breath is back, I’m struck by how much “The Long Night” seems repetitive as it replays in my head while writing, and how the end result revealed that outside of the characters who died, Arya, and those directly involved with Arya, there was a real lack of attention to character as the battle progressed, which lost itself in immersing us in chaos and failed to make that chaos as meaningful as it needed to be.

 

Todd Gilchrist
Birth. Movies. Death.

It’s not that seeing a character we love continue to live is dissatisfying. It’s that protecting him or her through implausible circumstances - like a long-lost relative who swoops in on a horse, then stays behind to nobly sacrifice himself - frustrates the tone and our general sense of the show. ... Nevertheless, the episode had some tremendously tense sequences, and some really, really terrific character moments.

 

Mark Perigard
Boston Herald

My biggest complaint about this episode: It was so damn dark. It was hard to see who was doing what. ... The Battle of the Bastards will still remain my top “Game” war sequence, if only because every bit of that awesome work was visible onscreen.

80

Huw Saunders
Cultured Vultures

The main criticism to be made of ‘The Long Night’ is nothing to do with the episode itself, but rather what it represents for the wider plot. The white walkers were always, always framed as the main antagonists, with the squabbling over the Iron Throne being a distraction. ... What I can’t help but take from the war against the dead being wrapped up quite so soon, is the idea that the Night King simply hasn’t tested as well as a villain as Cersei has.

80

James White
Empire

While a sustained serving of slashing, stabbing, charging and killing could have rendered the viewer numb, the GOT team fended that off by zigging and zagging all over the place and changing up the tone for several different sections. ... Were one or two of the last-second saves a tad convenient? Sure, but the drama was more than enough to make up for that.

 

James Hibberd
Entertainment Weekly

A hugely suspenseful and intense 82 minutes of action and thrills. ... This was TV’s most relentless and mammoth battle ever, a super-sized series of setpieces that never wore out its welcome and generated constant dread and nerve-wracking suspense.

 

Eammon Jacobs
Flickering Myth

The Battle of Winterfell is a visual treat for fans, mixing the epic battle genre with the terrifying zombie horror of the Wights.

83

Liz Shannon Miller
IndieWire

However, while there was literally no moment of the episode that wasn’t devoted to the battle, what’s fascinating about “The Long Night” is how it seems to take its time with the action, to some degree. It’s hardly a roller coaster ride, but that’s actually why this might be one of the better battle-focused episodes of “Game of Thrones” to date; it makes every moment of dread feel truly lived-in, lets each character beat scattered between the battles sink in.

 

Rob Bricken
io9

Somehow, this incredibly major episode doesn’t feel quite as satisfying as it should. ... But rest assured, I was on the edge of my seat just like the rest of you for the entirety of “The Long Night,” completely absorbed by the battle on the screen.

 

Anna Leszkiewicz
The New Statesman

Last night’s episode was an excruciating exercise in audience torture – all episode, our favourite characters were dangled over the precipice of certain death. Fighting on the front lines, Sam, Brienne, Jaime, Dany, and Jon were seconds away from a grim end every time they appeared on screen. But inexplicably, and despite all this build up, none of the key characters died. Some will no doubt see this as a cheap, audience-pleasing cop-out.

 

Ellen Gray
Philadelphia Inquirer

With three episodes to go, I’m not entirely sure what does matter to Game of Thrones, which appears to have dispatched with the existential threat and is ready to head back to the competition to see who’ll be in charge of Westeros. Which is fine -- it’s called Game of Thrones, after all -- but I guess I thought preventing the world from being overrun by the icy dead this might require more than one battle. Certainly more than one young woman. Not that the one battle and one young woman weren’t plenty. I’m exhausted just thinking about what went into this episode that I could barely see so much of.

 

Anne Cohen
Refinery29

The lighting in this episode was exceptionally beautiful, highlighting shadows and light in an intricate dance of snow and fire. The problem is that it also made it very difficult to see.

 

Mike Hogan
Vanity Fair

Sure, there’s plenty to quibble with. But let’s start by acknowledging that it’s rare, exciting, and pretty cool to see a group of professionals at the top of their game take a swing this big and more or less connect.

 

Daniel D'Addario
Variety

In its exuberantly nihilistic willingness to push past the point of viewer discomfort — building from a starting point of extreme intensity to an exhausted, burnt-out stagger towards the finish line — the episode stands in as the ultimate representative of one of the ways “Game of Thrones” has seen itself, as the staging-ground for ultra-violent action whose stakes are the fate of the world. But that’s not the only “Thrones” that exists. And, indeed, there are to be three more episodes of some other series, one in which the series’s most existentially pressing question, the fate of the world in the face of the encroaching Night King, has been settled. ... That’s why what may be the passing of one “Thrones” era is as exciting as it is — more exciting, certainly, than much of an episode that tended to spare any top-billed character, preserving the ensemble but reducing the stakes as the viewer got wise to what was going on.

Mixed Mixed/so-so reviews

 

Lenika Cruz
The Atlantic

I think “The Long Night” is an episode Thrones fans will argue about forever. ... “The Long Night” left me with mixed feelings that leaned toward disappointment and some confusion. On the one hand, I’m very open to the show getting back to the old power plays by people who don’t just want to annihilate the whole world. On the other hand, I’m deeply skeptical about how good the plotting and dialogue will be if Thrones fully goes that route.

 

David Sims
The Atlantic

The Night King is a real bore. ... I’m glad the story can make its way south again, where the sun shines and the action is a little easier to follow.

60

Stephen Kelly
BBC

The direction and cutting makes events frenzied, scrappy and yes, due to the lack of lighting, difficult to follow – a clever visual articulation of how this fight would really feel. This is an admirable artistic choice in theory, but after a while it starts to translate as tiresome, incomprehensible noise.

 

Andrew Bloom
Consequence of Sound

“The Long Night” can’t help but feel like something of a disappointment. It would be difficult, if not impossible, for a confrontation the series has been hyping up since its very first episode to ever fully live up to expectations. And yet, even judged on its own terms, the long-gestating Battle for Winterfell is difficult to follow, occasionally even impossible to discern, and ends the most existential threat the series has built up over the course of its run with a “one good hit kills them all” solution that feels more than a little cheap.

 

Barry Hertz
The Globe and Mail

A ridiculously intense, enormously brutal, delightfully captivating and kinda-sorta-sorry-but-it’s-true frustrating creation. ... Sunday night’s episode was a powerhouse of a thing, a vicious and delirious ride. But it was not without its many moments of, “Um, what?”

 

James Poniewozik
The New York Times

in a battle whose length and phantasmagoria befit a prog-rock double album, it reduced a climax eight years in the making to an inky, ill-defined scrum of beards and bones. ... “The Long Night” did its talking through image. Too often, what it had to say was mumblemurmurmumble. But there were also images that absolutely sang. And those were scenes that used the darkness to a purpose — not as a shroud, but as a physical presence. ... The battle began with life vanishing into the pitiless dark; it ended with life desperately leaping out of it. It’s too bad we couldn’t see more of what transpired in between.

 

Christopher Hooton
NME

The production design, choreography and VFX was, of course, terrific, but done a disservice by dizzying editing, insufficient lighting and never-ending so much fire. I get it, war is disorientating and if you’re in the middle of it you probably have no idea what is going on and who is friend or foe, but as viewer I didn’t feel immersed in the action but rather a confused spectator. ... HBO flung a trebuchet full of money at this episode, and yet it somehow didn’t inspire the awe of ‘Hardhome’ or the ‘Battle of the Bastards’, or even Daenerys’s attack on the loot train in ‘The Spoils of War’.

 

Jacob Hall
Slashfilm

Here is it is. The biggest battle in Game of Thrones history. And it was a huge letdown. But does the failure of big action mean “The Long Night” itself was a total failure? Not necessarily. Because nestled in that murky brawl were scenes of sublime beauty, unforgettable misery, and triumph that has been years in the making. ... Ultimately, the episode’s attempts to create chaos result in actual, unwatchable chaos, 90 minutes of television that are bizarrely incompetent for a series that has otherwise been so magnificently shot for nearly a decade. ... When the chaos takes a break, “The Long Night” is actually a damn solid episode of Game of Thrones painfully stretched around a lousy battle.

 

Judy Berman
Time

In one sense, “The Long Night” succeeded: It looked gorgeous. ... Yet for a feature-length action sequence that Game of Thrones has been foreshadowing since the series premiere, it felt strangely anticlimactic.... Season 8 has now essentially spent three of its last episodes on fan service ... That isn’t just lazy, predictable writing; it’s a betrayal of what made George R.R. Martin’s epic so great.

 

Kelly Lawler
USA Today

There was beauty and brilliance in "The Long Night," from the fire motif to Sansa and Tyrion's moments to its exceptional score. But it was also disappointing. The scenes were often so dark that it was impossible to see the action unless it happened to include fire (thanks a bunch, Drogon and Melisandre). The editing was sloppy at times, and it was hard to tell who was where and how they got there. And despite the high death count, most of our major characters still made it out alive, an illogical outcome considering the enemy.

 

Caroline Framke
Variety

The show spent so long convincing its viewers and protagonists alike that the war between the living and the dead was the ultimate conflict that ending it halfway through the season is as jarring as it is anticlimactic. ... This, plus the fact that not a single major death in “The Long Night” was at all narratively shocking, shows how much “Game of Thrones” has lost its handle on raising the stakes like it once did so well.

 

Todd VanDerWerff
Vox

It’s filled with thrilling moments, last-second heroics, and characters escaping death by the skin of their teeth. It’s also frequently completely incomprehensible. ... It also creates a situation where Game of Thrones essentially has to reboot itself with three episodes left in its run. ... I was enraptured by long swathes of it, frustrated by other long swathes of it, and deeply confused by certain parts.

Poor Negative reviews

 

Michael Rougeau
GameSpot

Game of Thrones has never been straightforward--until now. ... The battle with the dead is over, the Night King is defeated, and the forces of the living are victorious. And it happened in the least inventive, most predictable way imaginable. ... There's no catharsis or payoff in anything that happened in "The Long Night."

 

Scott Meslow
GQ

And maybe Game of Thrones was just too good at setting the bar that high—because man, is "The Long Night" a letdown. ... The White Walkers have always been unquestionably evil, which is the same thing as being unquestionably boring. And in the face of that evil, every character we care about has become unquestionably good, which is the same thing as being unquestionably boring. ... After almost 70 episodes of buildup: Is that all there is?

 

Michael Walsh
Nerdist

If you have invested in the history and lore behind the story, it was an anti-climactic end that didn't invert fantasy tropes in classic George R.R. Martin style. ... Arya killing the Night King was amazing to behold, but it felt somewhat hollow without payoff to the story's history.

 

Alan Sepinwall
Rolling Stone

The early portions of the episode were a visual nightmare. ... If the war with the army of the dead was just meant as misdirection for the real final fight, then the least it could have given us was better spectacle than most of what “The Long Night” had to offer.

 

Emma Stefansky
Thrillist

There were lots of cool moments -- Beric Dondarrion's heroic death and the dragon dogfight above the clouds were highlights -- but the end result felt weirdly lacking. ... It's frustrating to be bored by big-budget dragons and undead armies and cryptic prophetic sayings, but the true threat, even after all the lore building and theorizing that went into building up this huge event in our minds, was never the Night King.

 

Alyssa Rosenberg
The Washington Post

The show seemed both to lose its way artistically and to abandon the moral and narrative nerve that made it a genuine phenomenon. ... At the moment when “Game of Thrones” seemed poised to plunge its characters into the event of the episode’s title, it stuck us visually and intellectually in the dark instead. ... I love “Game of Thrones"; more than any other work of art, George R.R. Martin’s novels and the television adaptation of them have defined my career as a critic. But “The Long Night” was a powerful, late-in-the-game example of how its showrunners and directors have too often mistaken the show’s weakest qualities for its strongest.

What do you think?

What did you think of Sunday's episode? Let us know in the comments section below.

< Read reviews for the previous episode (Season 8, Episode 2)

 

Photo credit: Courtesy of HBO

 

Comments (9)

  • efonsecajr  

    Loved it.

  • zoe90  

    I can't stress just how idiotic this episode was. Worst GoT episode hands down. I'm still shocked and angry at the writers insulting my intelligence. Arya is now some kind of superhero in a universe that shouldn't have superheroes.

  • LatinCritic13  

    I thought the episode was totally remarkable in terms of choreography and tension led by Miguel Sapochnik, but at the same time, I'm very divided on the second half of the show when it's more fan servicey than being original nowadays especially when it comes seasons 6-8 now. Either way, I am still enjoying it.

  • Estoniantoad  

    The episode built and built and the final was kinda dull. This series has gone from purpose to just cinematographic images and scenes. The little girl kills IT! Wow, this must be written by somebody else but G Martin, because that story line is as trivial as it gets. This series has been good because of an excellent story, but the last series is just buzz and no deep story behind it. Anyway - after all is said and done - this is still the best entertainment you will get the whole lifetime. Just don´t come to look for a purpose!

  • j_khiiabaniian  

    writers of the GOT why are you doing this
    you don't answer about How the dragon was pulled out of the water With that great chains
    and now you make a new question about Aria we don't know how Aria go there and kill night king
    this is a terrible episode of this amazing serial
    jhon go dance whit dragon
    How is it possible؟
    if they don't Explanation how Aria go there and do that it is very very disappointing
    I really hope the night king return and fight with a Real fighter
    if they shut the amazing soundtrack of the end part of this episode it is hard to watch

  • GOTsmacked  

    Are GOT's writers suffering from exhaustion or perhaps dementia? The story-line to Episode 3 of this final series was unbelievably simplistic, and the battle which took up most of the show was as chaotic as football hooliganism (what happened to battle strategies!?!). Much of the visuals are too dark and fuzzy to be sure what you are looking at, and though the dragon action was one of the best bits, it was too restricted and unimaginative to satisfy. The main characters all act like they have had the charisma bypass operation, and the general chaos leaves little room for nuanced developments. Key characters were killed off in such daft and dubious ways that it made you wonder whether the producers just didn't have enough money left to pay them for the last three episodes.Compared with the first two brilliant works-of-art episodes, Episode 3 was a cringeworthy belly-flop. Seriously WTF?

  • MarcDoyle  

    What happened to the Bran storyline? Did he have no affect on anything in this ep? (other than drawing the Night King out?)

  • nikburlak  

    Как вообще можно было снять такое дерьмо? Самая масштабная и дорогая битва в истории телевидения? Лучше чем битвы из Властелина колец? Вы серьезно!? 15 млн. долларов!? 2 года съемок!? Более убогой и тупой по сюжету и логике осады замка я в жизни не видел! Эта серия окончательно убедила меня в том, что 8 сезон по праву будет считаться худшим из всей кино-саги, а без готовой книги-сюжета современные горе-сценаристы ничего толкового написать не могут. Это точно не наши снимали? Очень похоже, что главными по "распилу" бюджета были Учитель и Серебряков)))

  • LamontRaymond  

    Other than the fact that the episode was WAY too dark - not in tone, but in the ability to see what the hell is going on - I enjoyed it.

New in Metacritic Reports

What Our Users Are Talking About

  1. /feature/best-of-may-2019 Image
    Best of May 2019: Top Albums, Games, Movies & TV
    June 1, 2019 - 1 comment
    1. KidScoobie : y'all doing the summer metascore predictions this year? Read »
  2. /feature/tv-renewal-scorecard-2019-2020-season Image
    2019-20 TV Season Scorecard
    May 31, 2019 - 1 comment
    1. Benny2 : I wish they included more kids shows - Sofia the First, Elena of Avalor, Arthur... Read »
  3. /feature/2019-cannes-film-festival-recap-winners-reviews Image
    Best & Worst Films at the 2019 Cannes Film Festival
    May 25, 2019 - 3 comments
    1. Justhetip : Im sorry, so you want the panel to reverse their unanimous decision they made because the director is a... Read »
    2. IrradiatedNun : Who are you arguing with? Weirdo. Read »
    3. Takeru : LMAO Parasite is the best reviewed film of festival by far. Just because Portrait of Lady on Fire has a higher... Read »
  4. /feature/summer-music-preview-2019 Image
    Summer Music Preview: 35 Notable Upcoming Albums
    May 23, 2019 - 1 comment
    1. eli_fjr : Chance the Rapper as a wildcard? haha. Looking forward to it. Read »
  5. /feature/game-publisher-rankings-for-2018-releases Image
    Metacritic's 9th Annual Game Publisher Rankings
    January 29, 2019 - 13 comments
    1. a900104 : Hope you guys have Metascore Distribution bar for major developers too, but good job as always! Read »
  6. /feature/now-streaming-on-netflix Image
    What to Watch Now on Netflix
    May 22, 2019 - 29 comments
    1. ultraby : Regarding the Store ULTRA. BY Six good actions we perform for companies Thank you for going to this page.... Read »
  7. /feature/tv-premiere-dates Image
    2019 Summer/Fall TV Premiere Calendar
    May 7, 2019 - 203 comments
    1. LigeiaTepes : Little Women: LA returns july 25th Read »
    2. tzr916 : INSTINCT on CBS premieres on June 30, not June 16. Read »