X
- T
- Iridium Studios
- T
- Iridium Studios
- T
- Iridium Studios
- T
- Iridium Studios
There Came an Echo
Released On: Feb 24, 2015
58
5.7
All Platforms
Metascore
Mixed or Average
Based on 14 Critic Reviews
58
14% Positive
2 Reviews
2 Reviews
64% Mixed
9 Reviews
9 Reviews
21% Negative
3 Reviews
3 Reviews
Metascore
Mixed or Average
Based on 14 Critic Reviews
58
14% Positive
2 Reviews
2 Reviews
64% Mixed
9 Reviews
9 Reviews
21% Negative
3 Reviews
3 Reviews
Sure, its story can get a bit incoherent, its non-voice controls are awkward, and there are moments of spotty voice-recognition, but the good greatly outweighs what little bad there is. If you’ve found yourself bored with all of the monotony and nonsense surrounding recent titles, you’d be doing yourself an injustice not giving There Came an Echo a shot.
There Came an Echo with its surprisingly effective speech recognition is pure immersion. But it definitely could be more challenging, offering more tactical depth and more content in general.
User Score
Mixed or Average
Based on 23 User Ratings
5.7
43% Positive
10 Ratings
10 Ratings
26% Mixed
6 Ratings
6 Ratings
30% Negative
7 Ratings
7 Ratings
User Score
Mixed or Average
Based on 23 User Ratings
5.7
43% Positive
10 Ratings
10 Ratings
26% Mixed
6 Ratings
6 Ratings
30% Negative
7 Ratings
7 Ratings
This was a really fun, unique little game. The voice recognition was a bit quirky, but your shields give you some breathing room if you have to say a command twice. I felt the early missions give you enough of a tutorial that remembering them during the later, more intense battles was easy. You could play through this in one sitting. My only complaint is that it feels too short and there is a lot of plot and not enough combat. As a result sometimes it seems like you are listening to the (very good) voice acing more than you are playing with the cool voice controls.
Report
PC
Certainly has it flaws, but the game should definitely not be measured on the quality of it's regular controls. It is clearly designed to be a voice controlled game.
I plugged my apple earpods into my headphone jack and it seemed like they turned into a mic as well so I didn't have a problem with the game hearing and understanding me once I got it calibrated.
It was short, but for such a fun concept, and something that is totally unlike anything else I've played before, it is 100% worth a playthrough. Story wasn't too bad either.
It would be awesome to see the game fleshed out more. Maybe more content in a sequel.
Report
PC
There Came an Echo is hardly a full-fledged commercial game. It is more like a cool 3-4-hour proof of concept which shows you that yes, you can make a good strategy game fully controlled by voice.
Voice control just isn’t an improved method of input over just pointing at something and making it happen, but the effort is a worthy one.
Feels like a proof of concept for a much more substantial, and refined, counterpart. [Apr 2015, p.120]
Switch off voice recognition in the menu and you’re left with a run-of-the-mill budget game that doesn’t have much to offer. [05/2015, p.72]
Though the plot is poorly delivered, it provides an appropriate context for the role you assume as the omniscient commander. There is an eerie sensation when you realise your PC is actually listening to you. Unfortunately, far too often, it simply isn't.
In an age when developers are trying new and innovative ways at allowing the player to feel more engaged with the game, and failing, There Came an Echo is a breath of fresh air, and a massive success on all fronts. From the first simple commands you give your cryptographer turned soldier, you feel a massive sense of accomplishment and power. You are the on in control. You analyze the situations, give orders on the fly, and watch as your team expertly carves a path through enemy soldiers. There are some parts of the story that feel cliche, and the voice controls aren't always responsive, but the accuracy I have seen from my time playing it far outweighs any minor hiccups, and is leagues above other games that implement similar features. If you have a decent microphone and $15, There Came an Echo is a must buy.
Report
PC
Saying commands and watching them happen on screen is really a magical thing. I initially had some trouble getting the volume of my voice correct (shouting's a bad idea) but once I did, I was managing orders with ease.
The voice acting is superb and the plot, though heavily abridged, is one of my favorites in indie gaming. Well worth the $15 price of admission, and with a larger budget, it could've been one of the games of the year easily. Though the game is short, I was left wanting more - an excellent problem to have, and one that I will be revisiting on higher difficulties soon.
Report
PC
The non-voice controls are indeed quirky. Much of the time you'll spend will be spent on identifying what controls will come up on a radial dial and in which position. It's not as intuitive as I'd like it to be.
Seriously if you do get this game, you really should play it with a decent (not built-in for a start off) microphone. Built in mics won't cut it with this one I'm afraid.
It looks fine for the most part, if a little unpolished in one or two places - particularly with the most notable being the non-synced lip movement with the characters when they are supposedly speaking.
Without a mic this game can be very unforgiving, whereas it's much easier if you're able to speak commands because it'll take much less time to chat than to pick out commands from a list you have no idea how it's going to come up on the screen.
It's ok, but I wouldn't write home about it, even if Wheaton is one of the voice actors in it.
Report
PC
Tried only the voice controls, because really, that's the only reason to ever buy this game. Voice recognition is buggy as hell. It requires you to have *exact* pronunciation with *exact* tempo, *exact* volume and *exact* intonation. If you have any accent you're **** If your mic is bad you're **** etc. Watched Total Biscuit's WTF on this game and boy this guy is lucky. Almost 100% recognition of his commands! I have trouble to zoom in and out, and moving my squad to Alpha 2 or Foxtrot 1 is a feat that I haven't achieved in several hours, despite a lot of trying and listening to its correct pronunciation. Hell, I have trouble to recognize Pause, Back or Options (menu navigation also accepts voice input). Freaking Back! How much can I **** up a word as simple as that?! I mean, of course I have accent, and my mic is some 15 bucks **** but just how much can you mess up words like Back or Apply? I have zero trouble conversing with english-speakers or using Google Voice even with that same mic. I wonder how could they do VR that bad when there are many excellent solutions on the market already.
Couldn't even navigate the training room, didn't touch the campaign. For me this game has zero playability. Perhaps I'll give it a try again when they add my native language support (I'm already awed knowing how bad its support usually is).
Report
PC
The game is full of annoying characters who all try way too hard to sound witty and yet there is no swear recognition, meaning one would get no response for calling Whedon's character a **** mentioning another VA's brother is a cuckold, or just swearing at the game because the voice recognition is spotty (there is a way to control the game without voice recognition but the game handicaps you by making the controls clunky and requiring a character to read off your command before your units act it out.
As for the game part, the game is only a few hours long and the combat is rather shallow with each of your 4 units having identical base stats and being able to equip two of four weapons (in addition to a weak pistol weapon) also the missions are heavily scripted affairs that leave little room for trying to be creative with the game's limited mechanics.
Report
PC
Summary A real-time strategy game in which the player assumes command of a small squadron, using an advanced voice recognition system to issue orders.
Rated T
for Teen
Platforms:
- PlayStation 4
- PC
- Xbox One
Initial Release Date: Feb 24, 2015
Developer:
- Iridium Studios
Publisher: Iridium Studios
Genres:
