User Score
Generally favorable reviews- based on 133 Ratings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 78 out of 133
-
Mixed: 11 out of 133
-
Negative: 44 out of 133
Review this album
-
-
Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.
-
-
Submit
-
Check Spelling
- User score
- By date
- Most helpful
-
Apr 6, 2011Yes very fun album and great melody i believe this is one of their best, DFA really great song and the River very great singles . fun energetic great vocals from JOel himself overall a cohesive album and i cant believe also for the reviews this one is even better than Cardiology
-
tenzingwApr 3, 2007heard two songs so far and they rocked....cant wait to buy the album
-
-
CourneytMar 29, 2007I'm in love!!! Could they be any better!?
-
-
Dec 22, 2013For all the good albums released in 2007, there were two dissappointments, Linkin Park's Minutes To Midnight and this. The lyrics are poorly-written and the sound feels more like pop than pop punk. If you like it, that's fine.
-
QuaidMar 30, 2007This album is amazing and fun to listen to. The songs are very catchy and I'm shocked the reviews have not been better. But that's okay, because it just shows us that reviews are stupid.
-
-
SarahAApr 30, 2007Earlyier good charlotte was better
-
-
JKMar 27, 2007So bad you'd think it was Panic at the Disco...
-
-
harveyQMar 29, 2007B-E-A-utiful!
-
-
AlexRobertsJun 14, 2007This is immaturity at its worst. Bands growing up is not the issue with this group... Thrice has grown tremendously, Linkin Park, 311... all bands that have changed and grown with good results. This band is for rebellious children who think that they know everything. Musically, these people barely know how to play their instruments.
-
-
fredriceJun 7, 2007They rock!!! Although this album is kinda forgetable.. I love the river a lot though
-
-
DAnAOct 8, 2007Listened to the whole album again and again cant get enough of it, once again most of the bad reviews are because its different just give it a chance and it bloody grows on ya. Best song deff victims of love.
-
-
qdajMar 22, 2007you may look around but ull never find better than this one !!!!!
-
-
SamLMar 26, 2007One of the best albums of the year//// for me to poop on.
-
-
DevinMar 26, 2007Horrifyingly soulless, contrived, and talent-free. Do people older than age 14 honestly still listen to this trash?
-
-
claudiasMar 20, 2007i really love this album :D
-
-
ScottRMar 28, 2007
-
-
bobbMar 29, 2007sweetness!
-
-
LLMar 29, 2007I cant believe they get better every time!!!
-
-
TPMar 29, 2007A Disgusting pile of rubbish, i pity my poor ears.
-
-
MichelleKApr 13, 2007Oh...gosh, what do i say. This album is really quite...bad. Only good songs for me are Keep Your Hands Off and The River. 2 stars for 2 songs
-
-
MichaelEssexApr 2, 2007Go buy a screwdriver for your ears, its cheaper and a lot less painful.
-
-
KathyMApr 6, 2007wtf!? so many GC haters!
-
-
JohnSApr 6, 2007I really dont think its as horrible as every1s saying...is this one of my favorite albums? no...are there awe inspiring lyrics? no...but there are a few good songs i dont mind listening to....
-
-
DonniebMay 5, 2007They make looking fake seem soooooo so easy!
-
-
Rosezanna=]BacchusMay 6, 2007
-
-
JuliaAstarinaJun 3, 2007
-
-
KyleA.Jan 20, 2008A brilliant, brilliant album. Never liked the band before but this is, I can't get enough of!
-
-
AnnaanneNov 18, 2007I like it.....a lot!!!At keast the most part of it....
-
-
AdemaRulezMar 21, 2007a shit
-
-
RalphPMar 26, 2007Stay away from this. They were crap then and they are crap now. No talent just bad music and awful lyrics.
-
-
JonathanDMar 26, 2007Just go by a screwdriver for your ears, its cheaper and a lot less painful.
-
-
CarlVMar 26, 2007This album is really good, but an elitist attitude towards certain types of music will blind you from realizing that.
-
-
mattwMar 27, 2007terrible
-
-
GreggMar 27, 2007You know, Joel and Benji aren't from the streets like they sing about. They grew up in a gated community and are the definition of total phonys.
-
-
andreahMar 29, 2007This is an amazing album, my little babies are growing up!!!
-
-
RQuinMar 29, 2007I don't understand why people are bashing this album so much. It's not their best but there's still a few really decent tunes on this album. It seems like so many people can't accept change. If they recreated their second album people would still be complaining.
-
-
MelsWMar 29, 2007I cant believe you people!!! Your so closed minded! ...your so blind to greatness, it makes me sick!
-
-
jerretaMar 29, 2007soooooo good!
-
-
ssMar 29, 2007love!
-
-
sarahbMar 29, 2007I just wanna live!!!
-
-
throrntondMar 29, 2007I actually liked it
-
-
ZapBMar 30, 2007Wretched crap.. good charlotte are the very definition of posers..
-
-
MattD.Apr 11, 2007Unlike with My Chemical Romance, there's absolutely nothing here to set them apart. Even the choruses aren't punchy enough. Very dull.
-
-
jonnybApr 17, 2007good Charlotte is baCk and they are shitter than ever.if you take pride and like listening to shit musiC then give the Cd a go otherwise stay a far away from not the lead singer girl but this so Called trash that is Classed as musiC
-
-
CSApr 23, 2007Good Charlotte et al are the very reason why middle aged people pass off modern music as crap. Why don't we give away all this radio space (which is only good for making cars crash) to decent bands like The Arcade Fire and Sigur Ros, and then people will realise that modern music is not all s***. Metacritic, I hope you'll have minus numbers ready if these wemos release another album...
-
-
knomiApr 24, 2007
-
-
KrisSApr 5, 2007
-
-
TheCriticApr 8, 2007Wow these guys are gay
-
-
DanMay 31, 2007
-
-
HHamsterJun 10, 2007Harshly Critiscised. 8 Crackers 5 Turkeys sums it up well.
-
-
PatRJun 12, 2007As a person who loves to listen to punk rock old and new.... i have no idea how any one could possibly classify these wannabes as punk rockers.. its so stupid because they are clearly pop rock crap
-
-
kylefJun 19, 2007i thought they wud hav done betta with this album, but hey im not complainin it's worth listenin to (especccially "the river")
-
-
jessical.Jun 20, 2007Best album and if you have nothing good to say about them then dont say anything.
-
-
BeelayMar 31, 2008If Johnny Cash were alive, he's kick the shit out of those Madden tools. The only thing more pathetic than this band is their fans. Talk about a bunch of empty-headed, superficial, vapid peons.
-
-
MattSMar 16, 2007This album is a welcome maturation of Good Charlotte. Good bouncy fun music. That's what Good Charlotte is all about. Much different from their past releases but one of the best albums so far of 2007
-
-
[Anonymous]Mar 26, 2007Will likely be in the running with the new Used album for worst album of the year. The lyrics are ATROCIOUS.
-
-
touchemallMar 26, 2007gross
-
-
KLNMar 27, 2007I have heard only one song from this album and that sucked so i'm pretty sure the rest will as well.
-
-
nathansMar 27, 2007haha, what did you expect? good charlotte has always sucked
-
-
JoePMar 27, 2007I've had bowel movements more creative than this garbage.
-
-
theTHINGMar 28, 2007Vile; venal; venereal. Sublime in its suck-age.
-
-
RobertTMar 28, 2007
-
-
LaurenCApr 17, 2007wtf are you people talking about gc is the greatest band ever!
-
-
hokMay 11, 2007great album!!!
-
-
MikeMay 28, 2007
-
-
BenjiM.Jun 22, 2007
-
-
MattS.Jun 25, 2007Makes a decent drink coaster.
-
-
JoelW.Jun 11, 2008While this isn't the most mature album they've done it is very catchy and does still have some songs that show depth. it is really catchy and i love take your hands off my girl and the river. good job good Charlotte! i look forward to seeing what you do next.
-
Awards & Rankings
-
Alternative PressGood Charlotte have become caricatures of themselves. [Apr 2007, p.175]
-
Their multiple piercings, shaved heads, and abundant tattoos have them labeled a punk band, but on [Revival], Good Charlotte... fall much more under the umbrella of 1970s arena rock and mainstream ballads.
-
13 tracks of Disney-channel-ready pop, buffed and Pro-Tooled almost beyond recognition--and it's not half bad. [Apr 2007, p.111]