Buy Now
- Critic score
- Publication
- By date
-
Mar 18, 2019Far from sounding like lesser cast-offs, the songs here are just as worthy as anything off those earlier albums.
-
Feb 5, 2019A compilation of 13 new recordings of past songs and covers, Mayonnaise--and its Hellmann’s inspired cover art--are as buttery smooth as the well-known dressing. The recording is as clear and intimate as a living room concert, which is a treat, as Deer Tick is one group whose touring has made them terrific showmen.
-
Feb 5, 2019Whatever way you slice it, Deer Tick’s “leftovers” are better than the main courses of many other bands. This compilation is an attempt to show fans a more vulnerable side of the band, the ones that would choose the mayonnaise.
-
UncutFeb 5, 2019It's generally a thoughtful collection: stripped back so as to not stamp on the originals. [Mar 2019, p.27]
-
Feb 5, 2019While Deer Tick enthusiasts will smile at alternate versions, fun covers, and the spare track or two of credibly considered new originals, the casual listener should begin anywhere else in the band's storied (and often great) catalog.