User Score
Generally favorable reviews- based on 13 Ratings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 10 out of 13
-
Mixed: 0 out of 13
-
Negative: 3 out of 13
Review this album
-
-
Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.
-
-
Submit
-
Check Spelling
- User score
- By date
- Most helpful
-
jasontSep 18, 2004A very, very good album. I'd give it an 8.4 if that were available. Lyrically the songs leave something to be desired, but melodically they are borderline brilliant.
-
-
JenNAug 7, 2004Really great record. I especially like "Sewn Up"
-
-
BrianHSep 10, 2004Great record. Favs: Sewn Up, Be Kind and Remind, Falcon Settles Me
-
-
ErinMSep 10, 2004Sounds like the Shins!
-
-
GregHJan 15, 2005Comparison to the Shins is appropriate, and I think I might like Rogue Wave better than the Shins - which coming from me, means alot.....
-
-
JohnCFeb 5, 2005Forget the Shins. This is so far superior to The Shins, and I like the shins. The album is one of the best of the years and give promise to what could be one of the next great band.
-
-
BrianJSep 15, 2004Wow, what a great album. I usually don't give albums 10's, but this one is worth it. This is a must have for fans of the Shins and New Pornographers. This album sneaks up on you. Very melodic.
-
-
markfAug 11, 2004This is embarrasing. Everyone here loves the New Pornographers and A.C. Newman. Well, I'd give all their last three albums about a 7. This sounds like classic 60s music from Left Banke, but with enough Elliott Smith and/or Shins references to not be too old-fogeyish. I hate it that I agree so much with some of these Bozo reviewers. Problem is this is a great album!
-
-
mattaJul 13, 2005This really is a great album, one of the five best of the year in my opinion. I agree with others who have said they are similar to the Shins but better.....they really are better, better melodies, better strong structure, better sound....just all-around better. It will be interesting to see if they can duplicate the brilliance shown here on their sophomore release.
-
Awards & Rankings
-
Alternative PressThink Doug Martsch fronting the Shins and playing the sweetest Carl Newman jams ever. [Sep 2004, p.124]
-
Some of his melodies are so easily memorable they make The Thrills sound like Rammstein.
-
Beneath the occasionally shambling arrangements and fuzzy overdubs, though, lie some great songs.