Sky Blue Sky
by Wilco
  • Record Label: Nonesuch
  • Release Date: May 15, 2007
User Score
8.1

Universal acclaim- based on 213 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 177 out of 213
  2. Mixed: 25 out of 213
  3. Negative: 11 out of 213

Review this album

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. sguy157
    Jul 26, 2019
    7
    If you listen to this expecting something like Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, you'll probably end up disappointed. But if you remove such expectations, you'll find a very solid album. Sure, it might not feel as grand or experimental as some of their previous work, and it does drag a little here and there, but by no means does that make this album bad or boring. It has a great deal of gorgeousIf you listen to this expecting something like Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, you'll probably end up disappointed. But if you remove such expectations, you'll find a very solid album. Sure, it might not feel as grand or experimental as some of their previous work, and it does drag a little here and there, but by no means does that make this album bad or boring. It has a great deal of gorgeous songwriting, with "Either Way," "On and On and On," and "Impossible Germany" being some of my favorites. Also, the guitar work is on point. If you're looking for a more mellow Wilco album, you'll definitely enjoy this one.… Expand
  2. Ricko
    Jan 8, 2015
    7
    "Sky Blue Sky" is nothing if not a cohesive and consistent record. Made up of reasonably straight forward country rock, the record is easy to like but hard to really love. Opener "You Are My Face" is my personal favourite from the record, bring late era Beatles (mostly "Abbey Road") to mind. In fact all the best bits of this album remind me a little of "Abbey Road". There is nothing quite"Sky Blue Sky" is nothing if not a cohesive and consistent record. Made up of reasonably straight forward country rock, the record is easy to like but hard to really love. Opener "You Are My Face" is my personal favourite from the record, bring late era Beatles (mostly "Abbey Road") to mind. In fact all the best bits of this album remind me a little of "Abbey Road". There is nothing quite as ear catching to be found after "You Are My Face". The title track is a sleepy, slow paced country number, "Shake It Off" tries to be interesting but ultimately fails and again suffers from going at a snails pace - we really didn't need 5 plus minutes of this. "On and On and On" starts of very well and draws you in but Tweedy never goes anywhere interesting enough with it that is worth following. "Either Way" is a nice, decent quality tune while "Impossible Germany" again starts very well but just cruises along. Its kind of the story of the record for me - enjoyable enough with some great ideas where the execution just doesn't quite come off as well as it could have. The whole album could do with a shot in the arm, a bit more substance and a bit more courage on behalf of the band. This could have made it a really great record. The last third of the record picks things up a bit to be fair - "Leave Me Like You Found Me" and "What Light" being particular highlights.… Expand
  3. j30
    Sep 22, 2011
    7
    Far from their best work, but still a nice entry into their already great catalog of albums. A really good summer album that you could sing a-long to around a campfire.
  4. TheDaveHimself
    Jun 30, 2011
    8
    A memorable album. Worth the purchase for "Impossible Germany" alone. Tweedy said the album is almost like a break from his usual lyrical wandering and he wrote it intended for his wife, which is apparent on "Please Be Patient With Me." I've heard numerous die-hard Wilco fans state their disdain for this album, but I think they're missing the point. There are some true gems on here. And ifA memorable album. Worth the purchase for "Impossible Germany" alone. Tweedy said the album is almost like a break from his usual lyrical wandering and he wrote it intended for his wife, which is apparent on "Please Be Patient With Me." I've heard numerous die-hard Wilco fans state their disdain for this album, but I think they're missing the point. There are some true gems on here. And if you've caught the band live, you know how much these songs come to life, regardless of what you thought of the record.… Expand
  5. WesM.
    Jul 12, 2008
    0
    Boring; major disappointment!
  6. BrainK.
    Jun 25, 2008
    9
    I love this album. The riffs and guitars are great. Tweedy has a terrific sense of word play. This is too artsy for the mainstream and corporate radio. Great job Wilco!
  7. JasonJ
    Mar 20, 2008
    4
    I have been a fan since before UT broke up and have been enthusiastically with Wilco through all their changes. It is sad to see them retreating into boring and at times even annoying territory. The new lineup is thoroughly lame. What happened to the band that made Summerteeth? This is the first Wilco record I have ever sold to the used cd shop. Lucky for them their new fan base is larger I have been a fan since before UT broke up and have been enthusiastically with Wilco through all their changes. It is sad to see them retreating into boring and at times even annoying territory. The new lineup is thoroughly lame. What happened to the band that made Summerteeth? This is the first Wilco record I have ever sold to the used cd shop. Lucky for them their new fan base is larger than their old one, if significantly more shallow.… Expand
  8. JuanF.
    Feb 10, 2008
    10
    Is simple, beautiful, intelligent, all great songs. I think is the mayor Wilco album. Just listen songs like on and on and withe light.
  9. LewisM.
    Jan 8, 2008
    9
    Beatiful and fantastic, though im hoping this album is one for jeff to have some fun and the next will be a bit more messed up! Full of hope.
  10. RonA.
    Nov 26, 2007
    9
    Their second best effort ever behind only the near perfect Yankee Hotel Foxtrot. The critics need to listen closer and more than just one quick time through.
  11. PabloG
    Oct 30, 2007
    10
    I love this record. Wilco's beautiful collaboration in sound truly reflects a vision unique to those who know the hard times in life, but stand firm in hope. This album takes me. Thank you Wilco.
  12. booms.
    Oct 18, 2007
    6
    its pretty good, but not as good as i was hoping from a band like Wilco.
  13. ClayY.
    Sep 25, 2007
    10
    I have owned this album since it's release date. Ws very disappointed at first listen. Appreciated it much more, and fell in love with a couple of the songs about a week after having it. Months have passed since, and I picked it up again because I was about to see them live. Not only has this become my favorite Wilco album, there is something about it, and where I have been in my I have owned this album since it's release date. Ws very disappointed at first listen. Appreciated it much more, and fell in love with a couple of the songs about a week after having it. Months have passed since, and I picked it up again because I was about to see them live. Not only has this become my favorite Wilco album, there is something about it, and where I have been in my life lately, that it has now officially become my favorite album of all time. If there is anyone who is at a rough place in life, I really suggest this record to make you feel better. So much understanding, and enlightenment, with just the right touch of rage to fill ones soul. I can't get over how incredibly beautiful, and stong the simplistic lyrics to "On and On and On. A song that really makes me happy to have experienced life, no matter what hells I have reached in my journey. It gives me hope for a life that will make it's mark be known. And "What Light" has such a Lennon quality that really allows you to celebrate the good inside us all that we fail to recognize because we find ourselves distracted with society, and lose sight of what is important: our own hearts and souls and feelings!… Expand
  14. adolfop.
    Sep 14, 2007
    10
    Amazing guitar creativity, easy listening, thumbs up.
  15. RickW.
    Aug 5, 2007
    10
    I really liked this album when I first got it but after seeing WILCO perform just about the entire album live outdoors under a full Vermont summer solstice moon in June I became a true believer. I have all previous WILCO efforts but this one is the best! Nels Cline is a great addition to the band and takes their sound away from country towards rock. All songs performed live were even I really liked this album when I first got it but after seeing WILCO perform just about the entire album live outdoors under a full Vermont summer solstice moon in June I became a true believer. I have all previous WILCO efforts but this one is the best! Nels Cline is a great addition to the band and takes their sound away from country towards rock. All songs performed live were even better than the recordings, and the energy in "Shake it Off" and "Hate it Here" played live made me appreciate these tunes even more on the album. Best album of the year.....to date!… Expand
  16. JerryJ
    Jul 30, 2007
    9
    This is a logical step for a band that never compromises or worries about meeting anyone's expectations but their own. I can't wait to see what they have planned next.
  17. SonnyW
    Jul 29, 2007
    10
    One of the best albums of the year. Also, maybe the top Wilco work to date. Love this band.
  18. SteveS
    Jul 19, 2007
    1
    It's crap.
  19. IlyaR
    Jul 19, 2007
    6
    "Impossible Germany" sums up the album pretty well: accessible, attractive riff and lyrics quirky and cryptic enough to be really good. But it's just not worth multiple listens.
  20. JimK.
    Jul 14, 2007
    10
    After two very experimental albums this was a perfect fit for the band who will never compromise their sound for the masses needs. Beautiful album.
  21. Glen
    Jul 8, 2007
    5
    So disappointed, I've listened to it over and over hoping it would sink in like the last 3 albums but it just didn't do it for me. Boring, cheesy, not creative in the least bit. The last two albums were timeless and I'm being generous by giving it a 5 because of how much I love those last 2 or 3 albums.
  22. JaimeP.
    Jul 8, 2007
    10
    best music of the century, so far. A few seconds of Either way or impossible germany are much worthwhile than the f*** discography of truly boring groops, i.e U2, !!! or those monkeys in antarctica
  23. Felix
    Jul 6, 2007
    6
    Disappointing; there are only about 3-4 songs worth listening to.
  24. NoamB.
    Jul 5, 2007
    10
    a masterpiece. not absorbed in 1-2 listens. *****
  25. ChrisB
    Jul 2, 2007
    8
    The indie-hipster rejection of Sky Blue Sky puts a spotlight on the hypocrisy and shallowness of much of the movement. Take the same album, throw in some electric background noise and a few not-quite-cohesive off-harmonies, the same people trashing it would be calling it album of the year. Sky Blue Sky is a solid album full of a lot of extremely strong guitar riffs and overall good The indie-hipster rejection of Sky Blue Sky puts a spotlight on the hypocrisy and shallowness of much of the movement. Take the same album, throw in some electric background noise and a few not-quite-cohesive off-harmonies, the same people trashing it would be calling it album of the year. Sky Blue Sky is a solid album full of a lot of extremely strong guitar riffs and overall good songwriting. It's not as good as Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, but what is?… Expand
  26. TonyG.
    Jul 2, 2007
    5
    what a pain! total lack of inspiration, sonic interest, songs. nels cline solo, somewhere on the 1st song, is marking the end of the album. and, probably, of wilco's career. too bad to be true.
  27. WoohooW.
    Jun 28, 2007
    2
    Boring. Mind-numbingly dull and shockingly uncreative. And this is from a HUGE, long-time, devoted, tell-all-my-friends-about-this-out-of-this-world-awesome-creative-no-one-like-them fan. ,,,I'm so disappointed.
  28. JTR
    Jun 28, 2007
    10
    Further evidence of pitchfork media's doubtful value (they gave this a 52) as a critical resource. This album, if put on a graph would show Wilco continues to climb to heights of artistic importance and quality rarely fantasized about by better known, better rated bands. Easily a top 5 2007 release, easily a top 3 Wilco disc.
  29. BrianH
    Jun 26, 2007
    8
    Tweedy Singing and Nels Kiline on guitar! It's like I finally have some 70's style artists to worship in my lifetime. This album may be a grower for some but the complicated simplicity of this album is what will make this, and all other Wilco/Tweedy work, stand the test of time. There is no Best Wilco Album, it's all about the amazing quality album after album that no other Tweedy Singing and Nels Kiline on guitar! It's like I finally have some 70's style artists to worship in my lifetime. This album may be a grower for some but the complicated simplicity of this album is what will make this, and all other Wilco/Tweedy work, stand the test of time. There is no Best Wilco Album, it's all about the amazing quality album after album that no other band has given to this generation.… Expand
  30. EricC
    Jun 21, 2007
    7
    Can be pretty classic stuff when they gather some energy. Unfortunately, this doesn't happen often.
  31. Paul
    Jun 20, 2007
    9
    If you hate this album, so be it, but don't do so because the lyrics, or music is "bland". The lyrics aren't as postmodern or flashy as the previous albums, but instead, like some of Roger Waters' best lyrics, they're clear, economical, and hold a far more substantial beauty. "Something in my veins bloodier than blood" has got nothing on "Mysteries we believe in, not If you hate this album, so be it, but don't do so because the lyrics, or music is "bland". The lyrics aren't as postmodern or flashy as the previous albums, but instead, like some of Roger Waters' best lyrics, they're clear, economical, and hold a far more substantial beauty. "Something in my veins bloodier than blood" has got nothing on "Mysteries we believe in, not dreamed enough to be true". And try looking up the complex chord changes to these songs and play them on a piano sometime and see how "easy listening" the music is.… Expand
  32. GarthG
    Jun 20, 2007
    10
    Absolutely Awesome in its Beauty, Simplicity and Complexity! A classic that just grows and grows on you!
  33. JohnN
    Jun 19, 2007
    10
    Brilliant songwriting, Brilliant musicianship. There best to date and I have them all. Dont' believe the bad reviews, it's from people who think Revolution #9 is genius.
  34. ChrisC
    Jun 18, 2007
    8
    This record falls in line with all of Wilco's records. Sure, it might not be as great top-to-bottom as Being There or Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, but it's further proof that Jeff Tweedy is likely the most important artist of our time. If you've written this record off after a few listens, you MUST return to it. This record, though seeming simple, is very complex and takes time. This record falls in line with all of Wilco's records. Sure, it might not be as great top-to-bottom as Being There or Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, but it's further proof that Jeff Tweedy is likely the most important artist of our time. If you've written this record off after a few listens, you MUST return to it. This record, though seeming simple, is very complex and takes time. Another great output from an artist who's beginning to enter the ranks of artists such as Dylan and Springsteen.… Expand
  35. Matthew
    Jun 18, 2007
    8
    Pretty ridiculous all of the poor reviews...why does music have to be "experimental" or "groundbreaking". Tweedy made it very clear that he just wanted this album to be a collection of straightforward tunes (watch the documentary that comes with the disc), and it is a superb collection of just that, great tunes.
  36. Adrian
    Jun 17, 2007
    8
    Not as experimental as their previous efforts but a solid effort none the less. Everything has been simplified and we're back to the alt-country roots ... love and loss
  37. EvertonP
    Jun 16, 2007
    9
    pretty songcraft, simple but direct and effective lyrics, tweedy's emotional storm apparently under control... what more can we ask for? a timeless album which makes us feel how good 70's soft rock can be if well conducted and composed
  38. SteveH
    Jun 14, 2007
    8
    Bought it last week, now I'm having problems taking it out of the CD player. On first listen it sounded a little mundane, by the third go around it was magic. Tweedy really is an artist with real vision, and the band is loose and tight at the same time, how do they do that?
  39. yourmom
    Jun 12, 2007
    9
    well crafted music..... It's hard not be pleased. Although i find it to be one small step back from A Ghost Is Born.
  40. JohnP
    Jun 9, 2007
    9
    Apparently effortless and deceptively simple, as are all manifestations of brilliance.
  41. Walton
    Jun 7, 2007
    9
    Sky Blue Sky lacks the astonishing diversity of Being There or the experimental flair of Yankee Hotel Foxtrot. Yet it contains some terrific songs. Both Impossible Germany and Walken are among the very best numbers in Wilco live shows. And for the sentimental, Please Be Patient With Me is very touching. The best thing about Sky Blue Sky is that it is a unique addition to the Wilco/Tweedy Sky Blue Sky lacks the astonishing diversity of Being There or the experimental flair of Yankee Hotel Foxtrot. Yet it contains some terrific songs. Both Impossible Germany and Walken are among the very best numbers in Wilco live shows. And for the sentimental, Please Be Patient With Me is very touching. The best thing about Sky Blue Sky is that it is a unique addition to the Wilco/Tweedy repertoire.… Expand
  42. KevinO
    Jun 6, 2007
    7
    Its a nice album, but everytime I listen, I'm left longing for a few punchy Wilco songs to bring us out of the wallow. One shouldn't be able to play a Wilco album in full at the dinner table. The album is definitely missing some offensive sounds and clammer that would ruin a dignified dinner party.
  43. StephenR
    Jun 5, 2007
    9
    Lyrically smart and musically inventive even though it sticks to the basics - yes, that sounds contradictory but that's the only way I can think to describe this album. Listening to it is a treat and although it feels different from all of the others...when have any of the others ever felt like on of their siblings? Listen to it with headphones and minimum distractions to catch the Lyrically smart and musically inventive even though it sticks to the basics - yes, that sounds contradictory but that's the only way I can think to describe this album. Listening to it is a treat and although it feels different from all of the others...when have any of the others ever felt like on of their siblings? Listen to it with headphones and minimum distractions to catch the intricacies and the inherent beauty - you won't be disappointed.… Expand
  44. brent
    Jun 4, 2007
    9
    sounds like what a john lennon solo album would've sounded like if he never met yoko.
  45. JonnyG
    May 31, 2007
    1
    Quite possibly the blandest thing ever put to tape.
  46. MattR
    May 31, 2007
    4
    Not good, not great, and not close to either. This album is so simplistic, it deserves simple criticism: boring. Sorry, but as a huge Wilco fan since AM, there is no need to convince yourself this is good. The band is allowed one misstep after so many brilliant albums. Let's just hope that is all it is.
  47. stuartp
    May 29, 2007
    8
    a couple misses: "what light " and "shake it off." other than that, a fun album. i like the texture and color of the songs and the sound quality/mix is phenomenal. tweedy's voice is sounding better than ever on this record.
  48. BruceG
    May 29, 2007
    10
    A set of beautiful songs. What more could one ask for? Each Wilco album stand-alone suite and this one stands just as well as the others.
  49. BenS
    May 29, 2007
    7
    Great album. Who says every album needs to be some experimental ground-breaker? Just a great album of great tunes.
  50. hughg
    May 27, 2007
    9
    I look forward to each new Wilco album with great anticipation, wondering what will they come up with next. This disc is certainly softer and more straightforward than recent efforts. Great heartfelt songwriting and somehow each of the bandmembers musicianship is more clearly and simply on display. Like everything they do- sounds great with first listen, only gets better with age.
  51. DylanS
    May 27, 2007
    8
    It's no Yankee Hotel, but Sky Blue Sky is the best thing Wilco has put out since. Amazing in it's crafted simplicity, this CD is banking on catching you just with the music. No bullshit experimentation, no adventerous 11 minute songs, not to say that I'm no a whole hearted fan of these things, but everyone needs a break.
  52. ChrisP
    May 26, 2007
    10
    Best album of the year. I dare someone to top this.
  53. RyanS
    May 26, 2007
    10
    I can't stop listening to it, its simply a great album. Its such a summer time album. Makes me want to sit out on a deck somewhere and just chat with old friends.
  54. DoritP
    May 25, 2007
    9
    it's like coming home. quiet, mellow, relaxing. all you need is a calm night, a long drive, and this wilco album.
  55. JamesP
    May 25, 2007
    8
    This is the kind of album I love to play on a Sunday afternoon cruising by the beach. Seems like Tweedy is really starting to move past the demons and addiction that were main themes of YHF and AGIB. Doesn't take much artistic risk, but they're good solid chops.
  56. BrandonR
    May 24, 2007
    9
    Upon third or fourth listen, this album is tremendous. Tweedy really cares about subtlety in songwriting, and pretty much every thing here is tastefully executed. It's much too organic and not groundbreaking enough for the hipsters, but that's probably why it has so much soul.
  57. ZookeeperFerguson
    May 24, 2007
    4
    It's brutal to even get through this album. Tweedy used to sound like his mind was splitting open. Now he sounds lobotomized. The world doesn't need any more warmed-over 70's FM junk.
  58. STEVEK
    May 24, 2007
    10
    Better than the REO Speedwagon of my youth!!
  59. MattD.
    May 22, 2007
    8
    First of all, this CD is not simplistic like some say. The song "You Are My Face" goes from a Simon And Garfunkel-like melody to a jam back to a Simon And Garfunkel-like melody. Many of the slower songs like "White Light" feel relaxing instead of boring. Wilco has come up with their own brand of soul. There's a bit too much jamming on the CD and the lyrics aren't quite up to First of all, this CD is not simplistic like some say. The song "You Are My Face" goes from a Simon And Garfunkel-like melody to a jam back to a Simon And Garfunkel-like melody. Many of the slower songs like "White Light" feel relaxing instead of boring. Wilco has come up with their own brand of soul. There's a bit too much jamming on the CD and the lyrics aren't quite up to Summerteeth or Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, but this is a great addition to your Wilco collection.… Expand
  60. JohnH
    May 21, 2007
    10
    Just a simply beautiful album
  61. PeteO
    May 21, 2007
    8
    While not as overall impressed with it as A Ghost Is Born, which I now consider their peak, I must say that this is definitely a fantastic album. I really love how loose it sounds and how it often feels like a band just having a great time jamming out. The guitar solos in particular are all well played and inventive. Wilco continues to impress as one of the best American bands of our While not as overall impressed with it as A Ghost Is Born, which I now consider their peak, I must say that this is definitely a fantastic album. I really love how loose it sounds and how it often feels like a band just having a great time jamming out. The guitar solos in particular are all well played and inventive. Wilco continues to impress as one of the best American bands of our time, and all time.… Expand
  62. Rushmore
    May 21, 2007
    9
    The perfect springtime album.
  63. matta
    May 21, 2007
    7
    I'm glad this score has gone down a little. Really, it doesn't deserve to be in the same ballpark as A Ghost Is Born (and certainly not Summer Teeth or Yankee Hotel Foxtrot). It is solid, but not great. I feel like some reviews I've seen have given good marks just because it is Wilco, and on the flipside, some critics have been extra harsh because it is not as good as their I'm glad this score has gone down a little. Really, it doesn't deserve to be in the same ballpark as A Ghost Is Born (and certainly not Summer Teeth or Yankee Hotel Foxtrot). It is solid, but not great. I feel like some reviews I've seen have given good marks just because it is Wilco, and on the flipside, some critics have been extra harsh because it is not as good as their last three albums. Just taking it on its own merits, and not comparing it to past work, it is, like I said, good but not great.… Expand
  64. DylanR
    May 20, 2007
    9
    This record offers less instant gratification than past Wilco releases, but it just keeps getting better with repeated listens. As it currently stands, I can't turn the damn thing off. You're hearing a first-rate ensemble playing some simple, yet elegantly crafted songs with great lyrics to boot. This has been the strongest release of 2007 so far.
  65. DaveC.
    May 20, 2007
    9
    This album reminds me of Dylan's domestic turn with New Morning - not so much in its style, but in its imagery from the ordinary responsibilities of life in your 30's and 40's. It's not as dark and tormented as the Yankee and Ghost albums, but SBS is a beautiful addition to the Wilco cannon.
  66. MikefromMaine
    May 20, 2007
    9
    Finally, the Wilco album that delivers on the promise of AM and Being There. While all that experimenting did produce some fine albums, everything from Summerteeth up until now, seemed to lack the emotion of their first two collections. Sky Blue Sky delivers simple and honest emotion mixed in with some occasional interesting instrumentation to produce the album that Jeff Tweedy was Finally, the Wilco album that delivers on the promise of AM and Being There. While all that experimenting did produce some fine albums, everything from Summerteeth up until now, seemed to lack the emotion of their first two collections. Sky Blue Sky delivers simple and honest emotion mixed in with some occasional interesting instrumentation to produce the album that Jeff Tweedy was destined to make. And the Nels Cline lead and lap steel guitar work really tops it all off. Maybe I am a biased early Wilco (and UT) fan, but this could be their finest hour.… Expand
  67. ChrisD
    May 20, 2007
    8
    Took me a while to warm up to this, but I've been pleasantly surprised. Add another consistently good album and more importantly another great dimension to the band's discography. Check out "Impossible Germany" if nothing else. On a related note, is it just me or has Pitchfork started to become a parody of itself? The more reviews like the Wilco one the less seriously I can take them.
  68. Nick
    May 19, 2007
    5
    Pitchfork may have a blindspot for avant-guardism (almost as large as RollingStone's for everything a Babyboomer poops out), but they nailed the problem with this lump of coal: dad-rock indeed. Tweedy should make amends with that white-rasta looney-tune that got tossed out of the band six years ago; Jay Bennett....where are you now? "This may be the best Eagles album the Eagles never Pitchfork may have a blindspot for avant-guardism (almost as large as RollingStone's for everything a Babyboomer poops out), but they nailed the problem with this lump of coal: dad-rock indeed. Tweedy should make amends with that white-rasta looney-tune that got tossed out of the band six years ago; Jay Bennett....where are you now? "This may be the best Eagles album the Eagles never made": True. Maybe I will gift this album to my uncle Bob.… Expand
  69. JasonD
    May 19, 2007
    2
    I was pretty disappointed in this album. After "A Ghost is Born," I was ready for a more straight-forward Wilco disc, so I was braced for the simplicity of "Sky Blue Sky," but I wasn't prepared for Tweedy to write such a bland, uninspired set of songs. This album never takes off, never really presents any hooks or even many interesting melodic ideas to hang onto, it's just lazy I was pretty disappointed in this album. After "A Ghost is Born," I was ready for a more straight-forward Wilco disc, so I was braced for the simplicity of "Sky Blue Sky," but I wasn't prepared for Tweedy to write such a bland, uninspired set of songs. This album never takes off, never really presents any hooks or even many interesting melodic ideas to hang onto, it's just lazy classic rock.… Expand
  70. William
    May 18, 2007
    10
    2nd best Wilco album, afterYHF.
  71. jDearman
    May 18, 2007
    10
    I admit, I didn't quite expect this. After listening to the whole album 6-7 times, I can't get it out of my head. This is not the album that I was waiting for, but maby it should have been. I love it.
  72. KellyH
    May 18, 2007
    7
    It's like mixing all of your favorite flavors of ice cream - but serving them warm. Tweedy seems most honest when his lyrics are delving into frustration, desperation, and chaos. This CD seems to be a collection of lullabys, by comparison. That being said, it's worth a listen. I'm sure that we will all be crooning along with Tweedy at the next concert where, hopefully, all It's like mixing all of your favorite flavors of ice cream - but serving them warm. Tweedy seems most honest when his lyrics are delving into frustration, desperation, and chaos. This CD seems to be a collection of lullabys, by comparison. That being said, it's worth a listen. I'm sure that we will all be crooning along with Tweedy at the next concert where, hopefully, all of the audience will stay off of the stage!… Expand
  73. madsl
    May 18, 2007
    8
    It is rather pathetic how some wilco "fans" have easiliy dismissed this album solely because of its "failure" to go further down the path of experimentation...whatever that is!? Yes, I too, was initially disappointed by this more slick approach, but repeated listens really open up these songs in quite a magnificent way. Side with the seeds; Impossible Germany and Walken rate among their It is rather pathetic how some wilco "fans" have easiliy dismissed this album solely because of its "failure" to go further down the path of experimentation...whatever that is!? Yes, I too, was initially disappointed by this more slick approach, but repeated listens really open up these songs in quite a magnificent way. Side with the seeds; Impossible Germany and Walken rate among their very best songs ever...the last minute and a half of the latter is a breathtaking display of true guitar interplay brilliance.… Expand
  74. brianf
    May 18, 2007
    8
    I've been listening to this on their website for a while, and heard a few of the songs done live on bootlegs for over a year. Didn't especially get into some of it, but had especially enjoyed Impossible Germany and Walken. I thought the cd as a whole seemed too mellow, not at all like AGIB or YHF, so kind of a letdown. But I also hadn't listened to it start to finish at one I've been listening to this on their website for a while, and heard a few of the songs done live on bootlegs for over a year. Didn't especially get into some of it, but had especially enjoyed Impossible Germany and Walken. I thought the cd as a whole seemed too mellow, not at all like AGIB or YHF, so kind of a letdown. But I also hadn't listened to it start to finish at one time. Just got the cd in the mail yesterday, it came with a dvd which I first watched. Today I put the cd in and listened to it through headphones start to finish. As someone commented previously, it sounds great as a whole, for me that's somewhat how YHF was too. Not all songs seem to stand on their own, but as an entire cd it all works.… Expand
  75. PaulL
    May 17, 2007
    10
    Taken on its own terms this CD is a masterpiece. After reading some reviews from "experts" it seems that Wilco must continue on its path of musical deconstruction in order to be relevant. I disagree. Sky Blue Sky is not to be judged on anyone's expectations of what a Wilco album is supposed to sound like. Take it on its own terms and enjoy Tweedy's vocals which are the best of Taken on its own terms this CD is a masterpiece. After reading some reviews from "experts" it seems that Wilco must continue on its path of musical deconstruction in order to be relevant. I disagree. Sky Blue Sky is not to be judged on anyone's expectations of what a Wilco album is supposed to sound like. Take it on its own terms and enjoy Tweedy's vocals which are the best of any frontman in rock today. Enjoy listening to a band. That's right, a band. Not a producer or engineer. Not only does that make me think this is a sort of throwback album; but when was the last time you played a CD and enjoyed the whole thing. Save for Love and Theft by Bob Dylan I can't think of the last time I enjoyed a CD so thoroughly.… Expand
  76. ChristiainZ
    May 17, 2007
    9
    Am I the only one who thinks this is a great piece of work? This set just ended on my stereo and I'm thrilled with it. On and On and On is probably the best ender to Wilco album since Dreamer in My Dreams, the opener Either Way is the perfect theme-setter, and Impossible Germany could be the best thing these guys have ever done. Toss in Hate it Here, Leave Me Like You Found Me and Am I the only one who thinks this is a great piece of work? This set just ended on my stereo and I'm thrilled with it. On and On and On is probably the best ender to Wilco album since Dreamer in My Dreams, the opener Either Way is the perfect theme-setter, and Impossible Germany could be the best thing these guys have ever done. Toss in Hate it Here, Leave Me Like You Found Me and the awesome Walken and you got a near classic set. Is there a downside? Well, is the Pope Catholic? So Please Be Patient With Me isn't great (Jeff, we have wusses aplenty in music. Don't become a card-carrying member). But one song on an otherwise very-worthy accomplishment? Do the math, folks. Get this before the cynics drown out the compliments this deserves!… Expand
  77. DaniG
    May 17, 2007
    10
    Three words: Nels f--king Cline. I've been a Wilco fan for years, and I think they finally found what they needed to take them to the next level. This is my new favorite Wilco release.
  78. tylerk
    May 17, 2007
    6
    Eh... too many people trying to convince themselves this is a great album. This departure to smooth-rock adult contemporary is not what the majority of wilco fans expected or wanted. Very few if any catchy hooks or memorable melodies.
  79. BradleyP
    May 17, 2007
    8
    A mature outing that wears well, and for me a welcome return to melody. I am one of those who found the noise and texture experiments of YHT and Egg Is Born to be low points, cheap shots from a band that knows better. I found Pitchfork's review to be especially off track and juvenile, they seem to be missing the point that one may use references outside the 20-something world to A mature outing that wears well, and for me a welcome return to melody. I am one of those who found the noise and texture experiments of YHT and Egg Is Born to be low points, cheap shots from a band that knows better. I found Pitchfork's review to be especially off track and juvenile, they seem to be missing the point that one may use references outside the 20-something world to create fun and engaging music. In this case, those references are rock and country albums from the '70s that still carry weight. Some pop music ideas are endlessly usable. I will say right now how much I enjoyed hearing actual guitar solos on this album - the indie obsession with "texture" leaves too many songs in monotonous grooves excessively controlled by the songwriter, while the old pop device of improvised instrumental breaks provides welcome change from the vocalist and forces the melody to be viewed in a different light. Nice work.… Expand
  80. Jfurman
    May 16, 2007
    10
    Annoying that critics are kinda panning this one. Back to roots, so that must mean they're getting old and stale, right? This one has more texture, intimacy, and satisfying meat to it than the recent more experimental ones. Best wilco yet.
  81. ErinK
    May 16, 2007
    9
    Tweedy proves that lots of textured sounds and esoteric movements in the music aren't the only mark of brilliance. This album is Wilco back to basics. it sounds more like AM or Being There than their more recent stuff, but it is, in no way, a step back. It takes beauty, focus and genius to say so much, so simply as this album does- and having Nels Cline on the guitar doesn't Tweedy proves that lots of textured sounds and esoteric movements in the music aren't the only mark of brilliance. This album is Wilco back to basics. it sounds more like AM or Being There than their more recent stuff, but it is, in no way, a step back. It takes beauty, focus and genius to say so much, so simply as this album does- and having Nels Cline on the guitar doesn't hurt either ;)… Expand
  82. CameronJ
    May 16, 2007
    8
    Like Neil young and Van Morrison, Wilco have never been interested in what type of music is popular currently. And like them, I think we'll appreciate that their music won't date like a lot of other current artists.
  83. hippophile
    May 16, 2007
    9
    I put SBS right behind YHF as their second best. "Side with the Seeds" is worth the price of admission by itself! I agree that this is a more easily acceptable/likeable record if you've been following Wilco since A.M. But if you got on the bandwagon around the time of YHF, I can see how SBS may not live up to your expectations. Thanks Jeff and the boys, this long-timer thinks I put SBS right behind YHF as their second best. "Side with the Seeds" is worth the price of admission by itself! I agree that this is a more easily acceptable/likeable record if you've been following Wilco since A.M. But if you got on the bandwagon around the time of YHF, I can see how SBS may not live up to your expectations. Thanks Jeff and the boys, this long-timer thinks it's awesome.… Expand
  84. HonestPanda
    May 16, 2007
    10
    One has to review this album for what it isn't and what it isn't. Many are disappointed that it lacks the experimentalism of past records like YHF, But who cares. As this records stands, its a beautiful collection of songs with colorful intricate arrangements that is meticulously executed. Its pure love
  85. R.J.Fernandez
    May 16, 2007
    6
    A little too polished for my taste, I would have liked a little more pop and a little more rock, but then Tweedy didn't make this album for me. "Sky Blue Sky," the first single is about as great a song as he's ever written. There are about four other memorable songs here, but the album sounds bleak and souless to me as a whole.
  86. [Anonymous]
    May 16, 2007
    9
    Phenomenal album. It is different from Ghost and YHF, but that is what they needed. They carried over the sound from Kicking Television and put it into album form. Yes, it is more chill, but still the songs are great. Not too big of a fan of "what light" but love the rest. If you can only check out one, "Impossible Germany" is awesome.
  87. TomJ.
    May 16, 2007
    8
    I've been a Wilco fan for 10 years and this band has sent me on a roller coaster of a ride through alt.country, Beatlesque pop, and noisy post-rock. I can honestly say I wasn't prepared for an album like "Sky Blue Sky". But after just one listen, not only did I identify it as a collection of Wilco songs, but an "album", a cohesive musical statement. It's hard to make a I've been a Wilco fan for 10 years and this band has sent me on a roller coaster of a ride through alt.country, Beatlesque pop, and noisy post-rock. I can honestly say I wasn't prepared for an album like "Sky Blue Sky". But after just one listen, not only did I identify it as a collection of Wilco songs, but an "album", a cohesive musical statement. It's hard to make a texturally scaled-down record such as this without great songs underneath. I must admit; after pouring over the two Loose Fur records, I really wanted to hear Glen Kotche come out a little more on this record. But the songs didn't call for it, and the performance of all the musicians proves the band understands that no one member is more important than the song. The record sounds truly effortless, like a band getting together playing the songs they like with people they like. Nothing is forced. Some say it's Wilco showing it's age; I think it's Wilco showing their incredibly tasteful musical abilities and the spirit of a collective that can survive all the guff and criticism this industry can dish out. Where do they go from here? I have no clue. Then again, I've never been able to answer this question and I'm never disappointed in the end.… Expand
  88. Dave
    May 16, 2007
    10
    Wos what a great CD! I've really been hoping Tweedy would return to the sound of the "Being There" and "Summerteeth" era, and my wish was granted. Don't get me wrong, I love YHF, and to a lesser extent AGIB, but I still feel Being There is their best work, though this new CD comes very close! Can't wait to hear the new songs performed live!
  89. steve
    May 16, 2007
    9
    gorgeous guitar work, this album will grown on you with listenings, short attention spans will find it troublesome, they have mastered their craft.
  90. cables
    May 16, 2007
    9
    A brilliant departure from the experimentalism that bogged down parts of "a ghost is born". It recalls the pop glow of summerteeth with an added bit of maturity.
  91. JohnE
    May 15, 2007
    1
    Really boring and generic sounding record. Son Volt's "The Search" is far superior.
  92. JohnJ.
    May 15, 2007
    7
    Some songs are just plain limp but there are some very nice moments.
  93. HarryH
    May 15, 2007
    9
    It isn't startling, but it is a grower. If you are a disappointed Wilco fan, don't give up on this.
  94. Aaron
    May 15, 2007
    9
    Lovely set of laid back avant-country (if music is actually capable of falling under that name), occasionally punctuated by prog guitars or Stax keyboards. Tweedy's voice sounds lovely, and I'll be damned if "Impossible Germany isn't the best thing they've ever done.
  95. Mike
    May 15, 2007
    9
    I've had the chance to listen to this album several times. After the first listen, I was very skeptic and disappointed. As I've listened on, like all Wilco's music, it's gotten better and better each time. I think this will be a case where a lot of people will whine about how mellow it is at first and then soon realize it's just Wilco evolving naturally and doing I've had the chance to listen to this album several times. After the first listen, I was very skeptic and disappointed. As I've listened on, like all Wilco's music, it's gotten better and better each time. I think this will be a case where a lot of people will whine about how mellow it is at first and then soon realize it's just Wilco evolving naturally and doing something different. Great album.… Expand
  96. Ben
    May 15, 2007
    5
    Some good songs, but this album is ultimately disappointing, given the continued growth and greatness of previous albums. Wilco have always had great slow and melodic numbers, but they've always been a rock band above everything else. They already reinvented the wheel a couple of times, so I guess it was time to abandon all the experimentation and put out a straight-forward album of Some good songs, but this album is ultimately disappointing, given the continued growth and greatness of previous albums. Wilco have always had great slow and melodic numbers, but they've always been a rock band above everything else. They already reinvented the wheel a couple of times, so I guess it was time to abandon all the experimentation and put out a straight-forward album of mostly vanilla songs. Hopefully they got it out of their system. This definitely is not the album I waited 3 years to hear.… Expand
  97. JonathanE
    May 15, 2007
    8
    This is a really mellow low-key album and a really enjoyable listen. It's really bolstered by Nels Cline's fine guitar playing throughout. It may lack the head-first experimentalism of the past two Wilco albums, but it makes up for it in its realism and heartfelt songs.
  98. ChrisDJ
    May 15, 2007
    10
    Amazing album. It is 70 rock at it's greatest.
  99. romanmc
    May 15, 2007
    9
    Typically solid. The middle of the album is the soft spot (except Side with the Seeds) but the first and last few tracks stand up to anything they've done before. Pitchfork's hatchet job (and anything in the 5.0 range is as bad as it gets because it says "boring") demonstrates the difference between Pitchfork and Wilco. Wilco has made peace with the fact aging is a part of life Typically solid. The middle of the album is the soft spot (except Side with the Seeds) but the first and last few tracks stand up to anything they've done before. Pitchfork's hatchet job (and anything in the 5.0 range is as bad as it gets because it says "boring") demonstrates the difference between Pitchfork and Wilco. Wilco has made peace with the fact aging is a part of life and personal evolution. Naturally, the music reflects this journey and may come across as "mellower," and more pastoral and seemingly more assured of itself. It doesn't make it less interesting because there isn't a kitchen sink approach to the production (i.e. krautrock beats, xylophone sections, etc...). It's what is real to them right now. Pitchfork wouldn't understand that because evolution for them means finding whatever hipster trend seems to be peaking, give it the papal blessing no matter how shite it may be, congratulate itself on how important it is to the financial wherewithal of said shite hipster trend, and go on oblivious to the fact that whatever drone band they fellated in their review speaks to the hearts of no one. That isn't evolution. It's a desperate attempt to hit the hipster fountain of youth when the truth is that no one in their 30s can safely spot trends before whatever it was already isn't trendy. Sorry to rant. Go Wilco!… Expand
  100. MikeW
    May 15, 2007
    6
    A dissapointingly dry Wilco album. Devoid of the lyrical complexity and atonal expirements of days past. This is Wilco airbrushed and pressure cleaned for mass consumption. Being the best band in America, there are still some gems on this record. However, the gems sit next to some of Tweedy's worst lyrics (Maybe you love me, maybe you don't), and the band's most boring A dissapointingly dry Wilco album. Devoid of the lyrical complexity and atonal expirements of days past. This is Wilco airbrushed and pressure cleaned for mass consumption. Being the best band in America, there are still some gems on this record. However, the gems sit next to some of Tweedy's worst lyrics (Maybe you love me, maybe you don't), and the band's most boring arrangements since their debut. Only Tweedy's gift for melody makes this album bareable; and he does treat us to some melodic goodies; The American Beauty-esque "What Light", the hypnotic piano ballad "On and On and On", and the lazy day hammock folk of "Either Way". This is the first time In their career Wilco has been entertainment; nothing more nothing less. This album is nice for disposable nap time music, or sunny day in the park, but ultimately it is too weak to be ranked with the bands past classics like Summer Teeth and Yankee Hotel Foxtrot.… Expand
prev
Page:

Awards & Rankings

17
#17 Most Discussed Album of 2007
50
#50 Most Shared Album of 2007

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
73

Generally favorable reviews - based on 38 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 28 out of 38
  2. Mixed: 9 out of 38
  3. Negative: 1 out of 38
  1. Amazon.com
    70
    It's certainly the group's most cohesive album in ages.
    Read full review
  2. Under The Radar
    50
    A very professional but almost inconsequential set... flat and ultimately uninspired. [#17, p.88]
  3. Observer Music Monthly
    80
    The closer you listen to the jazzy guitars, Beatles touches and easy, shuffling rhythms ... the more it transpires that Tweedy is simply allowing the songs sufficient room to speak up for themselves.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »