X&Y
by Coldplay
  • Record Label: Capitol
  • Release Date: Jun 7, 2005
User Score
8.0

Generally favorable reviews- based on 711 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 574 out of 711
  2. Mixed: 75 out of 711
  3. Negative: 62 out of 711

Review this album

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. JenniferW
    Sep 14, 2005
    10
    Why don't these critics get it? "X&Y" is just full of melody, flow, and rythym. And these people call themselves "music critics". This album..when all is said and done will be a classic..kind of like U2's Joshua Tree. I, like most Coldplay fans cannot comprehend as to why bad reviews are written about this album..it is simply great music..just shut up and listen. Oh by the Why don't these critics get it? "X&Y" is just full of melody, flow, and rythym. And these people call themselves "music critics". This album..when all is said and done will be a classic..kind of like U2's Joshua Tree. I, like most Coldplay fans cannot comprehend as to why bad reviews are written about this album..it is simply great music..just shut up and listen. Oh by the way...Chris Martin is a very underrated singer, that boy can sing oh can he sing.… Expand
  2. JasonS
    Sep 9, 2005
    10
    This is the best album that I have listened to by far. Its just brilliant it gets better ever time I listen to it, ColdPlay's best album that they have so wonderfully created.
  3. alecv.
    Sep 9, 2005
    10
    I've never listened to Coldplay before, but this Album is the best I have listened to in a long time. Listen to it on headphones really loud and it gets a whole new sound! I cannot understand it gets bad reviews. This is simply great music. Isn't it all a totally subjective question of taste and mood, anyway, How can anyone be in a position to trash it officially???
  4. sk
    Sep 8, 2005
    10
    As Paste magazine suggests, it takes commitment to listen to this album.....when I did, I WAS rewarded! Martin admits that his lyrics are no great shakes, but he feels the music and chords are exceptional...and I agree. As for his voice, I find that he uses that as an instrument. This is one of my favorite albums!
  5. RobL
    Sep 7, 2005
    0
    There is nothing worse than boring music, and Coldplay is bordom distilled. Perhaps the most absurdly overblown band in history.
  6. DarrylR
    Sep 5, 2005
    10
    This is simply the best album i have ever heard. A cocktail of beautifull songs mixed with a strange sense of darkness that i have not heard since Radiohead's Ok Computer. It sends shivers through your bones. Breath taking!
  7. AleksC.
    Sep 4, 2005
    7
    While this may be a very successful record, it doesn't quite mak sense with me. The entire album sounds like some old B-sides that got some touch ups. Way too similar to their previous work, it's hard to distinguish them as anything new. It is obvious their trying a little harder, but do songs like "Speed Of Sound", and "Fix You" make it sound like they've made much progress?
  8. Kenny
    Sep 3, 2005
    3
    This is a huge disapointment. The lyrcis are so crappy and they're all cliches (Every step that you take/Could be yourbiggest mistake/It could bend or it could break/ But that's the risk that you take). Pure crap! And the transition into a more electronic style is pathetic (prob trying to be compared again with Radiohead). They should stick with they're old stuff.
  9. EmilyM.
    Aug 29, 2005
    0
    I agree with Bob S. The lead singer sounds like someone just kicked him in the nuts. His voice is like nails on a chalk board and Coldplay's lyrics are cheesey and some just don't make any sense! Hopefully, coldplay will die out.
  10. FrancoD
    Aug 28, 2005
    10
    X&y is a cd very intersting, i recommend... ...the best Coldplay's cd... ...my song favorite is Fix You!! ...please Coldplay come to Argentina!!!
  11. MarcoD
    Aug 28, 2005
    10
    The Best Disc Of The World 2005!!!!.... for me...
  12. thewaterboys
    Aug 27, 2005
    8
    this album takes work to enjoy. i didn't like it on first listen but it kind of snakes around in your head and you keep listening to it. there are some absolutely brilliant songs on here like 'fix you' and 'a message'. my favorite track...right now...is 'white shadows', although i seem to find a new favorite song every few days. My biggest complaint this album takes work to enjoy. i didn't like it on first listen but it kind of snakes around in your head and you keep listening to it. there are some absolutely brilliant songs on here like 'fix you' and 'a message'. my favorite track...right now...is 'white shadows', although i seem to find a new favorite song every few days. My biggest complaint about this album is that i am always thinking this album COULD have been one of the greatest ever and it just fals a bit short. there are too many spots where songs just never build from a nice beginning...they kind of drone away and you forget you are even listening to them. i will say this: after the very first time that i listened to this album, the first thought that popped into my head was that the NEXT Coldplay album will be a instant classic. i still think that and i guess that sums up how i feel about this album.… Expand
  13. JamesF
    Aug 27, 2005
    3
    I usually try to provide a little more explanation than this when I reject a record, but this was just really really really boring. It doesn't really invite any further scrutiny. The second CD was better.
  14. NicM
    Aug 26, 2005
    4
    Not nearly as good as the previous albums - makes you understand why non-fans feel Coldplay is contrived and tepid. Still a playable record, but very forgettable as well.
  15. BernieG.
    Aug 25, 2005
    10
    This is Coldplay's best album. They have finally reached U2-like status with their lyrical content and musical styles. Best song on the album, "Talk" is also, in my opinion, the best song of 2005.
  16. Kimi
    Aug 23, 2005
    10
    Wow! I think those who critic this album might be crazy! This is by far the best album ever! Even if you might not listen to it on radio stations quite often.. X&Y offers great songs from the greatest band.. COLDPLAY!!
  17. BeckaF
    Aug 21, 2005
    10
    I am officially in love with this album... although in my eyes it doesn't beat Parachutes i think it's genius and i don't understand why people give feedback if they hate the album.. here's a plan if you don't like it don't listen to it and stop trying to ruin it for other people!
  18. BlisterfishCafe
    Aug 18, 2005
    10
    Album of the year...end of review.
  19. FloydC
    Aug 17, 2005
    8
    Very good chord progressions that rival the Beatles. The sound is not bland and the CD begs for me to play it again. Great lyrics and sound. Good love songs. What can I say!
  20. BobS
    Aug 16, 2005
    2
    If coldplay's head gets any bigger people are going to have evacuate from the island. This cd is awful. The coldplay genre is lame , unexciting , and dying quickly. Once Chris martin hits puberty then maybe the band will be able to mature.
  21. sassbullied
    Aug 15, 2005
    10
    amazing... genious...
  22. TFletcher
    Aug 14, 2005
    1
    I can sum up X&Y in six words: an imitation of U2 and Radiohead. John Buckland is the biggest rip off I think I've ever heard. He's just capitalising off a sound The Edge perfected over many years. This whole album is a load of boring shite. "Fix You" is the worst song of this year, by far. Don't buy this album, it's a waste of money. "Twisted Logic" and "X&Y" are I can sum up X&Y in six words: an imitation of U2 and Radiohead. John Buckland is the biggest rip off I think I've ever heard. He's just capitalising off a sound The Edge perfected over many years. This whole album is a load of boring shite. "Fix You" is the worst song of this year, by far. Don't buy this album, it's a waste of money. "Twisted Logic" and "X&Y" are probably just about the only good songs on it. If you want to buy some good albums, pick up "The Unforgettable Fire" by U2 (this is the album Coldplay have been trying to recreate on AROBTTH and X&Y) "Achtung Baby" by U2, "The Bends" by Radiohead, and "OK Computer" by Radiohead. These are actually GOOD albums. Don't be fooled by the imitators. Coldplay are nothing more than a bland version of U2 and Radiohead combined. Can't believe everyone's falling for the act.… Expand
  23. LiJiaX
    Aug 12, 2005
    10
    This album rocks! The songs there are just so soothing! Those people who says that it isn't good does not have any taste! Th song For You is so soothing that it makes you feel 'high' and makes you feel like you are flying! Very suitable to listen to during airplane flights! 10 Thumbs Up!
  24. johnh
    Aug 11, 2005
    6
    OK, but in the end unadventurous. It's amazing how quickly one gets fed up with it. If only they had let themselves go a bit more - "Twisted Logic" should be the point of departure for their next album.
  25. guy
    Aug 11, 2005
    10
    Brilliant,the greatest album i've ever seen.
  26. AJ
    Aug 10, 2005
    9
    It took me a while to get into at first. It wasn't a summertime album, but then I saw them perform many of th songs, and I got it. On the surface thses songs are deceptively understated, but with close listening, their similarities are peeled back to reveal layers upon layers of differences and beauty. The one swelling end does somewhat redeem it. Standouts include: Talk, Square One, It took me a while to get into at first. It wasn't a summertime album, but then I saw them perform many of th songs, and I got it. On the surface thses songs are deceptively understated, but with close listening, their similarities are peeled back to reveal layers upon layers of differences and beauty. The one swelling end does somewhat redeem it. Standouts include: Talk, Square One, Speed of Sound and White Shadows.… Expand
  27. AdnanA
    Aug 3, 2005
    9
    This is the only album of the year so far which has exceeded my expectations. Since the magnificent 'A Rush Of Blood To The Head', Coldplay have decided to modify their sound and the result is a fine collection of well written and beautifullly constructed tracks. 'Square One' and 'Fix You' are both spectacular and 'Till Kingdom Come' is a fine way This is the only album of the year so far which has exceeded my expectations. Since the magnificent 'A Rush Of Blood To The Head', Coldplay have decided to modify their sound and the result is a fine collection of well written and beautifullly constructed tracks. 'Square One' and 'Fix You' are both spectacular and 'Till Kingdom Come' is a fine way to end an album. With the release of 'X & Y' Coldplay are right now the best band on planet.… Expand
  28. BradR
    Jul 31, 2005
    10
    A great album. Don't listen to the negativity, this is absolutely gorgeous especially Side X. White Shadows and Square One are probably the best songs Coldplay have written so far.
  29. youssefm
    Jul 30, 2005
    10
    brilliant. Don't forget that 'A Rush of Blood...' took a while to sear itself on our brains. The same thing is happening with X&Y. Bring on No. 4 when you are ready, Chris.
  30. martymcfly
    Jul 29, 2005
    10
    A fantastic album from start to finish. Sure they are sticking to their formula, but I loved their previous albums and I love this one too.
  31. JonW
    Jul 24, 2005
    8
    Overall good album with many good songs that martin some makes sound different and each in their own way enjoyable. Although it did take some time i was pleased with the album
  32. abern
    Jul 24, 2005
    0
    They are being touted to be the next U2 of the new generation....thats correct...just like the veteran counterparts without any hesitation they could be their three albums and call it X & Y and nobody will see the difference...the same formula...grand, lush and boring...if they are a good band they should come up with good ideas than recycle the same shit. dissappointing
  33. Mike
    Jul 23, 2005
    10
    I love every song on this album
  34. KyleJ
    Jul 22, 2005
    10
    I had always enjoyed Coldplay's singles, but never really connected with an entire CD they produced. X&Y, though, is easily one of the best purchases I have ever made and a solid piece of work the entire way through. I'd say this is easily their best music yet, and hopefully is just a teaser for even better things to come.
  35. BenjaminW.B.
    Jul 21, 2005
    8
    Coldplay can still create good music, make a homogenous record and write lyrics with the same glorious, Buckley-esque sentimental drunkenness, but it doesn't stop where ROBTTH knew it had to. Some things are taken one step to far (an example: 'Fix You' does not carry on the legacy of 'The Scientist', it's just too pseudo-emotional), and for the first time I Coldplay can still create good music, make a homogenous record and write lyrics with the same glorious, Buckley-esque sentimental drunkenness, but it doesn't stop where ROBTTH knew it had to. Some things are taken one step to far (an example: 'Fix You' does not carry on the legacy of 'The Scientist', it's just too pseudo-emotional), and for the first time I see myself questioning some of the production. All in all, many songs seem to follow a formula, less seem based on the intuition of the band members. This is Coldplay trying to live up to grandeur - which never works, just ask U2. Not quite as easy to listen to, and lacks outstanding tracks, in particular the opening an closing tracks, which are no match for 'Panic'/'Everything's Not Lost' and 'Politik'/'Amsterdam'… Expand
  36. AndrewL
    Jul 19, 2005
    10
    This is one of those records that takes more than one listen. The first time I listened to it through, I didn't really get it all. It didn't seem as good as ROBTTH. But after more listens, I find it to be a masterpiece. Like it or not, this is the album Coldplay will be remembered for.
  37. PeterG
    Jul 19, 2005
    8
    It,s safe,no arguing ther, still very good. Chris Martin still got it. This one will be played for a long time to come.
  38. matti
    Jul 18, 2005
    9
    my favourite coldplay album yet
  39. tsuede
    Jul 18, 2005
    0
    worst album of the year . so boring . chris martin's not a good song writer . all songs copy of U2 , mercury rev and radiohead .
  40. MihaiV
    Jul 18, 2005
    9
    It grows on me every time I hear it. At first I didn't like it. But now I love it. That's becouse I gave it a chance. My favourite tracks keep on changing every day. Noy I like "Square one"/
  41. malJ
    Jul 18, 2005
    9
    I was going to give this ten, but i would give Rush ten and this isn't as great as that is, it's very good though, i was the same as another user, didn't really like to start with, but after repeated listenings, the songs have really grown on me, square one, white shadows, (love that guitar), fix you, talk, X&Y, low, (my favourite) and twisted logic, they are all quality I was going to give this ten, but i would give Rush ten and this isn't as great as that is, it's very good though, i was the same as another user, didn't really like to start with, but after repeated listenings, the songs have really grown on me, square one, white shadows, (love that guitar), fix you, talk, X&Y, low, (my favourite) and twisted logic, they are all quality songs and get better with every listen, great album!!!!… Expand
  42. chrisr
    Jul 15, 2005
    10
    This is 1 of the best albums i've ever heard and anywho has anything bad to say about it is terribly wrong(New York Times.)
  43. JonyV
    Jul 13, 2005
    10
    easily on my top 5 ever! unsurprisingly, pop snobs will dismiss them as a stadium band... but who cares when coldplay can release records so well crafted like this one? HUGE.
  44. attab
    Jul 12, 2005
    5
    this album is way too easy. the really adhered to a formula that would yeild immediately catchy songs and resultingly high sales. after having more than a month to digest this album, it ends up being rather flat and forgetable. i'd rather listen to all the artists and albums they ripped off.
  45. IraD
    Jul 11, 2005
    10
    Absolutely fantastic. I love everything Coldplay has ever put out, and this is no exception. The whole album plays so well together and is incredible. I loved it.
  46. CaretteJ
    Jul 11, 2005
    7
    Not as fresh that Rush of blood to the head. Not bad but not the masterpiece...
  47. JosephA
    Jul 10, 2005
    4
    Boring. No risks, no innovation, nothing new. I can't believe the critics fell into this trap.
  48. CharlesL.
    Jul 10, 2005
    8
    This cd grows on you, just like their previous. When "Rush of Blood" came out, I intially didn't think it as good a "Parachutes". When I first heard X&Y I didn't think it matched up to "Rush". But the more I listen to it, the more I love it. Only two week tracks in my opinion, the rest are pretty great. For those that complain this band isn't eeperimental enough, your This cd grows on you, just like their previous. When "Rush of Blood" came out, I intially didn't think it as good a "Parachutes". When I first heard X&Y I didn't think it matched up to "Rush". But the more I listen to it, the more I love it. Only two week tracks in my opinion, the rest are pretty great. For those that complain this band isn't eeperimental enough, your missing the point. If every band were like Radiohead or Mars Volta (both of whom I love) it would be pretty boring. They do their things. Coldplay does theirs -- and very, very well.… Expand
  49. ScottY
    Jul 9, 2005
    8
    This may be their best effort yet. While I can't hear any stadium-sized rockers on this album, there's real beauty in some of the songs. The album reaches a real peak in the middle with the songs Fix You, Talk, X&Y, and Speed of Sound. What really differentiates this album from their previous efforts is their willingness to put the guitar front-and-center with this album as This may be their best effort yet. While I can't hear any stadium-sized rockers on this album, there's real beauty in some of the songs. The album reaches a real peak in the middle with the songs Fix You, Talk, X&Y, and Speed of Sound. What really differentiates this album from their previous efforts is their willingness to put the guitar front-and-center with this album as opposed to the piano. It's just enough to keep Coldplay from sounding derivative of themselves.… Expand
  50. josephf
    Jul 9, 2005
    9
    JF: On my first few listens I was a little dissapointed in the CD. I really appreciated their first two albums and this seemed like a let down. However the CD began to grow on me and I really started to hear the music not listen too it and my view changed. The melodies and rythymns are strong and it may sound similiar to earlier works but they have differnt twists to make each song JF: On my first few listens I was a little dissapointed in the CD. I really appreciated their first two albums and this seemed like a let down. However the CD began to grow on me and I really started to hear the music not listen too it and my view changed. The melodies and rythymns are strong and it may sound similiar to earlier works but they have differnt twists to make each song it's own. It is relaxing thought provacative music. I understand it is not for everyone, but it is for me.… Expand
  51. camm
    Jul 8, 2005
    10
    a masterpiece.
  52. EljahS
    Jul 8, 2005
    10
    The best record since Ok Computer!
  53. sarah?
    Jul 7, 2005
    10
    this is the best cd ever and all the songs rock.
  54. JamesH
    Jul 6, 2005
    0
    X&Y = ZZzzzz very disapointed with this album it is sooo sooo boring.
  55. jamesc
    Jul 5, 2005
    4
    the uptempo songs are very good but the ballads are so horribly boring. i am a big coldplay fan and just saw them live recently but i just feel a bit let down by this. i have an awful feeling that this will turn out like oasis be here now. everybody claiming to love it initially but later realising that isnt really that good. the first two albums will stand up in time to come, it pains me the uptempo songs are very good but the ballads are so horribly boring. i am a big coldplay fan and just saw them live recently but i just feel a bit let down by this. i have an awful feeling that this will turn out like oasis be here now. everybody claiming to love it initially but later realising that isnt really that good. the first two albums will stand up in time to come, it pains me to say that this will not. i wont desert them though, they still have more great music in them if they just become a bit more imaginative.… Expand
  56. SimonP
    Jul 4, 2005
    10
    An album that is the definition of a grower - those who can't see its beauty simply aren't listening. Every single song a craker (especially live), but track 4 - fix you - a fantastic 'shivers down your spine' song when it kicks in.
  57. jamess
    Jul 4, 2005
    10
    this is a very very good cd and i can't wait to get it
  58. PaulH
    Jul 3, 2005
    6
    The third straight album of exactly the same thing from these play it safe brits. Still i can't give it too bad a review because I still think their a okay band, better then a lot out there and i'm happy that their a rock and roll band that's been able to find success now and days
  59. NoahE
    Jul 2, 2005
    9
    The main criticism many reviewers were making about "A Rush of Blood To The Head", despite rave reviews, was that Martin and the band still sounded too mellow. Coldplay have taken those words to heart here in this most guitar-driven effort to date, "X&Y". The U2/Kraftwerk-esque crunches drive a number of songs including the raw opener "Square One", "Talk", "Low" and "Twisted Logic" The main criticism many reviewers were making about "A Rush of Blood To The Head", despite rave reviews, was that Martin and the band still sounded too mellow. Coldplay have taken those words to heart here in this most guitar-driven effort to date, "X&Y". The U2/Kraftwerk-esque crunches drive a number of songs including the raw opener "Square One", "Talk", "Low" and "Twisted Logic" forward, while 80's techno blends drive the impressive "White Shadows". "Fix You" takes off where "The Scientist" left off, reaching a climatic point with the gospel-esque vocals chiming, fading off with Martin vocalizing as though he's preaching to the choir, making it their most empowered ballad yet. And the "hidden" track "'Til Kingdom Come" makes a stunning closer to the record, acoustically-driven and one of Martin's more deeper writes. It's forgivable that Martin may come off as schmaltzy and soft on some latter tracks of the record, particularly "Swallowed In The Sea" and "The Hardest Part". The record is more slickly produced than their previous efforts, and we have seen Martin evolve a great deal in his personal life grappling with the issues of family with Gwyneth and his daughter Apple, along with dodging tabloids. Whoever rated this lower than "Parachutes" (The New York Times) have already discredited themselves here. The more sensible argument is whether "X&Y" is superior to "A Rush of Blood To The Head" or not. I believe "X&Y" tops both their previous efforts. Indeed there's still room for improvement (let's hope Martin is non-pretentious enough to keep the band together and give it another try) but, ideally, "Parachutes" was like the musical blueprint to the band, with "A Rush of Blood To The Head" musical architecture in the making, and "X&Y" putting soul into what they have built from scratch.… Expand
  60. matts
    Jul 2, 2005
    9
    First off, people should except the fact that bands (especially ones that have staying power) change their sound and evolve from album to album. If they didn't, well where would the creativity be? X&Y is a beautifully crafted album that blends perfectly. Changing producers is not an easy thing to do, espeically when the last album was such a smash. "Fix You" is a masterpiece and First off, people should except the fact that bands (especially ones that have staying power) change their sound and evolve from album to album. If they didn't, well where would the creativity be? X&Y is a beautifully crafted album that blends perfectly. Changing producers is not an easy thing to do, espeically when the last album was such a smash. "Fix You" is a masterpiece and hopefully the second single to be released. While other tracks such as "The Hardest Part" and "What If? trademark Coldplay's sound. Well done and looks like this album will silence some critics as to whether this Brits have what it takes to take on U2.… Expand
  61. DennisM
    Jun 30, 2005
    9
    I really like this CD. It did take a few times to get use to it (being a veteran Coldplay fan). They do tend to fall the last few songs (kind of sappy Gwenyth songs). I do believe alot of the critics are trying to compare this to Parachutes and A Rush... but, you cannot. Just like you could not compare A Rush.. to Parachutes. They all have there place. I do however think that 'Fix I really like this CD. It did take a few times to get use to it (being a veteran Coldplay fan). They do tend to fall the last few songs (kind of sappy Gwenyth songs). I do believe alot of the critics are trying to compare this to Parachutes and A Rush... but, you cannot. Just like you could not compare A Rush.. to Parachutes. They all have there place. I do however think that 'Fix you' should have been put on the CD last. It would've followed the pattern they had created with the last songs on there prior CD's. This is definatley worth picking up . The first 9 songs on the album are worth it!… Expand
  62. JaysonJ
    Jun 29, 2005
    8
    Ostensibly, X&Y is a triumph. Every second sounds sublimely good, but sometimes that alone cannot merit greatness. The album lacks the poeticism that "Don't Panic" and "Yellow" lent to Parachutes and the Instrumental glory found in A Rush's "Clocks" and "In My Place." Martin's lyrics are unforgivably stilted. How could the line "The tears come streaming down your face" be Ostensibly, X&Y is a triumph. Every second sounds sublimely good, but sometimes that alone cannot merit greatness. The album lacks the poeticism that "Don't Panic" and "Yellow" lent to Parachutes and the Instrumental glory found in A Rush's "Clocks" and "In My Place." Martin's lyrics are unforgivably stilted. How could the line "The tears come streaming down your face" be written by the same man who wrote "I was just guessing in numbers and figures." Then again, why can't I stop listening to it? I guess the real tragedy is in how good it could have been. Twisted Logic is the CD's best.… Expand
  63. kellyc
    Jun 29, 2005
    9
    I liked this album right when I heard it
  64. RM
    Jun 29, 2005
    10
    this is an album that takes a few listens to really like. im not a huge coldplay fan, but i liked a rush of blood and thought id check it out. some of the lyrics are kind of lame like "i want to love you but i dont know if i can," but the melodies were beautiful and i coudnt get them out of my head. this is a great listen!
  65. HarryH
    Jun 28, 2005
    6
    Great in places, but nowhere near as consistent as the last album. Coldplay seem to have forgotten that you can't add layers of synth simply for the sake of it, and this is where the album's main flaw stems from - they've tried to cram too much into too small a space. The best songs, such as "The Hardest Part" and "'Til Kingdom Come", are often the simplest.
  66. JoshuaE
    Jun 27, 2005
    10
    This is an excellent cd! It is near flawless and very good quality music, possibly my favorite album of all time. Speed of Sound, Fix You, Square One and White Shadows are some of the highlights. Coldplay is now officially my favorite band.
  67. MorganC
    Jun 26, 2005
    3
    This album could be called "Coldplay Takes No Chances" or "Empty, Slice-of-Life Platitudes" and the the single that's a total rehash of "Clocks" is unforgiveable.
  68. DanB.
    Jun 26, 2005
    6
    I'm not a huge coldplay fan, but I did like their previous albums enough that I still listen to them every once in a while. Not all the tracks, but, most of them. And I've listened to the new one a few times and can't help but think that I won't be pulling it out, randomly, months from now. It's not bad though. A few songs off it I'll pull off for mixes, maybe.
  69. donf
    Jun 25, 2005
    8
    this album is as good if not better then the previous 2 coldplay produced.!!!!!!!!!!!!
  70. PatrickD
    Jun 24, 2005
    9
    This album deserves much better than its Metacritic rating. First off, the New York Times' "Look At Us Playing the Contrarian" review skews the results unfairly. Secondly, the critical reviews of X&Y tend to be either of the "it's too perfect" variety or along the lines of "it never soars like previous albums." As for the former, that's just a ridiculous "criticism" that This album deserves much better than its Metacritic rating. First off, the New York Times' "Look At Us Playing the Contrarian" review skews the results unfairly. Secondly, the critical reviews of X&Y tend to be either of the "it's too perfect" variety or along the lines of "it never soars like previous albums." As for the former, that's just a ridiculous "criticism" that doesn't even make sense. If it were not "perfect," they'd slam it for being poorly produced and would be only too eager to point out its flaws. As for the latter, like any Coldplay album, this has to sink in for a few listens. These are songs that take a while to get under your skin and sink their teeth into you. But once they do (and they will), they don't let go. This CD has been in constant rotation since I got it. A great, big, anthemic album as good as anything they've ever done.… Expand
  71. DerrickM
    Jun 23, 2005
    9
    This is a very good album, not a complete departure, but an evolution. While it will be compared to U2 and others, I see a possible lineage, perhaps unintended, to John Lennon. The melodies, harmonies, suggest an affinity.
  72. KR
    Jun 23, 2005
    10
    Neat Stuff ! Talk, Square one , A Message and Fix You are the highlights of this album. White Shadows sounds edgy in more ways than one . Go Listen..
  73. CurtisMc
    Jun 23, 2005
    10
    Amazing! So many rock and pop bands put out so much thoughtless crap. This is a refreshing change
  74. MariaP
    Jun 22, 2005
    9
    well I read most of the comments that were posted here and I also took a chance and bought the CD for myself since I am a major Coldplay fan. I listened to it and in my opinion it was great. whoever said that the more you listen the more you like it was right but I think that all their CDs have done that to me. Though it does have many cliches and isn't as great as Rush of blood well I read most of the comments that were posted here and I also took a chance and bought the CD for myself since I am a major Coldplay fan. I listened to it and in my opinion it was great. whoever said that the more you listen the more you like it was right but I think that all their CDs have done that to me. Though it does have many cliches and isn't as great as Rush of blood is..im no music critic but I do know what I like and I like this CD and for those who trash it, you are entitled to your opinion but do remember that everyone is different and everyone is not going to like the same things. there would be no fun in it and the world would be boring, not to mention a very 'outter limits'/ 'twilight zone' kind of place… Expand
  75. Thom
    Jun 22, 2005
    0
    Blender give this 100 and then give Foo Fighters 60 and claim they are dull, Blender, you really suck big time.
  76. lewekj
    Jun 22, 2005
    7
    zzzzzzzzzzzzzzz wheres the alarm clock? garners a 7 off the sheer power of 4 truly u2 meets oasis meets radiohead meets coldplay fantastic songs. a rush of blood to the head will likely serve as "definitely maybe" their "morning glory. uneven.
  77. DenisC
    Jun 22, 2005
    9
    This is by far the best album to date of Coldplay with some of their songs taking a new direction , the first sone on the album especially sounding very like U2 and that cant be a bad thing can it . The more you listen to this album the more addicted you will become this CD is one habbit i definatly dont want to beat .
  78. JonH
    Jun 21, 2005
    8
    I could accept criticism of this album like, "I just don't get it," or "it's not listenable." But I don't understand how people criticize X&Y for being a sellout album or overly pop. This is BY FAR the least pop album Coldplay has ever put out. So if you're a person who just can't get into music that won't make the top 40 then that's fine, this album is I could accept criticism of this album like, "I just don't get it," or "it's not listenable." But I don't understand how people criticize X&Y for being a sellout album or overly pop. This is BY FAR the least pop album Coldplay has ever put out. So if you're a person who just can't get into music that won't make the top 40 then that's fine, this album is not for you. These songs are devoid of the instant catchiness of "Yellow" or "In My place." Why? Because the songwriting and the production is much more complex than in the past. But if you give the album a few listens you will find that Chris Martin's uncanny and original sense of melody pervades, along with a much more assertive use of lead guitars, giving the album a sprawling U2-epic feel. The songs are slow but the guitar rhythm is fast so the songs have a perpetual motion to them that keeps things interesting. Listen more carefully! There is A LOT there.… Expand
  79. JenniferM
    Jun 20, 2005
    5
    Well, I guess the sales numbers prove that suspense and over-hype really do work. I don't know what Coldplay were thinking. The ballads on this album are sappy and the hard(er) songs never really rock. Very disappointing as I adored AROBTTH. However, the biggest weakness is the lyrics. Heart-felt is fine, but don't club us over the head with it. We get it! -- you love your wife Well, I guess the sales numbers prove that suspense and over-hype really do work. I don't know what Coldplay were thinking. The ballads on this album are sappy and the hard(er) songs never really rock. Very disappointing as I adored AROBTTH. However, the biggest weakness is the lyrics. Heart-felt is fine, but don't club us over the head with it. We get it! -- you love your wife and she's been through a hard time It will be very interesting to see whether Coldplay can get back what they've obviously lost on this one.… Expand
  80. DouglasS
    Jun 20, 2005
    10
    The best new release so far this year! Coldplay has an album that will stand up for a long time.
  81. KatyK
    Jun 20, 2005
    0
    What an ugly piece of work. Yikes!
  82. JimH
    Jun 20, 2005
    4
    "What If" and "Talk" are two tracks on this CD that actually stand up and say for the band "See? We CAN be good but choose to be sleepy and boring instead! Take that!" If this CD only had those two songs on it, I'd give it a 10. Too bad.
  83. OliverP
    Jun 20, 2005
    7
    Square One, Speed of Sound and Talk are great songs, but too many of the rest are mediocre, run-of-the-mill. A decent album, but nowhere near as good as Rush of Blood
  84. BenG
    Jun 20, 2005
    10
    best album ever, by the best band ever
  85. MikeK
    Jun 18, 2005
    9
    Excellent record
  86. jessp
    Jun 18, 2005
    0
    i love so much colplay but this new album is horrible i don't like because is too seem at them old albums
  87. BradP
    Jun 18, 2005
    6
    this album was so influnced by the record company it's not funny! Coldplay fans will pick and choose their song and take what they want. Although it still has a strong sinigle, a sloppy but loveable piano ballad and good starting (i.e. Polik) which all coldplay albums have had. It good but not that good and even more mainsteam then before. It so safe at times it's offesive. Next this album was so influnced by the record company it's not funny! Coldplay fans will pick and choose their song and take what they want. Although it still has a strong sinigle, a sloppy but loveable piano ballad and good starting (i.e. Polik) which all coldplay albums have had. It good but not that good and even more mainsteam then before. It so safe at times it's offesive. Next ablum be better but this album is great for the first few times ut will then is useless… Expand
  88. Jon
    Jun 17, 2005
    10
    It just keeps growing and growing on me. An amazing CD that keeps working its way under my skin!
  89. MarianoD
    Jun 17, 2005
    8
    Coldplay has done again a remarkable job. For those who do not like this album, I must tell you that this is not easy listening music. You have to hear the songs many times to start finding the appropiate sour to the songs. Follow my advice, hear many times, find the sour and you will see this album is going to be amazing to your ears. Enjoy!
  90. Amanda
    Jun 17, 2005
    8
    My sister is crazy about this bands music. But who isn't, right. I think it they are ok.
  91. MikeD
    Jun 17, 2005
    9
    This is for all the so-called Coldplay fans that listened to the album once or twice, then wrote a stupid ass hasty review. PUT THE CD BACK IN AND LISTEN. I can't stand it when people put down good music when there is soooo much crap out there. It makes me want to drink turpentine and piss on a brushfire-- AAAAARRRRGGGHHHH!!!!! Seriously- this album on first listen was a tad This is for all the so-called Coldplay fans that listened to the album once or twice, then wrote a stupid ass hasty review. PUT THE CD BACK IN AND LISTEN. I can't stand it when people put down good music when there is soooo much crap out there. It makes me want to drink turpentine and piss on a brushfire-- AAAAARRRRGGGHHHH!!!!! Seriously- this album on first listen was a tad dissapointing. OF COURSE IT'S GOING TO BE. What cd that you've been eagerly waiting for 3 years isn't? Continued spins will have you in awe of the beauty of this music. Keep it coming.… Expand
  92. AZAELM
    Jun 17, 2005
    10
    I can not stop listen the whole album since i got it, I think is the most remarkable job of the band.... specially Talk....
  93. damlak
    Jun 17, 2005
    5
    typical coldplay. not original and not different. boring
  94. michaelc
    Jun 16, 2005
    5
    I loved Rush of blood to the head but this album just never takes off. The songs run together alot and are just kind of boring. It's too bad.
  95. JessS
    Jun 16, 2005
    9
    I have never been a huge coldplay fan, i will not deny the intensity of their hits, (ex. yellow, the scientist, clocks etc.) I own parachutes, which i have never much liked and AROBTTH which i enjoy, but rarely. However X & Y is one of the top 5 records I have heard released in since 1999. i am floored at their ability to mix all aspects and create such a beautifully blended masterpiece. I have never been a huge coldplay fan, i will not deny the intensity of their hits, (ex. yellow, the scientist, clocks etc.) I own parachutes, which i have never much liked and AROBTTH which i enjoy, but rarely. However X & Y is one of the top 5 records I have heard released in since 1999. i am floored at their ability to mix all aspects and create such a beautifully blended masterpiece. Those disappointed incertain aspects of the album should attempt to see the final product for what is, a heart felt ballad album with phenomenal rhythm. I am truly floored.… Expand
  96. KeramC
    Jun 16, 2005
    4
    This album is a pleasing but easily forgetable listen. If you're looking for mindless, instant gratification, this is your album. If you're looking for insightful, well-crafted lyrics, avoid this album like the plauge.
  97. m
    Jun 16, 2005
    8
    Just like their first 2 albums, this one'll grow on you. I don't know exactly why this is, but oh well. Musically, the album is great, with a few songs being extremely catchy, and progression in their sound is noticable. The areas where "X&Y" gets its demerits are lyrics and number of tracks on the album. Lyrically, the album is not so great. Martin covered a more diverse array Just like their first 2 albums, this one'll grow on you. I don't know exactly why this is, but oh well. Musically, the album is great, with a few songs being extremely catchy, and progression in their sound is noticable. The areas where "X&Y" gets its demerits are lyrics and number of tracks on the album. Lyrically, the album is not so great. Martin covered a more diverse array of topics on "A Rush of Blood to the Head." All he writes about here is love, romance, and his feelings. I would have liked to see more lyrical diversity. As for number of songs, "Twisted Logic" and "Low" shouldn't have made the cut. The album should have been 11 songs long. Also, it just doesn't sound as fresh or as simplistically beautiful as "A Rush of Blood to the Head" did when it first came out. However, "X&Y" still delivers the goods. It's very solid and very consistent. And hey, it's still great, just not exceptional like "A Rush of Blood to the Head" was.… Expand
  98. danim
    Jun 16, 2005
    7
    martin says the band gave it thier best; i think they are experimenting with something new. after rush of blood, i guess i was hoping for an extension of that album. Put aside your preconceptions and listen, there are some real jewels on this album.
  99. JackW
    Jun 16, 2005
    9
    This album, though not at all experimental or demanding of its listener, is nevertheless sublime, passionate and without doubt the best thing Coldplay have ever done. I find it incredible that there are so many negative reviews for this album. Just listen to it a few times rather than once or twice before reaching an opinion!!
  100. IanC
    Jun 16, 2005
    4
    I kept fast-forwarding through track after track; the songs don't take off, and each seems more bland than the next. Two listens is all the time I can waste with this.
Page:

Awards & Rankings

2
#2 Most Discussed Album of 2005
13
#13 Most Shared Album of 2005

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
72

Generally favorable reviews - based on 33 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 18 out of 33
  2. Mixed: 14 out of 33
  3. Negative: 1 out of 33
  1. Blender
    100
    [Coldplay] have made their masterpiece. [Jun 2005, p.112]
  2. New Musical Express (NME)
    90
    Confident, bold, ambitious, bunged with singles and impossible to contain, ‘X&Y’ doesn’t reinvent the wheel but it does reinforce Coldplay as the band of their time.
    Read full review
  3. The Guardian
    60
    They have chosen to opt for the standard formula: it's elegiac, mid-tempo, stadium-friendly ballads all the way.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »