Carol looks for an apartment with Nathan and Debbie eager to help each other look for a place far away from their own homes.

Tom and Carol decide to formally end their marriage but are surprised when they both hesitate to finalize the divorce, sending Nathan and Debbie into a panic at the thought of their parents reconciling.

Nathan lands the biggest interview of his career with professional basketball player Metta World Peace, but when karma catches up with him, he risks ruining his professional reputation.

When Ray points out that Nathan has a history of being the worst wingman ever, Nathan embarks on a mission to be a better friend by becoming less self-involved. Also, Debbie and Adam disagree over what's best for their family's livelihood.

Nathan plans a series of special reports on the Pope's visit to town, while Ray is planning to go to work for the competition.

In an attempt to get Carol to be more daring, Kip encourages her to confront her former Central Elementary School work nemesis Miss Pam at the woman's retirement party.

When staging their church's annual living nativity scene does not go as planned, Kip urges the Millers to stage their own rival show. Also, Carol asks Nathan and Kip to put aside their differences as a Christmas gift to her.

When The Millers get a visit from their elderly Aunt Louise, they rally to help her figure out what her legacy will be when she worries that she hasn't left her mark on the world yet.

Will tries to date a teacher at Mikayla's school.