Amazing, sensitive.

Sick and twisted. If you are a heterosexual male, save your money for anything else.

The movie haunts you afterwards. Achingly beautiful. It left me unfulfilled but in a good way. If that makes sense. It is a wonderful adaptation of a simple but powerful story. You don't have to like these characters but hopefully you have enough humanity to understand them.

First, let me say that I really hate it when the hero gets killed by a deus ex machina.
In many ways like Million Dollar Baby, another Hollywood tear-jerker where way too attractive actors & actresses pose as real people in a naturalistic world full of artifice. I did feel a smidge sad when Heath found his shirt (though I saw it coming when the shirt went missing in reel 2), but mostly I felt that these two dudes were too mopey and existential to be real gay cowboys. I mean, unless I missed something, they're not supposed to be French, are they? They behaved like starry-eyed teenagers past the point (and age) of believability; as much as I could buy the first half hour of meet-cute and the last five minutes of human loss, the big fat middle was a dull TV message-movie. Did Matthew Shepherd really die for this? And brand me a stereo-typer, but (in my limited experience) of most of the gay couples I've met, at least one of the partners displays way more of a fey affect then either of these two stoic shepherds ever showed.… Expand

I found this movie emotionally wrenching and very well made. However I think that it is an exaggeration to call this movie a masterpiece. In my mind it is a well-crafted assemblage of quality elements (cinematography, acting, screenplay) but somehow does not quite gel into a whole. I think this leads to a captivating movie experience for many as we can on our own "assemble" the satisfying movie experience that we each want to see in the movie. For me like a few other site users, there was not enough chemistry between Jack and Ennis, not just of the physical kind. I think that in particular Jack's character remained undeveloped...Jake Gyllenhall either was not given enough from the script or he didn't quite make the character seem plausible. This may seem to be a small detail but I kept on noticing that Jake's eyebrows looked plucked which I think of as anomalous given the time and place in which the story occurred. Nowadays it looks strange when a man plucks his eyebrows...it would have been 100x stranger in early 1960's Wyoming. Was that supposed to be a signal of gayness to other men? Why such an obvious one? This, to some minor, incongruity signals to me the more general problem of how to understand the main characters' and in particular Jack's motivation. He didn't seem to be a convincing character, more of a cypher.… Expand

Anyone who would give this movie a zero (Trish H.) because of its homosexual content missed the entire part about LOVE. You would do well to take some of your "moral fiber" and try to be a little more regular.

Fantastic movie, not at all preachy though it has a point. The story could easily be compared to "Romeo and Juliet", and Ang Lee proves that dispite the Hulk he is an excellent director. I went to watch the movie simply to thumb my nose at the bigots who opposed it because of the homosexuality, and it surprised me by being one of the best movies I've seen in a long time. Like Napolian Dynomite it relies on no special effects and is shot in a stark, almost documentary style that will only work if the story is worthwhile. The story is worthwhile.… Expand

Some (though not all) of the criticism I have read of this film serve as a startling reminder that ignorance, prejudice and hatred are still out there (which, in a way, only further justifies the point of this film). In 2006 there are still people who would exclaim, "This movie is sick! Why do most movies in this day and age have to be about homosexuality? Is nothing sacred anymore? What's next lesbian nuns?" Or, "Sick and twisted. If you are a heterosexual male, save your money for anything else." Only the inherent cliches and ignorance inherent in those opinions ensures they are not to be taken too seriously. It's sad. But it does something else: it reminds me that, whilst we may rightly proclaim the universality of this story and how accessible it is to everyone, it IS still an important film for gay people at this time in history. I found Brokeback Mountain to be a starkly frightening film in it's intelligence about the dangerous contexts (always implicit, nothing more is needed) in which such love would have existed. It leaves the viewer with so much to think about. all in the details and inferences, which will make it worth seeing again. In it's profound belief in the universality and power of love, though, it is also uplifting and extraordinary. I don't think the film is about something to applaud so much as it is about something worth believing in and worth fighting for.… Expand

Fantastic-- strong, meaningful and so real. Perfect movie.

This movie left me deeply despressed and I awoke early this morning thinking about it. I can not pin point all the ways it disturbed my until then contented love and life. I am not sure my love for mate is strong enough, I am not sure I can handle aging and the loss of romantic, passion filled love as it seems to ebb away over time. I have few of the obstacles these men faced in living my love, but their tragedy somehow upset the hold I felt I had on my relationship and life. I hope this leaks away soon and I hope in time I figure out is how and why it made me feel this way.… Expand

This film was a real eye opener, and timely, as humanity seeks to evolve and find our centre. This movie was all encompassing, surpassing what some may see as the main theme - gay love . It brought home the realisation that life is so short, that we do not stand in judgment of each other and that love in its purest form does not discriminate.

I think the movie although it was some gay cowboys is like the story Romeo and Juliet but guy to guy version I loved it.

This movie has dug so far into my soul and touched me so deep that its haunting effect may never go away. never has a movie made me take a long look in the mirror at myself, the life i've led, wanted to lead, what i've had to let go and why., what and who fills my heart with unimaginable joy and how sometimes that joy has been turned into unimaginable sorrow. this film has taken me to places that terrify me and leave me speechless while at the same time makes me realize what a precious gift i have been given....the ability to give and receive love in all its graces and hearrtbreaks. i will never take that gift f or it sunkown outcome for granted.but pursue it and be thankful i was allowed the journey.… Expand

An epic love story. Not a 'gay cowboy film". They aren't even cowboys. I cried, I laughed(a lot suprising), and I felt a connection to each and every character. BEST movie of the year. Hands down.

this is one of the best films i have ever seen. it is breathtaking leaving in shock and pain of the conclusion. everyone in it are amazing with no sub-standard performance and it should get best film at the oscars. it has broken the mold with the desperately sad story set with some of the most beautiful landscape in the world. a story about the bleakest and upsetting love that just happens to be two men.… Expand

I was totally moved by this movie - it slowly builds, and Wham! - all of the "could have", "should have", "what if's" of your life surface. I must see this movie again.

There are 17 reviews rated here "100" and only ne less than "50." Can this really be veridical? - truthful? - accurate? Or does this extraordinary ranking merely reflect the PC sensibility - the Gay "cowboy" romance everybody MUST love - that afflicts the latte drinking New York Times reading chattering class? I'm betting the latter. That doesn't mean this isn't worth seeing. But I remember when films about "men who couldn't talk about their feelings" were literally a dima dozen, a few decadesa go. And whom am I to say that new generations shouldn't redicover a timeless theme in a new setting? Ang Lee is also one of our best directors. SO why not see it now? I will see it, but only long after the buzz is gone and the self-righteous moralizing of the Leftist zombies who monopolize reviewing - probably when I can see it for two bucks. Why? Many friends say the short story by Annie Proulx is considerably better. Even reviewer "Neepy" writes "it is too safe. I didn't feel much chemistry, bonding, or even lust between the two cowboys." Thoughts others have echoed - it simply isn't as good as it's made out to be. It simply isn't as good or believable as Ang Lee's "The Wedding Banquet," another gay themed film about tragic love. So why do reviewers love a film that indulges in all the negative stereotypes about westerners and Mexicans? Because gays are a priviledged "minority." This is the "Philadelphia" or "Angels in America" of our time. The lemmings are out this season, ruining a good film for those who aren't bird watchers. Too bad they don't simply leave their agenda driven baggage at home and simply let the art speak for itself.… Expand

There are no words to really express my love for this film and the lives of its characters. I hold them all in my heart and lovingly do so. Ang Lee is a true master and the film is as brilliant as it is breathtaking. The script is pared down perfection and the performances are carried out with nuanced subtlety. Ennis and Jack come together to tell their story with such precision and perfection that I am almost moved to tears as I write this. Heath Ledger embodies Ennis in a way that lets us feel the vibration of his soul in every heartbeat, his and ours. And Jake Gyllenhal as Jack embodies the hope and enduring spirit of every peson who dares to really be true to himself in tehe world. The movie haunts me not because of it's tragic theme but because of Jack and Ennis's love and the exquisite way Ledger and Gyllenhal bring it to us. I treasure this film and I predict it will become one of the great films of the 21st century.… Expand

Only 3 films in my life have effected me so deeply. First The Sound of Music, next Cabaret, and now Brokeback Mountain.

It

This film haunted me after watching it. I feel like crying everytime I think of it. No other film EVER gave me these feelings.

Not as great as i thought or as its hyped to be. It was a nice story, but one that i've seen many times except this time it was two men as opposed to what i usually see with a man and a woman. Nice typical love story but with two men....maybe critics loved this because it was different. Who knows??? Overhyped, but an ok film.

This movie is a full-bodied love story of two people. It shows how both of them have been torn from each other due to society's pull, and every moment is captured in the eyes of the two men. It shows how much pain each of them go through with each passing year and the undeniable fire betwixt, keeping them together. This movie is a far cry from pornography and a rich jubilation of a love story; it is definitely worth seeing multiple times.… Expand

Gay cowboys are far from my idea of an American love story. Only another attempt of Hollywood to stuff the gay lifestyle down our throats. (no pun intended) As much as they would like to think this is the norm, it is not, and it is not acceptable.

I loved this movie. It was so close to the story, and kept the audience very involved.

Virtually a perfect movie.

I LOVED this movie. I thought it showed the lifestyles of some men because of the world today. Hopefully it will open people's minds.

Very sad but very good.

Acting superb, storyline disappointing. Cinematography was amazing.

An amazing film. This one is worthy of Oscars on all fronts: actors, cinematography, director, screenwriting, music, and more. And way overdue. The far right is just gonna have to get used to it.

This is the best portrayal ever of life in small western towns. Undoubtedly the gay relationship between the two cowboys is much more common than country people like to admit. This movie will be enoyed by all people, gay or straight, who have still have a heart and can feel for the sadness and frustration felt by these guys. Also: great settings: the natural beauty of western mountains and rivers.… Expand

In addition to its many, many genuine excellences, Ang Lee's so-called "gay cowboy" movie is also notable for providing me with the most simultaneously entertaining and disturbing time I've had watching a movie preview trailer since junior high school. The preview came on just before Syriana (a movie which, blaming as it does all the world's evils on American oil cartels, you'd hardly label as one especially attractive to a "red-state" audience) and when it became apparent that Ennis Del Mar (Heath Ledger) and Jack Twist (Jake Gyllenhaal) were going to share more than a can of beans, about twenty-five people in the audience, almost as one, simultaneously responded with a loud, high-pitched cry of "Eeeee-YEW!!!" Imagine that: a movie NOT dealing with horror or torture whose trailer reduces a group of seemingly intelligent, well-mannered adults to a bunch of 7-year-old girls reacting to a waterbug skittering across the basement floor at their Brownie meeting! Despite this and the recent news of a Utah multiplex suddenly yanking it despite the fact that it was making money there as everywhere (one word to their management staff: IDIOTS!) this film, despite its instant status as a Jay Leno punchline, is affecting and moving people all over the country who are willing to give it a chance, and it's doing so for several very simple, basic reasons: it's a beautifully written and directed, spectacularly shot, superbly acted piece of great storytelling that stays with you no matter what your political, religious or sexual persuasion. (Even conservative critic Michael Medved praised it, although part of this may stem from his awareness that his attempts to sabotage Million Dollar Baby last year by revealing its secrets in print and on TV might just have "tipped it" enough to win it several Oscars last year, and he's not making THAT mistake again.) Quentin Tarantino said at Cannes that he liked Michael Moore's Fahrenheit 9/11 not because he agreed with its stance but because he found it supremely entertaining, and regardless of your views on homosexuality, Brokeback Mountain works as a classic, old fashioned star-crossed and circumstance-separated lovers' "weeper" in the tradition of Back Street, Waterloo Bridge and many other movies familiar to your grandparents and those who like to tape Turner Classic Movies at 3 in the morning. (A more recent film parallel? Well, perhaps 2004's The Notebook...up to a point.) Writers Annie Proulx, Diana Ossana and Larry McMurtry (whose Lonesome Dove is undoubtedly much loved by some of the very same people who want nothing to do with his latest effort) may have specific viewpoints, but they're not doctrinaire: I think it's extremely possible for Brokeback Mountain to speak as strongly to conservative Christians as it does to gay activists. Keep in mind that the tragedy of Ennis's and Jack's long-running, clandestine affair extends to their wives and loved ones, and that nobody in the movie is patronized or caricatured. (Jack's wife, played by Anne Hathaway as a different kind of "princess" than she did in a pair of Disney movies, comes closest, but this is negated in a poignant, self-aware monologue near the end; Michelle Williams and Linda Cardellini as women in Ennis's life are simply heartbreaking.) It can also be argued that ranch boss Joe Aguirre (Randy Quaid), who hired Ennis and Jack to protect grazing sheep from wolf attacks, fires them not only because of their affair, but because they weren't doing their job--and that if the two cowboys had actually followed their hearts once down from Brokeback, Ennis's terrific, immensely sympathetic daughter (Kate Mara) would never have existed. Brokeback Mountain works superbly not only as an offbeat love story but as a powerful meditation of how entire lives are permanently altered by one impulsive action. Robert Frost's famous poem "The Road Not Taken" comes to mind not just in light of what would've happened if Jack and Ennis had become full-time lovers, but alternately (and in light of the turns everybody's lives end up taking) what the results would've been if the two guys hadn't reacted to boredom, loneliness, horniness and That Indescribable Something Else...and each of them had stayed on his side of the tent.… Expand

I loved this film. The relationship between Gyllenhaal and Ledger is powerful, amazing and unique. Slightly overrated, the

Incredible movie. The end hit me like a punch that knocks the wind out of you. I'm very open minded and have many gay friends, but was still a bit nervous about seeing this movie. If you love good film and are still haven't seen this movie, see it! The romantic scenes are very tastefully done and well acted. After a while you practically forget this movie is about two guys falling in love.… Expand

Teh first half of the movie is a Marlboro commercial. I was expecting the "Come to where the flavor is" voice. The second half is a failed gay compassion provoking video. We all know to be gay is ok, it is something normal to love. So, another love soap opera with a west side cowboys scenario was uneccessary.

This film, the story, the deeply real characters and the compelling portrayal from the wonderful actors in it have really moved me. I was not expecting the film to live up to the media build up but its graceful growth and the raw honest emotion carries you away. Heath Ledger's performance was surely his best yet and I think he gave the film a lot of integrity.

A truly breathtaking masterpiece. Ledger's performance as the inarticulate and eternally stifled Ennis is definitely Oscar-worthy. Rodrigo Prieto's amazing cinematography combined with the haunting musical score by Gustavo Santaolalla make this a true feast for the senses.

Very well written and preformed by all the actors involved. Would love to see the director turn the book The Front Runner by Patricia Warren into his next big screen movie. I enjoyed the book in 1974 and still do today. you go guys.

This movie touched me beyond words. I was barely able to make it out of the theatre and into my car without breaking down. I woke the next day, depressed and beyond tears. Brokeback Mountain had a profound effect on me and one that will not soon be forgotten. It has been over a week since I viewed the movie and not a day has gone by that it hasn't been in my thoughts. PLEASE go see this movie. Unless you are a homophobe or a card carrying member of the religious right, you will love the movie and be extremely touched. Only homophobes and haters give this movie a 0. I see probably roughly 25 movies a year and it's the best and most touching movie I've seen in YEARS. Both male actors deserve every award that can be given to them for doing an excellent job in telling the story of Jack and Ennis. The last few minutes will take your breath away. I sat in my chair for 10 minutes after the film ended before I was able to go to my car. I am not an emotional guy....especially in public...and this is the first movie I've ever cried at. I cannot say enough good about this moive. I loved it and if you are a kind and open hearted person, you'll love it too.… Expand

This is one of the best, most moving movies EVER made. I can't stop thinking about it and how great the actors were in the movie. It was amazing. Go see it, you won't be sorry.

Very sad. As a gay man it's easy to relate to one of the two. Mine was Dennis... until I came out. And I was so happy then. Still, it's not fair to frame this movie within its sex tendencies. It's a great movie no matter what. It's a supreme cry to all those who waste golden chances that may never show up again. We have to grab love where we find it. It's one of those movies that make you want to jump right inside and rescue the main character from his fatal lonely destiny. And like him, I swear, if I could do it, perhaps I would never jump out.… Expand

It didn't hit me in the guts the way "Bridges of Madison County" did , but that´s a whole another kind of story anyway.The "Marlboro postcards" are there to show us the surreal beauty of the place in question; somewhere you can always go back to, but what the heck, it's in your imagination! Concerning the slo pace, I think BM is character-driven, so the movie follows the aching, dubious, incredulous and often contemplative mood of it's main protagonist: Ennis Del Mar. Gay Western my balls!! This movie is a lot about subtext. ANYONE can relate to: 1) Commiting or suffering iInfidelities 2) wealth differences in a relationship 3) mad, obsessive search for the impossible 4) dealing with the authority when you have everything to lose (remember Jack's father in law) 5) the slow descent into lowdown when your object of passion can't give you what you want 6) consequences of not being able to say what you feel (regret) 7) fear of the payback 8) fear of everything else and last, and more imposrtantly, OPPORTUNITIES LOST (regret again). Can you relate to some of this? BM hast it's little flaws (yes, it's a bit too long) and it's memorable, magical moments (when Ennis whispers n impossibly tender lullaby in Jack's ears your heart just breaks out of nowhere) This is a movie you just need to watch leaving all of your prejudices, labels and high expectations in the box office.… Expand

If you liked 'Bridges of Madison County', you will like this movie. While similar in the basic premise of forbidden love vs. moral and 'right' committments, the subtext for Brokeback ends up being as much if not more powerful than the main story. And as an aside, you don't have to be gay to enjoy the movie (and I've heard it hasn't turned anyone gay . . . yet). So, if you're skipping out on this movie 'cause you've got an uncomfortable streak w/ the story, I suggest you get over it and check your homophobia at the ticket window; otherwise, you're gonna miss out on a captivating movie. My other half gets kind of uncomfortable seeing men together, but even she liked the movie. (and I'm still straight the last time I checked -- crossing my fingers).… Expand

I think this movie is great. heath's such an actor and the contrast between wild open natural scene and stifling oppressive human society. you do need some guts to be different, even just to be yourself. it's a comfort for people like these two poor ones.

How can I put in words my response to this film: superb, brilliant, terrifyingly true, sad, beautiful. I came out of the movie speechless and emotionally exhausted. The honest portrayal of all the characters is laudable, but Heath Ledger's performance throughout is truly staggering. In future years this film will come to be seen as one of the greatest of all time.

This film is shot so well, it actually transports the viewer to that period and location. The performances by Ledger and Gyllenhaal are so genuine for that generation in which the film is shot. However, this is a drama. It requires a mature audience. If you are looking for special effects or lots of laughs, this movie isn't for you. This film is an insight into the lives of two men that are coping with the demands of their society, their beliefs and their love for each other. I thought this movie had a very real feel to it. The end very sad. This is one of the most memorable movies I have ever seen. I would recomend it to almost anyone.… Expand

Best film I've seen in at least 3 years. Superior performances, superb cinematography, excellent screen play! Repeat viewings on the big screen are definitely in order!

this movie is the best! it is not supposed to be about 2 gay ppl falling in love, yes they are gay but so what..they fell in love. they did leave their families behind but they needed to do it, if yoyu loved someone that much then you;d do it. this movie ois great!! the actors are fantastic and ang less is great as well!!!!!!!!!!!(L)

A masterpiece of film. This one is going to be talked about for a hundred years.

Ok, let us all get past that the movie was based on Gay Love, this was not a movie about how it affected the wives, I guess you would have to be either Gay or bisexual to truley understand why they could not give themselves fully to one another, and yes the movie did lack a certain passion, but as a breakthrough movie, it was not about cheating on their wife, come on, Love between a man and a woman is different, you do not have to hise it, but in 1963 , do you really think they could of been together and lived a life with peace?, Now to the movie itself, Good acting, I even believed their Love, Truley can not compare to a man woman affair. Let us PLEASE get past that they were cheating on thier wife, in their hearts they were not cheating, they loved each other and in a different time and place, they would not of tried to get married and "Be Strieght", they would of just been together and not went on with a fake cover up life. OK, I am getting to emotional talking about it.… Expand

Worth a rental, but disappointing. I'm a fan of Ang Lee's films, but Heath Ledger's performance almost ruined the movie for me. I thought his use of his face and mouth was exagerrated and distracting--he was hard to understand, and frankly, frustrating to watch. (I grew up with a grandad who was this "strong silent type," so maybe my expectations are unrealistic?! Grandad was a master...) However, Jake Gyllenhall's performance saved the movie, and the cinematography is beautiful. But, the intensity just isn't sustained, and the screenplay somehow doesn't bring to life the depth and breadth of all those years' hidden love. Something didn't work here, and I think it's in Annie Proulx's short story. The movie ultimately seems at its core like merely an overexpanded idea, relying on a foundation of supposed bleakness that's unexplored. It doesn't quite work, and it's a shame. I thought the Ice Storm understood and explored its era and culture much better, and I expected more from Mr. Lee.… Expand

I'm sure the book is good. However, this is one truly boring and terrible movie. The plot is thin and incredibly unexplained, and no I'm not talking about the ending because I GOT IT, but the fact that the men could have wives and children and still be in love with each other could have used much more explanation. I don't know why people don't question that. I understand how it is, but it saddens me, as a gay man, to have this garbage strewn onto the public without any explanation. The cinematography is good, the acting is good, the story is terrible, and it is very very very boring. I know slower moving movies that kept me more entertained that this garbage. I can't believe people think this is 'artful'. It wouldn't take very much for me to come up with a better screenplay involving the forbidden love of two men - making it more interesting, more developed, and could probably even add a twist ending to it. But alas, this is what we get. And it gets all of it's good reviews just because conservative America isn't used to contemporary life. Shame.… Expand

If u like watching 2 guys in a movie get it on i do recammend this.not 2 mention it starts out very slow.

Not only sensitive but skilful in its sustained sadness. It has surprised many men generally unmoved by gay relationships depicted on film. The short story is a classic and the film comes close to matching its restraint.

A touching and beautiful love story. A great film, one of the best movies in the last 30 years or so. I'll never understand the people who are saying terrible things about this masterpiece.

Wow! Talk about overrated! The most unforgatble Love Story becomes excatly that! Forgatble! I was actually looking forward to seeing this movie. But as I sat there watching couldnt help but feel a little cheated. People say it is Greek Tragedy or what have you. To me the story could have been more. There are some nice moments where we feel the characters pain having to deal with this uncontrollable feeling. They are very well directed. However there really was not that big of drama! I have an open mind and that is why i wanted to see this movie. but it really did not deliver to me. I dont know what it is. it just was not there. I guess it has to be moments where Hey they get spotted acting a little to friendly with each other but nothing happens... This is a sad story. Well worth at least one time glance but nothing more. Just Over rated! Now Ang Lee can get back to more important movies Like "Hulk II"… Expand

Heard so much about this "gay cowboy" story- the great reviews, the worst reviews, the winning streak, the final disappointment....could not figure out who was right and who was wrong. But that was untill I saw it myself. And when I did, I was completely bowled over. The movie wrenched my heart out. Never before have I seen a movie which portrayed true love being found and lost in such a masterly way. I have strong objections against the "gay cowboy" tag. It's not a story about gay people, it's a story about two people finding love where they least expected and they cannot do anything about it. In the final moments I found myself crying almost involuntarily. I would have given it a 100 out of 10 if it was possible to do so!… Expand

An excellent movie. Although many people who don't like it say that it could just as easily have been a man and a woman, this is not true. The movie, at least to me, was more about the sheer REPRESSION Ennis and Jack inflicted on themselves than even about their affair. [***SPOILERS***] It was about how they were having a relationship that was not socially acceptable at the time which eventually led to Jack's death- which is not cliche because it never gets old.… Expand

Extraordinary movie. This film truly moved me. Wow! An unforgettable Masterpiece!

Movie buff here. This movie was simply stunning. Acting, directing, cinematography, music were perfect. Visually breathtaking.

Two homosexual individuals struggle to be together, bound by the norms and rules of society. At first, I was confused to how fast the story was moving with the very short scenes; but then understood the movie has to be told like this as it takes place over somewhat 20years. Looking back, this method of story-telling was very effective. As a true horror, sci-fi and animie fanatic, even I found this movie breathtaking. Scenery, story and acting was spot on. I've seen alot of movies, and this is at the top of the pile. Everybody should see this movie!… Expand

I loved it! Loved it! Great actors Gyllenhaal and Ledger, (RIP) and the story is perfect.

Without a doubt, the best film of the year. It is subtle and respectful. It doesn't manipulate. It has a story to tell, and it does so--beautifully. The acting is superb. The directing is restrained. These are people you feel you know; not actors playing parts. The biggest tragedy of "Brokeback Mountain" is that small-minded people insist it's "propaganda" for the "gay agenda". Those who could learn from it won't see it; those who could maybe see that love is indeed a force of nature by viewing this gorgeous and haunting film, never will because of preconceived ideas and/or ignorance. For those who open their hearst and minds, this movie is a gem. The most perfect example of heart-wrenching, doomed love since Romeo and Juliet.… Expand

Brilliant film. Oscars all around.

A minimum of story-telling elements is used to convey a powerfully moving story of enduring love in a very beautiful way.

Mainstream next!

During our history here as humans on planet earth, we as a collective whole experience times where we are boosted up to the next level of higher conciousness. As a world and as a nation we have accended higher up to the green valleys of Brokeback Mountain. If you do not love this movie than you will be left behind. This is not an implication of the world turning gay, but a deep behooving that unless you start loving and stop judging you will be the only one to suffer.… Expand

One of the most overated movies of the year.

Like Annie Proulx's writing, the film was by equal turns rapturous and devastating. Both exquisitely beautiful and gut-punched painful. Do not go to this movie thinking that Ang Lee has thoughtfully sprinkled in some magic movie dust that will leave you feeling good. You will walk out feeling emotionally drained and conflicted. The conflicted feeling will last for days. My explicit advice is that the film be seen in an environment that will promote a feeling of intimacy. See it with someone you love. You will willingly bear your heart. You will feel vulnerable. Heath Ledger fully becomes Ennis del Mar. He is wracked by pain, frustration, fear and guilt that never completely leave him. Jake Gyllenhaal fully becomes Jack Twist. He has a kind of hopeful joy you feel you can drink in great healing gulps. But Ennis cannot be completely healed, he can only be temporarily relieved and the anguish that this causes Jack is fully realized through Jake. Ennis' and Jack's love is made fully evident by Heath and Jake in actions and expressions both great and small. The music of Gustavo Santaolalla is pitch perfect and the screenplay of Larry McMurtry and Diana Ossana is flawless. I don't feel the need to elaborate on the performances of Michelle Williams and Anne Hathaway or the cinematography of Rodrigo Prieto. They were each exceptional and have been praised elsewhere. They were not the focus of my concern although if they had not been so exceptional the film would have been crippled. Please, read the story. But expect to come away from the film with different impressions and understandings. Be prepared to think differently about Jack and Ennis. Be prepared to understand them more fully. I am honestly grateful to Heath Ledger, Jake Gyllenhaal and Ang Lee for so lovingly giving Ennis and Jack and their story to us and I will write them to say so. You will be changed by this film.… Expand

Can hardly breath for the melancholy I still feel after watching this fantastic film.

I saw this movie the day it opened in L. A. and I was left shattered, speechless, and emotionally drained. What a beautiful and profound vision of the complexities of the human heart from Ang Lee. It is a trancendent love story in the tradition of "Gone With The Wind," Wuthering Heights," and "Doctor Zhivago." I believe that like Scarlett and Rhett, Heathcliff and Cathy, and Yuri and Lara, that Ennis and Jack will join the pantheon of these literary and cinematic immortal lovers. Heath Ledger and Jake Gyllenhaal give career-defining performances that make the heart flutter and bleed. I predict an Oscar Sweep for this film: Picture, Director, Best Actor (Ledger), Best Supporting Actress (Williams/Hathaway), Best Supporting Actor (Gyllenhaal), Best Adapted Screenplay, Best Cinematography, and maybe Best Score, Best Song, Best Editing, and Best Costume Design as well. Run, don't walk, and go see this movie with a loved oned!… Expand

I expected and got the timeless love story: amazingly universal, but tragic and powerful. What I didn't expect was the other tragedy that played out: the family devastation and ensuing pain. Watch for Hathaway's bitterness and Williams, crestfallen and lonely. I have NEVER seen any movie that has done all that so well.

Just a well made, simple love story between two men. Void of the streotypical characters portrayed in most films dealing with "a gay lifestyle". Their love connection comes across naturally in the wilderness. Complications and heartbreak only arise when society and the times keep these two apart from a possible chance of a life together. I give Ang Lee praise for not portraying true love as a sterotype, but just as human.… Expand

I had no desire to see this movie! I went with my girlfriend to get out of the "doghouse" and I did not want any of my friends to know. We had all be joking about the movie for weeks. After going, and just minutes into the movie, I completely forgot it was a story about 2 guys. You get so caught up in the movie......and what is going on. When it was over, we were both so down. Actually down for a couple of days. This is the first movie that has ever had this kind of impact on me. She and I have had some of the best talks since this movie and it has brought us closer. You guys out there (including my friends) who think this is a joke of a movie......go see it with open eyes. And just because you find this movie is a 10, does not mean you are gay!… Expand

This is by far the best film I've seen in the past five years. Don't be swayed by negative comments, this film is a total "experience", to be had by each individual, in his own way, with his own sensibility.

Superlative in every way--writing, acting, directing, set design...if you love movies, you must see this one.

This truly memorable work of art accomplishes nothing less than what Aristotle claimed for genuine tragedy - the evocation of deep fear and pity followed by catharsis. What a remarkable gift!

Will no one criticize this trite, overacted, and, most importantly, overrated tribute to America's continued love affair with celebrity directors, handsome actors, and subject matter that deems a film above reproach? I guess not. Get in line, the are a couple of spots on Ang Lee's butt that have not been kissed.

This is truly one of the best films of this year. Top notch script, director, and cast. Every adult should see this film.

I think that this movie is incredible. I agree that Heath Ledger did an amazing job in his role but I really believe that Jake Gyllenhaal deserves some major kudos for his superb performance as well. There is a lot of meaning and symbolism that you don't catch the first time through. I recommend that everyone sees the film a second time. You will be amazed at how much you missed the first time you watched it.… Expand

Lives up to the hype and more. Both Ledger and Gyllenhaal give brilliant performances, plus a lot of really interesting side characters (Anna Faris is an great short surprise). A quiet and subtle movie, but not without much life and spark. This movie will haunt you long after you leave the theater.

Absolutely the best film I've seen in the last ten years. The most astonishing depiction of male love ever committed to the screen in a mainstream film, and supported by impeccable acting across the entire cast. This is an experience of true cinematic art, something that is often attempted and almost never acheived. See it on the widest screen you can find, in a theatre, and be prepared to be blown away.… Expand

One week after seeing this movie, it remains in my heart, my mind and my blood. Never, ever has a movie seeped into my soul until now. It's a little embarrassing, for Ledger and Gyllenhaal are the same ages as my sons, and I feel a more than a little depraved.....they are impossibly beautiful. But the movie is a crystal bell ringing for the "what ifs" in every life. It beckons every heart in which a wild cry was buried long ago, a heart whose choices were made and had to be lived with. I am shaken, heartbroken and completely undone. Bad choices really screw things up, and this film should be shown to everyone planning to marry.… Expand

Powerful.

This movie made me forget, for a while, that it contains two gay men. To me, this love story is just that... a story about LOVE, albeit between two men. The complicated lives of these men mirror those of many when they find love that is not accepted by society and must revert to "acceptable norms". Great film!

This movie left me sad for days, as if I was feeling the Ennis Del Mar's pain. In addition, the music was very beautiful as well as the cinematography. The only reason I did not give it a 10 is because the ending seemed too hopeful in spite of the sadness. I would have ended it more tragically--probably with Ennis going back and staying at Brokeback Mountain or ending his life there. The actors were absolutely great--all of them--and the director did a magnificent job.… Expand

Beautiful movie -- writing, directing, acting, cinematography, music. A sublime adaptation of Annie Proulx's haunting short story by the writers, director and especially, the actors.

Amazing film.

At last a serious attempt to portray a complex issue in a truthful unjudgemental way! It took an Oriental Director to do that. AR.

The film is about love, nothing more. The leit-motif is repressed passion: the notion that repressed passion does no one any good. In Brokeback Mountain, it turns vibrant men ghostly. Jack and Ennis, worn down by the constant crushing burden of being someone they are not, can only look backward as outside forces wedge them apart and life pushes them in the opposite direction. A taboo-structured culture obliges them to fail those around them as they disappoint themselves. In the end, they might have been saved by something as simple as love -- just plain love.… Expand

This film was fantastic- most important film to come out of cinema in years!

Emotional, powerful, impressive and masterfully done. To quote Ennis from the movie " This thing grabs on us (as a movie goer). Ain't no reins on this one." Buy a copy of "Brokeback Mountain Story to Screenplay." Read the short story by Annie Proulx and the screenplay contained in this paperback. Again quoting from the screenplay, "Old Brokeback got us good, didn't it?" Brokeback got me good...it's a movie I'll never forget and cherish forever.… Expand

Wonderful movie !

This is a landmark film, and it will take your breath away. It is unbelievably accurate in its portrayal of the emotional turmoil some young gay men go through, even today.

Excellent film.

My wife & I just saw this film and we both came away generally bored, unmoved, and feeling duped by all the hype. Beautiful scenery and cinematography, reasonable depiction of herding sheep on summer range, good cast, and fair acting (nothing special, as others seem to think). BUT: The story is just not engaging. There's no chemistry between the lovers, no flirting nuances, no buildup. In fact, their initial lovemaking seems more like an impulsive act of rape. Like one of the other reviewers herein, I think I must have missed the "love" part (maybe I dozed off). And much of the rest of the story is either implausible or uninteresting. Will they finally get together and live happily ever after? We simply don't care. One of the "great films of all time"? No way. Even if you narrow the category to gay films, it's not even in the same league as "The Crying Game". I'm always perplexed when I'm in such disagreement with the reviewers, especially the "user comments" on this site, with which I normally agree. So I analyzed the data a little more carefully. For the weekend of Jan. 13-15, BBM (in its 6th week) grossed $5.8M, which is in ninth place. Seems odd that, by now, word of mouth for this monumental film would be doing at least as well as "Memoirs of a Geisha" or "Fun With Dick & Jane". I know, "there's no accounting for taste". I also looked at the Top 10 films of 2005 where, based on critics' reviews, BBM is #6. Excluding BBM, the average number of User Comments for the other top 9 films is 43. BBM, on the other hand, has over 460 User Comments. Seems odd that a film that is generating so much positive feedback from users would not be doing better at the box office. Or could it be that the ballot box is getting stuffed by folks with an agenda, trying to generate interest and help its chances for an Oscar. Just a thought.… Expand

Ennis Del Mar does not fall in love with Jack Twist because he is a gay man. At 19, Ennis is still virgin, and is, above all, lonesome and unloved. He finds himself with one other open and big-hearted individual in a great panoramic space far removed from life

Honestly, as profound experiences go, this is up there near or at the top for me, alongside things like john lennons/plastic ono band album, kerouac's on the road, really essential stories. ive cried about 5 times! honestly, if you think you may relate to this movie in anyway, or even not - go see it, its a stunner.