All Critics

  1. Average review score: 52

    On average, this critic grades
    14 points lower than other critics.

  2. Average review score: 74

    On average, this critic grades
    8 points higher than other critics.

  3. James Collins

    6 TvShows
    Average review score: 53

    On average, this critic grades
    13 points lower than other critics.

  4. James Poniewozik

    460 TvShows
    Average review score: 63

    On average, this critic grades
    2 points lower than other critics.

  5. Average review score: 74

    On average, this critic grades
    8 points higher than other critics.

  6. Jason Hughes

    13 TvShows
    Average review score: 60

    On average, this critic grades
    6 points lower than other critics.

  7. Average review score: 72

    On average, this critic grades
    6 points higher than other critics.

  8. Average review score: 100

    On average, this critic grades
    34 points higher than other critics.

  9. Average review score: 78

    On average, this critic grades
    12 points higher than other critics.

  10. Average review score: 75

    On average, this critic grades
    10 points higher than other critics.

  11. Average review score: 72

    On average, this critic grades
    7 points higher than other critics.

  12. Average review score: 80

    On average, this critic grades
    14 points higher than other critics.

  13. Average review score: 76

    On average, this critic grades
    10 points higher than other critics.

  14. Average review score: 62

    On average, this critic grades
    4 points lower than other critics.

  15. Average review score: 73

    On average, this critic grades
    7 points higher than other critics.

  16. Average review score: 70

    On average, this critic grades
    4 points higher than other critics.

  17. Average review score: 67

    On average, this critic grades
    2 points higher than other critics.

  18. Average review score: 64

    On average, this critic grades
    2 points lower than other critics.

  19. Average review score: 71

    On average, this critic grades
    6 points higher than other critics.

  20. Average review score: 80

    On average, this critic grades
    14 points higher than other critics.

  21. Average review score: 66

    On average, this critic grades
    1 point higher than other critics.

  22. Joe Reid

    1 TvShow
    Average review score: 80

    On average, this critic grades
    14 points higher than other critics.

  23. Joel Stein

    4 TvShows
    Average review score: 62

    On average, this critic grades
    4 points lower than other critics.

  24. Average review score: 61

    On average, this critic grades
    4 points lower than other critics.

  25. Average review score: 50

    On average, this critic grades
    16 points lower than other critics.

Recent User Reviews

  1. From the very first scene in Series 2 I was disappointed, its not simply that Season 2 is different from S1, it just seems like the script isFrom the very first scene in Series 2 I was disappointed, its not simply that Season 2 is different from S1, it just seems like the script is trying too hard, the Photography is sub par and has none of the subtle nuance of the original, worst of all it has no clear story arc per episode.

    But back to the opening scene .. and why this series is annoying me rather than entertaining, we open on the scene where Colin Farrel is talking to his son ... now I know they haven't brought up the whole rape thing in the first scene, but the script is going to question CF as being his dad ... I don't mind that concept, but visually and conceptually it was as subtle as a brick to the face. Its like the director/casting agent thought ok we have a dark haired skinny CF and later we want the audience to question if he's the father, so ok we'll cast a Ginger haired fat kid, it leave no question marks, no is he or isn't he the father to play on. It was almost like watching a comedy sketch. Simply put, this season lacks any sense of mystery.

    There are also TOO many storylines, it felt like a train wreck, your introduced to what felt like 20 characters in the first episode, it gave you no time to buy into any scene or character, you get a few lines and your jarred of to another character.

    It also lacks any sense of atmosphere, Season 1 practically oozed Deep South America, Season 2 has alot of aerial shots of cars on highways, shots that frankly could be filmed anywhere, in fact it seemed 90% of the opening episodes felt like they were shot inside some generic soundstage ... it simply lacks any real sense of location.

    Its cliched, muddled, lacks nuance, and has some terrible acting at times, it's as if everyone knows it should be great, knows the writier is capable of great things but no one wants or knows how to commit.
    Full Review »
  2. 10
    Great show. Intelligent and funny. It pokes fun at **** that you know must be real to a certain degree. Tim Robbins is awesome. If youGreat show. Intelligent and funny. It pokes fun at **** that you know must be real to a certain degree. Tim Robbins is awesome. If you listen to NPR on a daily basis you'll probably like it. If not you either hate it or don't give a single **** Full Review »
  3. Doesn't hit its stride until Episode 5. Like a lot of comedy series, it takes a few episodes to gel. But starting at #5, the timing, writingDoesn't hit its stride until Episode 5. Like a lot of comedy series, it takes a few episodes to gel. But starting at #5, the timing, writing and editing hit the mark, turning an amusing show into a laugh out loud show. Full Review »
  4. Season one was great. Season two was okay. Season three was a mess. Graeme keeps using the term slow burn which means he has no clue whatSeason one was great. Season two was okay. Season three was a mess. Graeme keeps using the term slow burn which means he has no clue what to do with a character or storyline. Shay? Why is she on the show? There is no chemistry between her and Cosima. Yuk! There has been no storyline where she is concerned and the little time she has had on screen was useless. The writers have lost focus with this show. We don't see Art anymore and Felix has little or nothing witty to say. No more zingers for him. Ahh, Delphine, Delphine! Why hurt the only one who tried to help the sisters from the beginning? They really messed up with the hot romance between Cosima and Delphine. A lot of people are disappointed that they shot Delphine. If she is gone next season so am I. Evelyne Brochu is talented. You can't give us a powerhouse like her and then take her away from us. I hope the creators are listening to the fans and do the right thing. Full Review »
  5. Wet Hot American Summer: First Day of Camp offers more of the the goofy hijinks that fans of the cult classic crave, but outsiders might notWet Hot American Summer: First Day of Camp offers more of the the goofy hijinks that fans of the cult classic crave, but outsiders might not be quite as enamored. Full Review »

Most talked about trailers