For 167 reviews, this critic has graded:
  • 39% higher than the average critic
  • 1% same as the average critic
  • 60% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 12.4 points lower than other critics. (0-100 point scale)

Melanie McFarland's Scores

  • TV
Average review score: 51
Highest review score:
Critic Score 100
Lowest review score:
Critic Score 0
Score distribution:
  1. Positive: 58 out of 167
  2. Negative: 54 out of 167
167 tv reviews
    • Metascore: 64
    • Melanie McFarland 60
    While one can never count out a decent cop show, Life's main character is so weird he either fascinates you immediately or turns you off.
    • Metascore: 64
    • Melanie McFarland 80
    Considering all that it has going for it, "Threshold" has a more formidable foe in Friday night apathy. Out of all the shows that could possibly conquer that, though, you couldn't place your faith in a better choice than this excellent proof of intelligent TV life.
    • Metascore: 51
    • Melanie McFarland 40
    File this under "We'll See."
    • Metascore: 64
    • Melanie McFarland 70
    Unless you're a cold, cynical, seen-it-all kind of guy (or chick), odds are you'll find a lot to like about the first episode.
    • Metascore: 64
    • Melanie McFarland 50
    It isn't a laugh-a-minute free-for-all.
    • Metascore: 64
    • Melanie McFarland 70
    This is not a shoot-the-moon, wholly unique story, but it's comforting and thoughtful.
    • Metascore: 64
    • Melanie McFarland 10
    Worst of all is the writing's low-bar comedy; it's so weak that the laugh track doesn't just sound forced, it sounds as if the audience has a gun to its head.
    • Metascore: 64
    • Melanie McFarland 30
    It's unfair to lay every fault on the actors when the dialogue is so insubstantial, verging on sophomoric and mawkish in a few exchanges
    • Metascore: 63
    • Melanie McFarland 80
    Guide to Style is smart, fun and instructive, emphasizing enlightenment over shame and choice over following orders.
    • Metascore: 39
    • Melanie McFarland 40
    Interesting, but the sprawling pilot doesn't do "Surface" any favors.
    • Metascore: 63
    • Melanie McFarland 60
    "Hex" may not be stupendous TV, but for a decent summer thrill, nothing on broadcast holds a candle to it.
    • Metascore: 63
    • Melanie McFarland 70
    A classy, stimulating look at six true mavericks through the eyes of six people in various stages of iconoclastic development.
    • Metascore: 55
    • Melanie McFarland 40
    "Bones" probably will remind more viewers of a cross between "CSI" and "The X-Files," except with more humorous banter than the first, and more romantic heat than the latter.
    • Metascore: 62
    • Melanie McFarland 60
    It's all very quirky. Too quirky, maybe, for an audience that is used to spaceships, robots and explosions.
    • Metascore: 62
    • Melanie McFarland 70
    A promising cast and respected executive producers conspire to give "The Unit" a shot at being this spring's breakout hit. But the real proof's in the pilot, a thrilling balance between the action of this sharpshooting brotherhood and the schemes of their secretive, slightly overbearing wives.
    • Metascore: 61
    • Melanie McFarland 70
    Borders on terrific at times and falters in others.
    • Metascore: 61
    • Melanie McFarland 70
    Relentlessly odd as "Meadowlands" can be, don't be surprised if it seduces you.
    • Metascore: 61
    • Melanie McFarland 50
    Just when you think The Office is working, it starts to crumble. You reach a point of giving up on it, and then suddenly it pulls you back. The thing defies concrete evaluation because it could go either way. [24 Mar 2005, p.D1]
    • Metascore: 60
    • Melanie McFarland 60
    If you don't like Woods' frantic, frequent speeches, and you can't get out of the "Without a Trace" Thursday habit, best to steer clear.
    • Metascore: 60
    • Melanie McFarland 60
    "Day Break" is an intricate, imaginative series designed to make you ask questions at every turn, but the killer will be, "What else is on?"
    • Metascore: 47
    • Melanie McFarland 20
    There comes a point at which sisterhood becomes powerfully irritating, and "Related" finds it within the first 40 minutes of its existence.
    • Metascore: 38
    • Melanie McFarland 0
    This vampire detective show (sorry, can't resist this) is one that first bites, then sucks. Hard.
    • Metascore: 60
    • Melanie McFarland 70
    The premiere breathe[s] like a moody, dark theatrical release -- one that tastes like Quentin Tarantino muddled with Michael Mann -- as opposed to a pilot from executive producer John Wells.
    • Metascore: 59
    • Melanie McFarland 40
    The only person with untainted clues as to the person Samantha really was is the doorman to her apartment building, Frank (Tim Russ), and the combination of all these factors creates a premiere that is as pathetic as it is occasionally funny.
    • Metascore: 59
    • Melanie McFarland 60
    "My Boys"... has development potential if you can get past the notion that it's been done to death.
    • Metascore: 59
    • Melanie McFarland 30
    Hang out for a while... and you may quickly realize why you didn't stay in touch with most of your fellow third-graders. People like these suck the life out of you.
    • Metascore: 59
    • Melanie McFarland 70
    "Supernatural" plays like a high-octane B-flick. You could be mildly ashamed at how much you like it.
    • Metascore: 58
    • Melanie McFarland 80
    "Psych" is one of those happy collisions of an intelligent script and an appealing cast.
    • Metascore: 58
    • Melanie McFarland 60
    The tale's beyond complicated, to be sure. But it also may be the most watchable six hours of strangeness you'll see this season.
    • Metascore: 28
    • Melanie McFarland 20
    Besides making every aspect of dating and mating look depressing, it's hard to come up with a reason to spend time with any of these characters.