For 1,220 reviews, this critic has graded:
  • 51% higher than the average critic
  • 2% same as the average critic
  • 47% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 2.8 points higher than other critics. (0-100 point scale)

Todd McCarthy's Scores

  • Movies
Average review score: 62
Highest review score:
Critic Score 100
Lowest review score:
Critic Score 0
Score distribution:
1,220 movie reviews
    • Metascore: 82
    • Todd McCarthy 100
    Clint Eastwood has crafted a tense, hard-edged, superbly dramatic yarn that is also an exceedingly intelligent meditation on the West, its myths and its heroes.
    • Metascore: 82
    • Todd McCarthy 70
    As intensely personal and deeply felt as it is, however, Davies' attempt to breathe new life into Rattigan's 1952 play is a rather bloodless, suffocating thing, lent tragic passion more by its use of Samuel Barber's Violin Concerto than by anything achieved by his star Rachel Weisz and her leading man.
    • Metascore: 82
    • Todd McCarthy 80
    Succeeds in capturing the book's essential themes and concerns, albeit in a hectic style that could not be more antithetical to that of the literary master of international intrigue.
    • Metascore: 82
    • Todd McCarthy 80
    Sympathetic, genial and exceedingly wholesome, it's a film that, once seen, will permanently and favorably influence the way viewers regard the characters' real-life counterparts.
    • Metascore: 82
    • Todd McCarthy 70
    A provocative premise, virtuoso direction and two dazzling lead performances go a long way toward offsetting a lack of dramatic structure and a sense of when to quit in Face/Off.
    • Metascore: 82
    • Todd McCarthy 90
    Manages the difficult feat of being an intimate, even delicate tale played with an appealingly light touch against an epic backdrop.
    • Metascore: 82
    • Todd McCarthy 60
    Jewish and academically inclined audiences worldwide will respond to numerous aspects of this unusual drama, although it is paradoxically both too broad and too esoteric for the general art house public.
    • Metascore: 82
    • Todd McCarthy 90
    Immaculately crafted in beautiful black-and-white and entirely absorbing through its longish running time, Michael Haneke’s The White Ribbon nonetheless proves a difficult film to entirely embrace.
    • Metascore: 82
    • Todd McCarthy 70
    An impudently comic, stylistically aggressive and, finally, very thoughtful manner.
    • Metascore: 82
    • Todd McCarthy 90
    Uses first-person on-camera accounts of the adventure by Simpson and fellow climber Simon Yates to backdrop newly shot you-are-there footage that brings home the awesome and harrowing aspects of their feat.
    • Metascore: 82
    • Todd McCarthy 70
    Audiences looking for something fresh and different, not to mention a head trip, will find it in Waking Life.
    • Metascore: 82
    • Todd McCarthy 90
    A superbly wrought yarn set in the milieu of first-generation Russian mobsters in London that is simultaneously tough-minded and compassionate about the human condition, Eastern Promises instantly takes its place among David Cronenberg's very best films.
    • Metascore: 81
    • Todd McCarthy 70
    Lack of depth, complexity or strangeness make this a relatively routine entry for the director.
    • Metascore: 81
    • Todd McCarthy 80
    A genuinely ominous and suspenseful thriller.
    • Metascore: 81
    • Todd McCarthy 80
    An ultra-smart-mouthed comedy about a planned adoption that goes weirdly awry.
    • Metascore: 81
    • Todd McCarthy 80
    On balance, this is a meaty, strongly realized dramatic work of considerable accomplishment.
    • Metascore: 81
    • Todd McCarthy 90
    Truly beguiling romantic comedy.
    • Metascore: 81
    • Todd McCarthy 100
    Rare proof that a gigantic production in contemporary Hollywood can possess a distinctive personality and its own approach to storytelling, Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World proves as bracing as a stiff wind on the open sea.
    • Metascore: 81
    • Todd McCarthy 70
    A well-acted and crafted character piece that's a bit too calculated and cutesy for its own good.
    • Metascore: 81
    • Todd McCarthy 90
    Breaking through any period-piece mustiness with piercing insight into the emotions and behavior of her characters, the writer-director examines the final years in the short life of 19th-century romantic poet John Keats through the eyes of his beloved, Fanny Brawne, played by Abbie Cornish in an outstanding performance.
    • Metascore: 81
    • Todd McCarthy 80
    Only Tarantino could come up with such a wild cross-cultural mash, a smorgasbord of ingredients stemming from spaghetti Westerns, German legend, historical slavery, modern rap music, proto-Ku Klux Klan fashion, an assembly of '60s and '70s character actors and a leading couple meant to be the distant forebears of blaxploitation hero John Shaft and make it not only digestible but actually pretty delicious.
    • Metascore: 81
    • Todd McCarthy 90
    Dramatically gripping while still brandishing a droll undercurrent of humor, this beautifully made film will certainly be embraced as one of the best Bonds by loyal fans worldwide and leaves you wanting the next one to turn up sooner than four years from now.
    • Metascore: 81
    • Todd McCarthy 70
    Baker does an amazingly sensitive job with the ticklish part and is joined in this by Read, who is superlative as his inquisitive young son.
    • Metascore: 81
    • Todd McCarthy 90
    Considerable intelligence and strategic finesse have been brought to bear on this handsomely mounted adaptation of Michael Cunningham's Pulitzer Prize-winning novel, which was hardly a natural for the bigscreen.
    • Metascore: 81
    • Todd McCarthy 90
    The director mixes moods with a playfulness that is both brazen and carefree and yet precisely modulated, yielding results that amplify the specific content of the screenplay. This makes for a film that, however cheap it was to make, is incredibly rich to watch.
    • Metascore: 81
    • Todd McCarthy 100
    Rourke creates a galvanizing, humorous, deeply moving portrait that instantly takes its place among the great, iconic screen performances. An elemental story simply and brilliantly told, Darren Aronofsky's fourth feature is a winner from every possible angle.
    • Metascore: 81
    • Todd McCarthy 90
    Last year's "The Prisoner of Azkaban" seemed dark, but this excellent fourth film derived from J.K. Rowling's books is the darkest "Potter" yet, intense enough to warrant a PG-13 rating.
    • Metascore: 81
    • Todd McCarthy 90
    An intensely imaginative piece of conceptual filmmaking that also delivers the goods as a dread-drenched horror movie.
    • Metascore: 81
    • Todd McCarthy 90
    Almost too much of a good thing, Peter Jackson's remake of the film that made him want to make movies is a super-sized version of a yarn that was big to begin with, a stupendous adventure that maximizes, and sometimes oversells, its dazzling wares.
    • Metascore: 81
    • Todd McCarthy 80
    Craig comes closer to the author's original conception of this exceptionally long-lived male fantasy figure than anyone since early Sean Connery.