1. Jasmine

   9

   This movie is intelligent, strongly executed, well-crafted, intense, graphic, and compelling. It is one of the best movies of the year. Jolie did an excellent job for a first time director. I will write a more detailed review later. She was brave for tackling this controversial subject. It is from the victim's point of view and should be viewed circumstantially instead of taking any sides politically or religiously. Zana Marjanovic gives an Oscar-worthy performance. It was so heartbreaking. I was horrified, moved, saddened, and even enlightened at times. It was such a powerful and thought-provoking experience. God bless those people affected by the Bosnian War. It also sheds a light on rape was used as weapon in war. It shines a light on atrocities and brings awareness. I decided to contribute to relief efforts in Bosnia and Yugoslavia after watching this film. This is a fine achievement and should be critically acclaimed especially when compared to fluff like The Artist which got high reviews and is incosequential in comparison. This is the type of movie that could have done well at Cannes. It is a shame she has to overcome media corruption, personal misconceptions, and slander. The nasty comments on Rottentomatoes was really upsetting. Plenty of users gave excellent reviews but the site is just displaying two inflammatory post from her haters who believe lies about her and those type of comments shouldn't even be allowed. You could tell some people were just flaming her and have not seen the film. She is NOT a homewrecker and that bs shouldn't even brought into discussion of the movie anyway. No other actress has to deal with that. That lawsuit had no legitimacy and was based on a false, far-fetched claim
   but now you have Fanistons bombarding Rottentomatoes & other sites with ugly attacks that have no basis in truth. Those inflammatory comments should not be allowed on that site. I also want to make note of the fact that Peter Travers review for Rolling Stone was labeled positive here but gotten a rotten rating on the tomatometer. He or the other site needs to fix that. The Salon review was also positive here and labeled rotten on the tomatometer. There is a discrepancy. The rottentomatoes site needs to fix this asap! I really hope by 2012, the ratings will be higher, at around 60% on both sites.… Expand

   • Helpful? 5 of 12 users said Yes.
2. mschoa

   8

   I think the background of the story is something well-informed people should be aware of. This was another Holocaust, although of a smaller scale. I love the fact that Angelina Jolie chose such a serious topic for her directorial and writing efforts. Kudos to her.… Expand

   • Helpful? 1 of 4 users said Yes.
3. FaceTheSlayer

   7

   Ignore all the negative user reviews, most of them are made by ultra nationalists Serbs that are full of hate. This movie realistically pictures war crimes done by Serbs in Bosnian war. THESE CRIMES HAPPENED and whoever denies that is no better than people who deny holocaust. Sure directing could be better but this is Angie's first movie and she did a great job for a first one. As someone who lived on Bosnia during the war (and I still live here) I am surprised with level of Realistic details that are put together in this film. Thank you Angie for caring. A solid 7.… Collapse

   • Helpful? 1 of 1 users said Yes.
4. Sasha62

   1

   For the trained or informed viewer the message becomes utterly
   predictable only after the introduction part of the story. After that
   it is highly insulting for the Serbs and all factually informed people
   who personally know about civil war, especially about that tragic
   region more than what the average Western viewer will ever be allowed
   to know via their usually available media sources that are not
   objective no matter how many times they are keen to repeat that fib.
   Seriously good acting and good standard directing for a cherry-popping
   movie for Jolie... I wish Angelina could have done it so much better
   and fairer with her not really informative story line in her debut that
   smells of dubious and occasionally even obvious subjectivity during her
   "research" period. On the other hand; if Madonna can get a Golden Globe
   for a song nobody really knows, I would not be surprised if she gets an
   Oscar for a movie nobody will remember. As long some positive PR spin
   done for US policy no matter how deeply stereotypically hypocritical it
   is. It's all a game for that part of that franchise; a cruel game of
   mirror-mirage distortion in pursuit of the Holy dollar no matter how
   dirty or otherwise contaminated the financier's banknote really is and
   where it is coming from. Really exposing debut for such a talented
   actress and director but from an unexpected and rather dark angle...… Expand

   • Helpful? 9 of 18 users said Yes.

See all 28 User Reviews