If I could give this movie a zillon rating, I would! It is, by far, the best movie I've ever, ever seen! I am still in chills over such a wonderful journey of a movie experience. When I was watching this movie, I knew I was experiencing something special. Frank Miller, one of my favorite authors, was all over the production of this film - and it paid off brilliantly. Miller himself is brilliant, as the stories painlessly translated to film. I'm not kidding, this is the greatest movie I've ever seen. The angles, the shots, everything. The film is unique; I can't think of any movie that was like this. Put it this way: Metropolis is to sci-fi as Nosferatu is to horror as Sin City is to Noir. I don't know what else to say. I am so happy that Miller's vision was not screwed up by stupid executives who don't even know the first thing about storytelling. Many Hollywood films aren't so lucky, unfortunately. I don't want to end this on a sad note. I just wanna say thank you so much! Thank you for making this movie and showing me that not all Hollywood movies have to suck and only independent or foreign movies rock. I'm still on a high from this movie!!! I just want to shout to the world and tell everyone to see this movie! It's amazing what we people can come up with. Thank you Frank Miller!… Expand

One of the five best films I've ever seen, Sin City is a masterpiece of monumental proportions. The only reason people are giving this film bad reviews is because they have no taste, thought it was boring, and hated how it represented everything wrong with society. That's what the purpose of it is, it represents what is wrong with society and isn't far from reality. This film was amazing throughout and if you get pissed at films that show the dark side of human nature, then just walk away. If you actually have taste in films and have no problems with films that aren't interested in happy endings or showing a good side of humanity, then this is quite the sight. It's determined to be stylish and feel realistic. BEST COMIC BOOK FILM EVER.… Expand

I loved the way the it is presented; a pulp noir thing. I never read the comic so I really didn't know what I was in for when I decided to watch this and I am glad I did. The violence is a bit over the top but it's no big deal, it acts as part of the city helping boost the fact that it's 'Sin City'

Now we get to see who's who in the critics. If you want to find members of the right wing and left wing thought police, look for the low reviews.

To be brief.... Really cool, and lots of fun!

Very close to a perfect adaptation/ If you don't really understand or enjoy noir and pulp writing you're not going to "get" this movie - I suppose it's inevitable that the top box office movie of the week is going to attract those who are perpetually offended and confused, but it's a shame to have them bring down the pointless-but-satisfying Metacritic score. I thought the Josh Hartnett bookends did a good job of holding the barely-connected plot threads together (who said they had to connect anyway? I cannot fathom why so many are bothered by this) and that the film was visually arresting and the dialogue was spot-on classic noir.… Expand

Wonderful movie that succinctly combined elements of morality and violence by displaying their congruencies and contradictions. A very Tarantino-esque film because of it's effective graphic displays and moral representations.

The visual aspect of the movie would have been enough, but the created atmosphere fuses noir and comic books in a way I'd never seen before. And, yes, Jessica Alba is absolutely compelling. Yes, I know that nothing I say here isn't echoing the sentiments of other reviewers, but I did want to counteract (as best I could) some of the negative reviews. Some professional movie critics seem to be astoundingly bitter people...… Expand

Ground breaking, gutsy, mind-boggeling...oozing originality.

Incredible adaptation.

Wow. What can I say. A little over 2 hours later and i'm in awe. Addicted. If there was another showing after the 12:40 am show i saw i would buy another ticket. Absoluetly beautiful!! Cinematography is outstanding. Acting from everyone, including Alba and Murphy were flawless. Script was a perfect blend, not too sappy, not predictable. It was funny, and witty. This will be on peoples minds for a while. Round of applause for Robert Rodriquez and Frank Miller. A+++… Expand

Visually stunning, unlike anything that has come out of hollywood in years. Not the greatest story, but the way in which the movie is done, the creative and fearless violence and subject matter makes it a must see.

Not the best movie of 2005, but certainly the best major studio movie of 2005 and DEFINITELY the best Robert Rodriguez movie ever, who I've never been a fan of (sans Spy Kids). This movie is brilliant and provides the type of kinetic cinematic experience we usually have to wait every 4 years for from QT. Go see it. It is definitely the best movie playing at your multiplex.

WOW!!!

A true original. Will see it again and again. Hope to see MORE coloboration between Miller and Rodriguez.

Most creative and interesting movie I've seen in quite a while. Nicely captured Frank Miller's tone and mythical caricatures.

Phenomenal!

The first part of the three part series is the strongest, but the visuals and the world the movie creates make this a very interesting experience.

That was a great "flick" as Robert Rodriguez would have you call it. It stayed absolutely true to the original comics. My favorite story was The Big Fat Kill, and Clive Owen did a great job with Dwight. The visual style was amazing!

A visually astonishing and endlessly absorbing movie. I can't wait to see it again, and look forward to owning it on DVD so I can linger over it and appreciate it even more.

What the cinema was made for.... but why all the empty seats when the film has only been open for 2 days? Go see it NOW!

This is ART this is NEW. why can't some people get it! I think it's one of the best movies of the year.

Fenomenal! wonderful, who gives under than 9 for this film does not like cinema. believe - me Take off the breath, a trip that if attends with fascinates and that cause giddiness (is half hipnótico, you none is loaded for history without resistance, it seems a feverish delirium), The best movie of the century.

People who say this movie has no depth, It's based on a comic! This movie is not ment to be taken seriously. This is one of the few movies I have seen that was 2 hours long, and when it ended it left me feeling like is was a common length film. The time passes nicely, and it left me satisfied. If you like a good simple movie to enjoy...don't walk, run and rent this!

This movie truly was a masterpeice. It was entertaining and interesting. It was gorey, but in no way simply for the sake of gore. You can clearly see the comic book in the film. It's very well done in a unique style.I just can't beleive William Arnold thought so low of it. I don't say this much about these types of stylistic, modern art type things, but this movie really was extrodanarily done, and it's great entertainment all the way through.… Expand

It would seem campy if it weren't so visually advanced, but the campiness combined with the CGI actually makes for an unforgettable combination.

When I saw Sin City I was blown away by the pace and style that it had. The film not only had an artistic style that has never been seen before in cinema but also strong stories as well as a great cast of characters who, over the course of the film, you care about and support as the film runs its course. The film has a deeply dark tone but also a great humane quality about it. Heres hoping Sin City 2 is soon produced.… Expand

The epitome of sadistic movies. And it was good that way. The trash, the sadism and the cruelty actually gave the film a sense to the non-sensed and nutcase plot. Extraordinary visuals too. The negative point goes to the cast with all the Hollywood stars. I'd prefer less famous actors.

Probably the best comic adaptation ever.

M going to see again saturday.

haven't had this much fun in a theatre since Snatch.

Great gun fights, and visually thrilling!

I didn't want to give it a ten but it is the only score i could justify. I thought of giving it a nine for the sake of appearances but it was better than a nine even though I'm sure i'll find something to gripe about after seeing it a dozen times (which i invariably will). This movie had me mesmerized the whole way through.

You can see the Tarintino influence, but this is a near perfect "graphic novel" transformed into a movie, even the over the top narration fits the style.

The comic adaptation genre has a new movie on which to aspire to. That movie is Sin City. I've not read the books but I am a deep comic background and this movie was a comic come to life. Each screen shot could be cut and paste into a comic book/graphic novel. Big time Tarantino influence from the look to the music. One can only hope that this movie makes mega bucks and that hollywood finally finally finally realizes that the way to do these movies is to stay true to the source material. I don't give 10's very easily... that is reserved for the Casablanca's, but this was a very good movie, the top of its genre, and the creators deserve praise for putting this together in the manner that they did.… Expand

This movie is amazing in both its visuals and dialogue. Anyone who calls it misogynistic or too violent is clearly permanently stuck in living in the eighties. Negative critics of the film are exactly why there are so many rehashed romantic comedies out there today. The bold risks and ingenuity found in the film should be rewarded, not punished.

Totally Awesome!!

Near-perfect adaptaion of a classic graphic novel.....i don't think i will ever look at mustard again wihout thinking of Yellow Bastard.

Simply amazing!!! Right from the very first scene till the end. I do sniff a sequel to this in future. But it is a must watch for those who are fan of Quentin's.

I am not going to repeat what many critics and other have said about this great movie. What are these people who trash the movie on?? The violence?? I've seen worse and being exposed to Raiders of the Lost Ark in the theatre at 9 years old started the desensitization. Great movie, should have been rated R!! Austin Powers anyone?? After the year to year blitzkreig of PG13 movies, it was great to have something i wanted to see rated R and have it be great. There's a reason Ben Stiller is in countless movies, there are sequels to movies like Bad Boys, and why Anchorman was made. There are people out there who like those kind of movies. So as long as those kinds of films are being made, I do hope more great R rated movies will be made as well. Just a question. Why the hell is Batman Begins PG13?!?!… Expand

Best Movie Ever!!!

Knew the storyline - knew the spoilers - knew all about the gore - expected it to suck. Still went to see it because a friend wanted to. Have to say I really enjoyed it. If you're not put off by excessive violence, give it a chance. I think this film easily falls into the "love it or hate it" category.

I really enjoyed this movie. Mind you, if you are the queasy type, you might want to think twice about seeing this movie. As with other Tarantino inspired flicks, the blood flows freely. This movie had me saying "wow" through-out. Great Job.

I think if you don't get this movie, just like Pulp Fiction, you're really going to hate it. But so far, I think it's safe to say that a majority of people get it (like most people did with Pulp Fiction). The Neo-Noir, ultra stylized, ultra-violent theme is translated perfectly from Frank Miller's graphic novels. There are underlying stories here that literally are Shakespearean (King Lear) as well as just a straight love of 50s Film Noir. It's great to see someone (Robert Rodriguez) swing for the fences and actually hit a home run. Easily one of the better movies I've seen in quite some time. Bravo.… Expand

Great acting, directing, cast, visuals, and audio. It followed the comic books almost word for word, which I liked. Overall a very good movie hands down one of my favorite.

As a reader of the graphic novel I have to say that this movie is the best comic book movie ever made because it stays so true to the books themselves. Everyone who gives this movie a bad review has no respect for both art forms (film and comics) nor do they have respect for fantasy itself.

This has to be one of the best movies I have ever seen. With its visuals and its huge cast with the fantastic stories mixed in with some of the most grusome visuals that you will ever see, I would have to say that this movie is perfect.

This movie is amazing!

Most perfect adaptation from paper to screen ever.

Those saying that this movie limits it's audience because of the styling, well no kidding. It was made for the fans of the series and pretty much for no one else. It's a direct adaptation of the series and that is because you cant make a faithful comic book movie and at the same time have it be good for all naive audiences. It's either one or the other, this time someone finally chose to make a faithful rendition of a graphic novel. The movie was by far the best adaptation of a graphic novel to date.… Expand

Whoa this movie is awesome. It was unpredictable, funny and crazy. It's one of those movies you have to watch twice to get what it's about.

Sin City was way more than I expected. It's powerful and provocative without being either a feel good movie or morbidly Se7en-esque. Nitty, gritty, Machiavellian, Darwinian. I was never big on noir, but this film does for the genre what Star Wars (the original trilogy) did for sci-fi.

[***SPOILERS***] Warning Spoilers: To answer Edward's question: Josh Hartnett's character at the beginning and end was a hitman. That's why he killed the woman at the beginning (he was "going to cash her check tomorrow"), and at the end he was hired by the hookers to kill that chick for betraying them. She looked scared because she knew who he was and what he was there to do. Great movie if you ask me. Reminded me of "The Maxx" cartoon from MTV a few years back.… Expand

Almost everything you need in a movie is in this movie.

Amazing. One spectacular looking film. Great casting, great characters, great dialogue. The Characters really fit into their roles. Great action scenes, violent to the max. One hell of a movie.

Visually one of the most impresive films I've ever seen.

The best movie in 2005 so far. One of the very few movies, if any, to go into the characters' internal conflicts and thoughts, giving SIn City an unusual style. The unique visual detail and characters communicating more to the screen rather than to each other breaks most rules of how movies are made. It sort of has that Pulp Fiction storyline to it where it may be hard to understand by some, but loved by others. Fortunately, this, for me, was one of the greats.… Expand

Gritty, stylish and ultra-violent.

Superb movie. Great entertainment and filming technique. When it comes to the violence: It underlines the mentality of the city and makes the movie complete.

Definitely the first best movie of 2005.

It's perfect. Every frame of it.

This movie has a real WOW factor. The artwork and the characters bring a graphic novel to life. And graphic it is! There is a generous helping of violence, which can get a bit much, but you get consumed by great action and cool storytelling! If you can stomach the violence, you'll love this one.

Here lies an example of such an imaginative context such as graphic novel to film conversion can work sublimely. I saw this film, having no idea of the plot or its comic book background, and was blown away. The use of a black-and-white pallette, with splashes of colour where appropriate, is truly masterful in enhancing the mood of the movie. The progression is action-packed, and the characters instantly likeable (Elijah Wood's role as Kevin is particularly imaginative). There are plenty of plot twists thrown into the mix, and a few loose ends that I can only imagine will be tied up in the sequal in 2007. Other points of merit include the OTT and occasionally cringeworthy for level (hold on to your nuts) and I can't think of another movie featuring as many gorgeous women, whom frequently appear nude, exposing the perfection of their bodacious fruit. Incredible.… Expand

By Far Robert Rodrguez best film that he has ever been involved in. I never heard of Frank Miller up until now. But hey I love this mans style. The film opening scene grabbed me and the film never let me loose. The stories were all great. And the photography was beyond words. This movie is definitely one of the best films of the year. And Rourke's acting..... oscar worthy!

I love this movie! I love this movie! I love this movie! I love this movie! I love this movie! I love this movie! I love this movie! I love this movie! I love this movie! I love this movie! I love this movie! I love this movie! I love this movie! I love this movie! I love this movie!!!!!

Film noir n. -A movie characterized by low-key lighting, a bleak urban setting, and corrupt, cynical characters. -The genre or style of such movies. [French : black] check, check, check.

Amazing, wholly orginal movie -- a real breathe of fresh air. If only more directors could be this creative. The only downside is that the movie gets a bit repetitive during the second act. As the guy from Rolling Stone said: "Too much of a good thing." And indeed, it is good.

This movie was great. It was exciting and the visuals were great. The fact that all of the live action was filmed on a green is not even apparent. The actors' actions are believable. The characters are memorable and this movie begs to be watch more than once. The film is "film noir" at it's absolute greatest.

Frickin Amazing!!!! A couple of bad lines and bad props (the gold eye) wont even make you flinch. This is the closest think to true piece of art I have ever seen.

One of the best movies I have ever seen. It was amazingly directed and so unique. The fact that there is so many hotty's in it helps, but it was the visual aspect that really impressed me. This movie in 100% getting bought.

The film has an excellent atmosphere and feel. The film-noir style which is achieved makes the movie all the more brilliant. It is a seamless adaptation of some of Frank Miller's comic books. Unless you're squeamish and can't stand the sight of blood and gore, it's a must-see. The dialogue is delivered smoothly and effectively. The film defines 'cool', not by the strippers and hard-men, but by their surroundings, the musical score, the monochorome~colour effects employed and visual style.… Expand

One of the best movie ever made ! I can't wait to see Sin City 2!

The best movie that tells diffrent life stories throug the eyes of others who try to survive the wild life in Sin City. This movie has great fighting scenes and great effects. Robert Rodriguez really outdone himself in this movie

If you dont appreciate and really love this movie you are pathetic, maybe you know it or maybe you dont, but trust me... you are, either that or your IQ is waaaay too low.

This film is the perfect example of a perfect acting and directing. At first I believed that it would be one more usual movie which is totally different from the comic but when I saw it I changed my mind completely. The transfer from the comic is excellent and as fantastic is the comic so fantastic is the movie. Frank Miller remains the best!

To say this movie is just visually appealing is wrong. Everything is appealing. This movie took me on a ride to and what I saw I was not disappointed with. Wow

Just amazing... I'm stunned... The cinematography is unbelievable! One of the best movies I've seen in years.

Without question, the best movie adaptation of a comic book ever made (to this point). The section with Clive Owen is the weakest. Mickry Rourke gives an amazing performance. Not for the faint of heart.

Practically perfect.

Great movie with lots of humor. Even if you have never read the graphic novels, you wont be lost at all. Although violent, like the books, it is still a great movie with awesome acting. Go and see this immediately.

This film is the best film so far of 2005 for a multitude of reasons, among which are its nearly flawless amalgamation of Frank Miller's gritty pulp sensibilities and post-modern film noir; its willingness to champion the cause of experimental filmmaking; and its possession of an extended middle finger toward the we-gotta-please-everybody, receipt-counting, box-office-dollar obsessed weasels that too often make the artistic decisions in present-day Hollywood. Unlike pre-fab, PG -13 flotsam like, say, the Scorpion King, Sin City has balls. As for the those who critisize Sin City for being juvenile, nihilistic, expliotative or two-dimensional, I would say this: You don't critisize an artistic work in a given medium as being faithful to that very medium, you critisize it in terms of how well it reflects its chosen medium. You don't say that Beethoven or Mozart are of no importance because they continually compose music in the same four-movement style, and show their limitations by always using violins and bassoons; you judge them by how effectively they utilize the medium they've chosen or how well they innovate upon the established conventions of their medium. Calling Sin City (a film that is noir reimagined) nihilistic or mysogynist is like saying that Monet sucks because his pictures are blurry. So...don't listen to whiny, art house bores. See this film! Mickey Rourke is a standout here, and the film is everything a forties-emulating, Sam Spade-loving, Frank Miller-digging, post-modern film noir should be.… Expand

Simply amazing. Every portion of the film was shot perfectly and kept me entertained the whole movie.

Amazing film technique. The characters-especially Mickey Rourke's character- are amazing too. But yes, it is incredibly viiolent. And while the first two big stories were very good, I didn't like the Bruce Willis/Jessica Alba one as much. Still an amazing movie.

This movie is violent and filled with things completely unappropriate for children but if you look at it as a movie (which is the way it was meant to be viewed as) you will probably love it. It shows the story of three different characters and is visually awesome. However, if violence bothers you i would recommend that you see something else.

Wow, 2 hours that don't let go and show what bigger than life can mean on the screen. It seems that Robert Rodriguez is reinventing movies.

Absolutely stunning. A perfect adaptation of Frank Miller's ugly, blood soaked, and violent comics. Visually astonishing, well acted (for its type), beautiful in all ways but one: someone massively fouled up on the soundtrack. The throbbing music from the previews is nowhere to be heard and what was in the movie was so mediocre that I can't even remember it.

I disagree with Keith, who said that in movies you should never be aware that you are watching a movie. Such a traditional, realist interpretation is valid, but is far from the only one. By calling attention to the act of filming, the director(s) open up cinema to new interpretations, revisions and dimensions. Should every single photograph or painting be realistic and accurate? Of course not, that's just one way of playing with the representations of reality. Tell that to Monet! As far as the film, I really liked it, but the different stories were uneven. I loved the Mickey Rourke short, but couldn't care less for the Clive Owen part of the film; not that he was bad, mind you, but the story just didn't appeal to me. That said, this was a very fun, creative film.… Expand

The seattle post can suck it along with any one who says this movie is bad and cliche. the visuals are amazing along with the way the made this awsome comic book come alive.

I LOVE THIS FILM!!

One of the better movies so far this year. Stays faithful to the spirit of the graphic novels and brings Frank Miller's genius to the big screen at last! Eye-popping action sequences and great dialogue. The most fun i've had at the movies this year.

Pastiche plus.

Fantastic, visual and inovative.

Brilliant. Not an adaptation of comic books but a comic book on film, I have never seen anything like it. The visuals stayed with me for days and days afterward. Violent, yes. Bizarre, definitely. But as original and unique as anything I have ever had the pleasure of experiencing. This is the kind of originilaity that Quentin Taratino was hoping for in "Pulp Fiction," but (unbeknownst to most viewers who simply rode the wave of popular appeal), he simply did not accomplish.… Expand

WOW!!!

One of the best comic book adaptions I've ever seen. It was like watching a living comic book. And that's what I think turned off a lot of people to this movie. They didn't understand what was going on. Accept this movie for what it is, and don't compare it to something it isnt. The sex and violence and taboo issues are off the charts. Sad to say it, but in this day and age, if it's not controversial, it's not worth talking about. This movie touched on a lot of sensitive issues, and gave them all the middle finger. It's brash, it's harsh, it's sometimes hard to digest, but that's why it's so good. This movie challenges you to accept it for what it is. And I don't agree with people saying how it's the most violent thing they've ever seen. Watch the news. Atleast when watching Sin City, you know everything is stylized and make believe. As for the visuals, they were completely stunning! Each shot of this movie, individually, is wonderfully framed and composed, and a work of art. It's funny how you either hate this movie, or love it. I, personally, loved this movie. I've seen it 4 four times already, and will probably watch it countless more times after it comes out on dvd!!!… Expand

Artistic, brutal, pulpy, clever, heartfelt. This is just the right kind of role for Bruce Willis ... fits him as well as Butch did in Pulp Fiction. Mickey Roarke was WOW, and Clive Owen did the tongue-in-cheek bit like a master. And EW, how creepy can Elijah Wood possibly be?!?! I don't read comics, so I don't know anything about Frank Miller, but this film was literally a work of art, defying conventions and entertaining. Do NOT take the kiddies, though. And don't see it if violence makes you squeamish.… Expand

AWESOME. JUST AWESOME. Best movie this year so far.

I had an ear-to-ear grin the whole time.