1. JJohnson

   10

   McCormack is brilliant. This is a mix of Monk, the Mentalist and A Beautiful Mind. In response to somebody's criticism that the disorders are too outlandish--you mean too interesting? Would it be that great of a show if the mental disorders were ordinary? It's quirky yet smart, the dialogue is poetic, and the problems are complex yet simple to follow in context. Cook is very likeable and contrary to the opinions of some critics, she is smart and confident in her role. It's a nice break to have youth and excitement along with experience in a head law enforcement role, instead of the stereotypical cold, sarcastic and/or angry narcissist with a control fetish. I hope for many more seasons, and that the pretentious critics don't spoil it for the rest of us.… Expand

   • Helpful? 1 of 3 users said Yes.
2. HoolaTallulah

   8

   I've watched the pilot and one ep. The pilot had a grittier edge, which was no doubt deemed too gritty for the US audience. Suited me tho. Hope Eric McCormack is allowed to return to the darker version of the character as presented in the pilot, which seemed more believable and authentic -- except for the conducting movements (too much like those Mrs Haig taught me in Year 5, or whatever the 10-year-old equivalent is in your part of the world). Fingers crossed that it doesn't become US pap.… Expand

   • Helpful? 0 of 1 users said Yes.
3. theasset

   7

   It's a show that needs time to 'boil' but I'm content with it 'simmering'. Each episode presents great plot twists and help from various medical conditions and although the show is brought down by the abysmal acting of Rachael Leigh Cook it regains points with clever cameo hallucinations and McCormack's continuing outstanding performance.… Expand

   • Helpful? 0 of 0 users said Yes.
4. Rattazustra

   3

   The first episode seemed interesting, but as soon as with the second episode it started to go downhill. The basic concept of the series is not bad, but the execution is. Most importantly, the foreshadowing technique that is used is essentially sloppy and not credible, the plots are clearly based on a very simple formula and so far there is no meta-plot visible. The main character is likable and quirky in a nice way, but unfortunately most of the other characters are not.… Expand

   • Helpful? 0 of 1 users said Yes.

See all 8 User Reviews