Metascore
28 out of 100

Generally unfavorable - based on 31 Critics

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 3 out of 31
  2. Negative: 20 out of 31
  1. Reviewed by: Matt Kelsey
    90
    Ranks with the best of the bunch, given its spooky storyline that fuses religion with down-to-earth characters.
  2. 67
    Less and less a skillfully creepy B-movie and more and more a plea for ecumenical reform.
  3. Reviewed by: Jay Carr
    63
    Could have been a classy thriller. But all the Aramaic in the world can't save it from its own pounding slickness.
  4. Reviewed by: Ken Fox
    60
    Filled with short, rapid-fire takes, edited to a pulsating beat and punctuated with blasts of noise...the style suits the often violent material, as well as Arquette's remarkable physical performance.
  5. Essentially a late-'90s MTV version of "The Exorcist," a half-serious, half-silly piece of business that keeps us involved despite (or maybe because of) being more than a little overdone.
  6. 50
    Possibly the funniest movie ever made about Catholicism. It confuses the phenomenon of stigmata with satanic possession.
  7. 50
    A garish clashing of sacred images and bloody semihorror, this is a movie that defines the category: interesting failure.
  8. Begins with a scene of mass repentance, but the real sin here is a profligate waste of talent.
  9. There's not an authentically scary moment in it.
  10. Reviewed by: David Rooney
    40
    A fiery, convoluted finale fails to deliver any satisfying payoff.
  11. 40
    This serious if assaultively stylish meditation on faith uses traditional elements of religion-based horror in a way that's more innocent than calculating.
  12. By the time the credits roll and a disclaimer informs us that there may, in fact, be a lost gospel of Jesus and that it is being suppressed by the Church, all we can think to say is, "Ah, shaudup!"
  13. Reviewed by: Rod Dreher
    38
    What a bloody disappointment Stigmata is!
  14. Reviewed by: Andy Seiler
    38
    The scariest thing about this appalling and seemingly endless movie is that you paid for your ticket and now have to sit through it.
  15. 38
    Busy, over-stylized mess of a movie.
  16. Repeated lapses in continuity and common sense.
  17. A leaden exercise in what can go wrong when movies attempt to explore mysterious forces with dated special effects and easy symbolism...a soggy mess.
  18. Despite exposition delivered so redundantly and witlessly you think you're in a Kaplan class, Stigmata manages to be incoherent.
  19. 30
    If a movie is going to be so totally derivative, it should at least do a better job of it.
  20. Reviewed by: Tom Keogh
    30
    Can anyone but a lapsed Catholic possibly be interested in this unpleasant, anti-Papist creepshow?
  21. A vicious anti-Catholic diatribe disguised as an audition tape for MTV.
  22. Tom Lazarus and Rick Ramage should be ashamed to have written such nonsense.
  23. Reviewed by: Justine Elias
    20
    An incomprehensible mess.
  24. 20
    A better title for this flick might have been Astigmatism: Nothing ever comes into focus long enough ... to deliver even the faintest sense of fright.
  25. 20
    There should be a place in hell for hacks who turn out derivative terror trash and then pretend they're doing an important investigative piece on Vatican corruption.
  26. Reviewed by: Moira Macdonald
    20
    Lurches on for the better part of two hours with a ludicrous plot and even worse dialogue, interspersed with what look like excerpts from a music video made by some naughty Catholic-school graduates.
  27. (Patricia Arquette's) irritated reactions to her dire situation have all the force of a pet owner's whiny complaints when her feline refuses to use the cat box.
  28. Reviewed by: Jane Hogan
    20
    Save yourself from this mess.
  29. A crude, silly supernatural thriller.
  30. What is bloody and full of holes?
  31. 0
    The only question audiences are likely to be asking their higher power in the wake of viewing the film is, "What the fuck?"
User Score

Generally favorable reviews- based on 29 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 14 out of 17
  2. Negative: 2 out of 17
  1. I honestly do not see how anybody can enjoy this. The story is ok, it could be really good, if it weren't for the disgusting and nauseating cinematography. Freakish looking people, ADD/ADHD style editing, it looks like a LSD trip clip made for MTV. I always wonder what the life of directors looks like who make these films. They cannot possibly be normal and functioning people. Otherwise they would not be able to come up with this superweird crap. Full Review »