The Amish Mafia is secret subculture within the Amish community of Lancaster, PA. They provide protection for their people and deliver righteous justice against those who stand in their way.

Amish Mafia boss Lebanon Levi and his crew hunt down one of their own - a crew member on the run and wanted for arrest by local law enforcement. Mafia soldier John throws a hut party that goes bad when someone shows up with "green corn".

Levi's crew splinters just as his war with Ohio boss Merlin escalates. Each member of Levi's crew has to decide if they will leave or stand by Levi and fight.

Esther and John engage in an Amish Exorcism to save their brother. Levi tries to rebuild his crew. Merlin attempts to regain control of the Ohio Amish community. Alan and Jolin must choose between darkness and light.

Lebanon Levi and his crew look back at Season One of Amish Mafia and look forward to what lies ahead in Season Two.