Mary heads to NYC to visit Kate and gets a bit more than she bargained for. Katie Ann returns to support Mary and clean the B&B. Chapel visits Andrew and Jeremiah gets into trouble with the law.

Miriam tells Matt's wife the truth about their hookup and the group deals with the fallout. Meanwhile, Bates works on launching his acting career and Vonda tries online dating.

The group finally decides to ditch their Amish clothes, but one of them goes missing. Mirium focuses on her dreams, Matt's marriage takes a drastic turn and Bates is blind-sided by his girlfriend back home.

Matt and Bates return to the Amish and Mennonite country for the women they love; Bates visits his mother, who he has not seen since he left.

Miriam's return to New York brings the family back together, but the camaraderie doesn't last long. Bates focuses on his acting career but can't shake the fact that he doesn't have his mother's support.

Having returned home to face their new reality, the group grapples with their decisions to return Amish or stay in the English world.