Steve Sullivan, a successful attorney, brings his girlfriend Ashley home for his father's 60th birthday. There, he learn that his father is planning to sell the family business...and decides to intervene.

The bar is celebrating its 50th year in business and throwing a party. They have invited former and current customers which brings an evening of memories of how it all began.

Steve is upset that his father wants to enter a father-and-son tournament with Owen rather than him. Owen decides he wants to know who his real father is, but Carol cannot remember anything about his conception.

An old comic book of Steve's turns out to be a classic worth a lot of money. The guys try to find a buyer but their dealings backfire on them. Carol and Owen decide to be the entertainment at the bar.

Steve's mother set up his profile on a dating service without telling Steve. When a beautiful woman comes for the first date, it gives the other guys in the bar the idea to set up their own profile for a dating service.

The family is surprised when Steve's aunt comes to visit.

A coworker of Hank's files a complaint against Hank for comments he made. Hank hires Steve to defend him. Susan and her mother try to build their relationship.