10 years ago, Adam Warren disappeared. Today, he finally returns and not all the family members are handling his return well.

Determined to find the kidnapper, Nina devises a dangerous plan to capture him. Willa struggles with her feelings for Bridey, who reveals the shocking truth of Adam's identity.

Willa takes Ben to pass him off as Adam. Now the family is furious to find out that Adam died one week prior. Ben knew everything about Adam, so it was easy to pass him off. In the end, all plans fall to pieces.

Claire deals with the emotional ramifications of Willa's scheming; Nina is determined to find out where Adam disappears to every night; Willa exposes another family secret; Hank's role in Adam's kidnapping is revealed.

Nina is at turmoil with the Warrens as she and Hank try to expose Adam's kidnapper. Willa and Claire's conspiracy reaches a breaking point.

Nina closes in on Jane. Claire suffers an emotional breakdown when visiting Ben and Adam's prison. Secrets finally arise.