User Score
Universal acclaim- based on 348 Ratings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 313 out of 348
-
Mixed: 14 out of 348
-
Negative: 21 out of 348
Review this album
-
-
Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.
-
-
Submit
-
Check Spelling
- User score
- By date
- Most helpful
-
MattE.Jun 27, 2007Lucky, what the f@## are you talking about? Berninger doesn't sound remotely like he's trying to sound like Bob Dylan. Have you ever heard Bob Dylan? Dylan is nasally. Berninger has a deep voice. You could say it's trite and total crap, but the Dylan slam doesn't compute.
-
-
georgeb.Jun 27, 2007those guys can sing
-
-
AndyBJun 29, 2007that they haven't been hailed as the greatest band writing today only proves what floats and what doesn't.
-
-
ZacharyMJul 24, 2007
-
-
PhilMJul 28, 2007This is a stunner. I agree wholehearetdly with "The Onion" review above. At first glance, this seems dullsville. But this album gets right uner your skin with a constant stream of gorgeous, subtle, warming melodies that is not currently letting anything else near the headphones. Album of the year!
-
-
THATMUSICGUYAug 16, 2007
-
-
BillSAug 29, 2007Very, very nice work. Great melodies, and lyrics. Vocals remind me a bit of John Cale. Not meaning to dismiss all the other strengths, but the thing I like the most about the album is the drum work. The only thing holding the album up a bit is the production.
-
-
JustinB.Sep 21, 2007Not as good as alligator, but, what is? this is a very good album.
-
-
JohnD.Mar 13, 2008Its a thing of beauty, a gorgeous sonnet in a storm of denial, a feeling, a mood beyond the crowd.
-
-
BobD.Apr 13, 2008mad mad good. after being introduced by "mistaken for strangers," i used to think they're were too many slow songs on here. but now i relish this album for its somber mood. a slow grower, but highly recommended.
-
-
JonnyR.Jul 13, 2008It seems as though the National intentionally leave off some of their best material from their albums.
-
-
JoeDoeDec 14, 2007It's an absolutely great album! I've heard them for the first time on got radio just a couple of hours before. And yes, I already have the album.
-
-
Mar 10, 2013
-
Sep 14, 2017This is tremendous, amazing, outstanding, lyrically and musically, an instant classic for music and certainly best album of 2007 and best album from the band,
-
Jan 26, 2012Amazing album. The dark, soulful LP from the Brooklyn based band is one of my favorite albums from 2007. Matt Berninger's low, crooning voice and Bryan Devendorf's bruising drums carry this album to great heights.
-
Dec 6, 2017
-
Dec 1, 2012The album reflects the ideas and philosophies of a grown up man and his emotions are displayed in such great depth with some amazing music you haven't heard before. Yes, the album has a serious tone and it carries its own melody which is unique and depressing somewhat.
Clearly the best album of 2000s. -
Apr 12, 2013Far better than its predecessor in terms of arrangements: these songs are truly flawless.
-
May 1, 2013Quite simply, a masterpiece of modern music. Deeply affective, darkly humorous, and as human as music can possibly be. Honestly the best album of the 2000s.
-
Jun 20, 2013I consider this album as a milestone of post-new-wave sound. Furthermore Matt Berninger's voice is outstanding, absolutely unique. Undoubtedly their best album!
-
Sep 21, 2014The slow-burning masterwork of a band at it's creative peak, both totally comfortable with where they are, and yet still pushing their own creative abilities and perfecting their craft. A perfect listen from start to finish.
-
Mar 9, 2016As always and expected from The National, a really amazing and outstanding album. I'd definitely recommend it to all fans of the band or everyone who liked the other albums as well. If you're new to The National, buy it. Now.
-
Dec 12, 2019
Awards & Rankings
-
The National hews too closely to established formula on "Boxer," content to revisit previously explored territory without expanding its sound.
-
Here, most gestures remain a bit too consciously panoramic—elegant enough for comfort but often not chancy enough to be breathtaking.
-
A patchy, flawed effort.