User Score
Universal acclaim- based on 27 Ratings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 24 out of 27
-
Mixed: 1 out of 27
-
Negative: 2 out of 27
Review this album
-
-
Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.
-
-
Submit
-
Check Spelling
- User score
- By date
- Most helpful
-
TimK.Jul 7, 2008lacking the backup vocals of gilmour this album wasn't quite as good as the original tracks, but I enjoyed it greatly, but when I can I still listen to the original Pink Floyd.
-
-
RogerE.Aug 13, 2007Pink Floyd personified. Musical theater. Waters doing what Waters does best....setting the stage for a group of professionals to do their best with some of the best pop material ever written under Water's direction. Simply amazing arrangements. Yes, I have 'Pulse'. This is better.
-
-
JeffRJan 18, 2007An awesome DVD from the consumate showman Roger Waters. The musicians are top shelf and the whole band is awesome together. Waters shows his passion is still 100% there.
-
-
CarlMAug 24, 2006Excellent set and excellent performances. Waters holds the essential ingredient for Pink Floyd. Much much better than Pulse, which is so deadpan its only value for me was to demonstrate that Waters is the only Floyd member who could not be replaced.
-
-
lairdjJan 25, 2006Brilliant. Old Floyd, new Waters, everything is just spot on - better than Pulse, without a doubt.
-
-
jsawyerJun 15, 2005I own 4000 DVDs, almost half are concert videos. If i could keep only one of the lot, this MF would be the one! A M A Z I N G
-
-
RobMMay 24, 2005
-
-
BSinghApr 19, 2005This is the best LIVE DVD I have ever seen! The sound is incredible!
-
-
deniseApr 16, 2005This album rocks!!
-
-
MarkSomethingFeb 2, 2005
-
-
zotherJan 23, 2005This album gets better every time I listen to it. Although I think it misses Gilmore, more than pulse misses Waters. However both these albums highlight that Floyd was better than its component parts. Waters solo work is the best part of this album and sounds great live. I am glad I purchased this album and look forward to Waters next album.
-
-
JakeMJan 9, 2005
-
-
BeverlySMar 16, 2004I think to appreciate this CD as a Roger Waters solo project, separate from PF, you definitely have to have the DVD version. It's absolutely my favorite of all my DVD's. He took me back to 17 again. He took me down memory lane.
-
-
harooniSep 19, 2003Well,I ve always been a fan of Gilmour And I preferred him over Waters after their conflicts but I really admit that THIS ALBUM HAS GOT THE TRUE MAGICAL FLAVOUR OF PF. Specially the greatest solo of Phrygian dominant I ever heard is the new " set the controls of the heart of the sun " huh truly exotic. And the "comfortably numb" played just as Gilmour did in the past.
-
-
LeslieSep 19, 2002Come on people, the man is a lyrical genius. If it werent't for him there wouldn't have been a Pink Floyd and im saying that in past tense because Dave's version of Pink Floyd sucks
-
-
JPAug 6, 2002Better or as good as Floyd in most places... Amused/Miracle/Comf Numb all brilliant
-
-
IsraelK.Jun 7, 2002i live 22 years (in israel) and i never seen any performence that look sound and feel the roger water -live- show
-
-
As the man who wrote Pink Floyd's lyrics, he is far more concerned with their meaning than his old bandmates, and you can hear that in his singing, which is emphasized without robbing the music of its magisterial power. In fact, with a band boasting several guitarists - primarily Doyle Bramhall II, Andy Fairweather Low, and Snowy White - to make up for the lack of Pink Floyd's David Gilmour, Waters effectively recreates the sound of his Pink Floyd work.
-
There's admirable sonic purity to these live recordings, but that only underscores the astonishing lack of verve in the performances.
-
A couple of hours negotiating the treacherous whirlpools of Waters's fears, paranoia and loathing can still prove a slog, mind, no matter how stately the settings.