- Record Label: Guided by Voices
- Release Date: Jun 12, 2012
Generally favorable reviews- based on 13 Ratings
User score distribution:
Positive: 8 out of 8
Mixed: 0 out of 8
Negative: 0 out of 8
Feb 4, 2014So much potential left unfulfilled in the songs
While this Guided by Voices record has plenty of great ideas and hooks, too often the ideasSo much potential left unfulfilled in the songs
While this Guided by Voices record has plenty of great ideas and hooks, too often the ideas are left under developed. The record is nothing if not catchy and the band come together nicely to create a series of melody infused pieces that introduce themselves and then leave before you can get fully acquainted with them.
For a record full of potential, it does leaves you with a sense that the band are spreading themselves too thin, unwilling to let any idea behind but a consequence of this being that most ideas are never given the full attention they deserved. The title track "Class Clown Spots a UFO" is one of three tracks out of 21 to go over the 3 minute mark. This track is a prime example of how good this record could have been with a little bit of focus - a real catchy number and a pop gem. Billy Wire, another one of the albums longer tracks at just over 2 minutes, is a further example.
If we had an track album of expanded tracks such as these aforementioned ones, then it would have been an excellent album. As it is, more than half of the record are brief interludes between songs, and these interludes show more potential than the more developed tracks actually deliver.… Full Review »
Jul 24, 2012Admittedly the latest Guided By Voices' album may initially scare by a surprising number of songs contained on it - because very scarcelyAdmittedly the latest Guided By Voices' album may initially scare by a surprising number of songs contained on it - because very scarcely someone put up 21 different - and more importantly - memorable songs on one disc. "Class Clown Spots A UFO" is however a very interesting compilation of short, little more than minute compositions in various musical genres, and what's more importantly - you can not say that the band did not achieved their established goals. Haunting are even songs like the classic-rock "Blue Babbleships Bay" or hard rock, kept in lo-fi "Tyson's High School".… Full Review »