User Score
Universal acclaim- based on 86 Ratings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 79 out of 86
-
Mixed: 4 out of 86
-
Negative: 3 out of 86
Buy Now
Review this album
-
-
Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.
-
-
Submit
-
Check Spelling
- User score
- By date
- Most helpful
-
SigurðurEApr 4, 2006Grate album and funer are one of the best sog of the year
-
-
JamesCFeb 1, 2007For me this was an unlikely find. I bought several other albums and this was one I was least excited about and proved to be the best of the bunch. I am a my morning jacket fan, but like these guys better, even if it flies in the face of conventional wisdom. Every song ranges from good to great and that means something when so many albums only have a handful of good songs.
-
-
ReubenFDec 19, 2006There are three things to love about Band Of Horses: Ben Bridwell's vocals, Mat Brooke's songwriting, and oh, the cover of their LP. Unfortunately, Brooke is nolonger a member of this band, so for a debut that is not great, but sounds full of promise, it is quite sad to hear that Brooke is gone. Hopefully the band will find another gifted songwriter to complement those gorgeous vocals.
-
-
RockyNOct 6, 2006Awesome CD, just got it yesterday and can't stop listening to it!
-
-
SteveNMar 23, 2006This album is on my list of contenders for Album of 2006. I really like the reverb-intense indie rock tracks which make up the first half of the album and the acoustic vocal duos of the last 3 tracks. Definate recommended buying
-
-
joeyMar 24, 2006this is my favorite album so far this year, love every song. great listen.
-
-
zippyfMar 26, 2006Very good for a first CD. There is a bright future ahead of these guys.
-
-
JakeWApr 12, 2006what is this? a my morning jacket flaming lips clone? the songs are derivative and all sound the same - don't buy this
-
-
CablesApr 20, 2006What is this you ask? Freaking brilliant and possibly the best record you'll hear all year. Thats what.
-
-
KyleMApr 3, 2006While not as earth-shattering as some other recent debuts in the indie world, this album is solid from head to hilt. The obvious Flaming Lips and emo nods are justified, but this album shows a band that has an ability to use simple melodic devices to bolster heart-felt sentiments, not unlike an early Neil Young. Hypnotic and transcendant, an anthemic record for the modern age.
-
-
GabrielPApr 6, 2006Magnificent debut. Great music, good lyrics, great voice.... one of the best albums this year so far, and i'm pretty sure it's going to stay on top all year long.
-
-
DougBApr 7, 2006I love it. Great Album......great debut
-
-
tylerlApr 9, 2006Great Debut! Thick, thin and full of charm. Tyler
-
-
TomMay 12, 2006
-
-
EGoldJul 28, 2006Do not be tricked into buying this CD. Pitchfork's high review convinced me to give it a shot, and it was a complete waste of money. The CD is bland, derivative, and all of the songs sound the same. Their lyrics are laughably generic and there is a complete lack of catchy hooks. This is from someone who likes indie music, too.
-
-
MusicMavenApr 16, 2007To my ears they definitely sound a lot like My Morning Jacket, but lighter and more refined. "The Funeral" and "The Great Salt Lake" rank with the best that MMJ has ever done, and the album as a whole is nearly at that level as well.
-
-
DaveDec 1, 2006This is one of the most over-hyped CD's this year. I've listened several times, and just don't understand why they are getting so much praise.
-
-
GMar 22, 2006Way to rip off My Morning Jacket completely.
-
-
IrkMar 31, 2006this album is my choice, so far, for album of the year. absolutely flawless, or as close as it gets. i'm almost afraid for their sophomore effort. and dude, the guy sounds nothing like wayne coyne. perry farrell, yes. wayne coyne?
-
-
BrandonHApr 15, 2006The record is more effective than most of My Morning Jacket's catalogue. Each track shines as bright as the one before it. Certainly one of the best debuts anyone will hear this year.
-
-
daveApr 17, 2006One of the most honest, gimmick-free records I've heard in the past year.
-
-
DonMApr 18, 2006Solid album. While nothing really stands out as exceptional, there was enough depth here to keep me listening; and is a sign of greater things to come in the future
-
-
WHApr 5, 2006WOW! Wicked Gil is amazing. Funeral is tight. Love this album. Rock roots with alt. edge.
-
-
Piss&VinegarApr 5, 2006Stellar record from start to finish... can't wait to see these guys when they come to town.
-
-
ChaseMay 14, 2006Band of Horses? More like Bland of Horses. I've given it about 4 listens now and I still don't get what the buzz is. It's not horrible, but not good either; very overrated and very average. It's heavily influenced by My Morning Jacket, but I much prefer My Morning Jacket to Band Of Horses.
-
-
right8left33May 22, 2006Another gem. Gotta love the voice.
-
-
LeeGMay 7, 2006Can't stop playing this CD. brilliant. Great Salt Lake, Funeral, Wicked Gil, Monsters, Weed Party, barely a bad song in the bunch. can't wait to see them next month.
-
-
JakegJan 31, 2007amazing. I don't ususally like music so slow, but BOH pulls it off amazingly. Ben's vocals are great, and love the lyrics. Best CD is bought in a while.
-
-
RomanKNov 27, 2006
-
-
JustinBMar 22, 2006great album...the song 'great salt lake' is definately one of the best songs of the year. simply great music.
-
Awards & Rankings
-
It gets a little long in the tooth in places and samey-sounding.
-
It takes a few listens to sink in, but Everything is transcendent, shimmering, layered, and smartass emo-pop fully ready for stadium saturation.
-
Entertainment Weekly[They] show impressive mood-manipulation skills despite relatively simplistic songwriting. [24 Mar 2006, p.70]