User Score
Generally favorable reviews- based on 476 Ratings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 396 out of 476
-
Mixed: 46 out of 476
-
Negative: 34 out of 476
Review this album
-
-
Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.
-
-
Submit
-
Check Spelling
- User score
- By date
- Most helpful
-
BenjiGJan 3, 2006Not perfect, but very very good. Highlights are "Heart In a Cage," opener "You Only Live Once," and the unexpected ballad "Ask Me Anything."
-
-
JoeJan 3, 2006It takes a few listens to love it,but once you love it,you love it!!
-
-
EmmaWJan 3, 2006You gotta give this album a chance. You may not like it the first time round, but keep listening because it's really a great album. It may be a different Strokes' sound, but it's still brillaint.
-
-
JohnnyKJan 3, 2006A masterpiece. Early and nearly insurmountable contender for album of the year. Every track shines with techinically flawless precision. Those who decry the tautness of the performances seem to ignore the potency of the hooks within. And, of course, the lyrics matter much less than the attitude. This is glorious rock and roll circa 2006.
-
-
AaronSJan 3, 2006Terribly boring album. I mean when you rip off Barry Manilow for a melody....c'mon now!
-
-
JoseCuervoJan 3, 2006This is an album that requires a few listens before an accurate judgement can be made. Give it time and it will reveal it's genius to you.
-
-
RobJan 3, 2006While not scaling the heights of 'Is This It?', The Strokes' new album is an improvement on 'Room On Fire' and demands multiple listens to really make sense. Reviewers have been put off by the fact that not every song is an instant grabber like the lead single 'Juicebox', however the album is all the richer for that.
-
-
KurtCJan 3, 2006The Strokes have always been good at disguising their talent for songwriting and brilliant musicianship behind a façade of simplicity. They
-
-
wasp2020CJan 3, 2006Superb album.
-
-
BertJJan 3, 2006about as good as Room on Fire
-
-
kmerJan 3, 2006
-
-
KesMJan 3, 2006Not as good as Is This It, but definitely better than Room On Fire, which I thought was good. The Critics are wrong, trust me. Buy It!
-
-
V.Z.Jan 3, 2006
-
-
ridgebJan 3, 2006
-
-
TomBJan 3, 2006not bad, not great.
-
-
BenJJan 2, 2006The Strokes have perhaps tried to do too many things on this album, it's a tad incoherant, but it works as a collection of songs. There will be plenty of haters--but regardless its still the Strokes, meaning it's going to be one of the best of this year for me. The 8 is in comparison to the previous albums, otherwise it would be a 10 in comparison to other bands.
-
-
JulianGJan 2, 2006Great album, begins with 3 great tracks and ends solidly with a track that reminds us of their first album.
-
-
andrewfJan 2, 2006Not bad, could do with a bit of pruning. On the Other Side is the worst song they've ever written, but other than that, it's solid. A disappointment but it could've been worse, so only the one major complaint. Just can't stand those lyrics.
-
-
KrisBJan 2, 2006I'm giving it a 10 although there are 3 forgetable songs on this album. The other 11 more than make up for it. This is, without a doubt, my favorite Strokes album to date. Their sound has evolved without them changing their style. WHAT AN ALBUM!!!!
-
-
pylertJan 2, 2006this is pretty bad
-
-
talisJan 2, 2006i was afraid it will be crap after two great albums, but luckily i was wrong
-
-
TylerWJan 2, 2006It sucks.
-
-
wardf.Jan 2, 2006After repeated listens, the album really grows on you.
-
-
pierrelJan 2, 2006This third album, indeed changes from the two predecessors, but also changes in quality and not for good. Many of the songs just doesn't seem to take off, or just go down after a good start which just repeats itself through the whole song, which makes the album sort of boring. Still it remains a good album, but doesn't get close from their exceptional "Is This It" work.
-
Awards & Rankings
-
BlenderEarth is the sound of a band coming to that inevitable realization: five patrician perfectionists who've resolved to sound sloppy, even (or especially) at the risk of fucking up. [Jan/Feb 2006, p.98]
-
Turns out what the world was waiting for really was those that saved guitars finally making a record that truly reaped the rewards of their efforts. Is this it? OH GOD YES!
-
First Impressions introduces some subtle new colors to the band's musical palette... but the pervasive sense of inert boredom, which has been noted as a strength in the past, is difficult to shake.