User Score
Mixed or average reviews- based on 45 Ratings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 20 out of 45
-
Mixed: 3 out of 45
-
Negative: 22 out of 45
Review this album
-
-
Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.
-
-
Submit
-
Check Spelling
- User score
- By date
- Most helpful
-
erikoDec 3, 2003kurt will turn around in his grave
-
-
WesFromPuddleoMuddFeb 4, 2005I tried to make an album that was good, but sadly I could only come up with this pile of crap. But hey, the kids will buy it as long as MTV plays it. I'm going to go sell my music to some advertisers... maybe I can support my drinking habits that way!
-
-
robbFeb 23, 2004Your album is poor and your concert was worse. See you in the unemployment line.
-
-
jonathanmJun 30, 2004
-
-
mikesAug 2, 2005This horrible, formula-driven, generic rock. This cd doesen't rock and it is scary that this cd sells at all. Wes's grating whining Cobain rip-off style honestly hurts my ears
-
-
StephenUMay 13, 2006While this most certainly deserves a 0 artistically, I do applaud Puddle of Mudd for continuing to pull down major label schlock rock into the muck and allowing labels who foster artistic expression that goes beyond pathetic teen angst being mewled by a 30 year old to flourish. And thanks to metacritic for allowing me to write ridiculously long sentences.
-
-
RobbieCOct 4, 2007Absolute crap.
-
-
IbgikMay 17, 2007Ah, Puddle of Mudd, - note the 2 D's... misspelling is RAWK! - you constantly play to the absolute lowest expectation. Somehow, you've been allowed to make not one, but TWO major label records. Even my girlfriend, who has from time to time enjoyed a Nickelback song noted amazement that off-key, no talent stuff like this was signed to a major record deal. Sad.
-
-
MariaSJan 5, 2004WES - Please QUIT YOUR WHINING. Enough buddy! Poor Wes, always the misunderstood pathetic boyfriend screwed over by a girl. PLEASE! Get over yourself!
-
-
TheDudeFeb 1, 2004garbage.
-
-
RobSSep 23, 2004What a great way to celebrate Kurt's 10th anniversary suicide than throw in this Puddle of Dudd cd. After a few beers and a joint, nobody'd be able to tell the difference. A+ for originality all the way
-
-
GeorgeC.Feb 7, 2008Cradle of Crap.
-
-
DomS.Jan 16, 2004The only thing on display here is the blandest, most pathetic excuse for "hard rock" since, well, their first album. Or maybe Creed.
-
-
JoeDJan 17, 2004You guys suck! This is the single worst CD I have ever listened to.
-
-
oprahwinfreyMar 18, 2004one good song. The rest sucks big time
-
-
oprahwinfreyMar 18, 2004one good song. The rest sucks big time
-
-
AndyFeb 16, 2005Best selling rock debut of all time? Ever heard of Pearl Jam's Ten? (12 million) And besides, what difference do sales make?
-
-
Jun 2, 2015
Awards & Rankings
-
Third-rate grunge retreads stuffed with overdriven guitars and generic rock-dude melancholia.
-
Fails to whip up much excitement.
-
Entertainment WeeklyIf it's lowest-common-demon heavy rawk you crave, Life awaits. [28 Nov 2003, p.125]