- Critic score
- Publication
- By date
-
As it is, Now or Heaven is good enough but too derivative and uneven to be seen as anything other than a mild disappointment.
-
Under The RadarThere are some strong moments, especially 'Gwen, Now And then,' 'Auctioneer,' and 'Perfect Game,' but those high points are surrounded largely by filler. [Fall 2008, p.79]
-
They're never slavish imitators, and when they goose the velocity--those comparisons gradually fade into classic, shimmery guitar pop. [Nov 2008, p.88]
-
Given the far sunnier cast of the group's debut, it's fair to say Now or Heaven is a document of growing pains.
-
The biggest problem for the Broken West may be that in polishing up their sound they’ve emerged sounding like a wannabe Coldplay.
-
Maybe Now or Heaven isn’t an awful record, but it’s certainly one that strips away everything I felt was compelling about the band to begin with.