User Score
Universal acclaim- based on 161 Ratings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 145 out of 161
-
Mixed: 10 out of 161
-
Negative: 6 out of 161
Review this album
-
-
Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.
-
-
Submit
-
Check Spelling
- User score
- By date
- Most helpful
-
Mar 28, 2012
-
DavidFJan 11, 2008A little pretentious. I don't know if that's the word I'm looking for, but it's something like that.
-
-
WHOct 11, 2006Astounding. I cannot put it down.
-
-
RobertDDec 1, 2006This could be my favorite album of the year!
-
-
mgscOct 25, 2006
-
-
NickYOct 4, 2006The whole album is gorgeous. The entire Crane Wife cycle, (especially part 3) are some of the saddest, most beautiful songs the Decemberists have ever produced, which is saying a lot, seeing as sad and beautiful songs are something of a specialty of theirs.
-
-
MaxFOct 7, 2006Forget Decembrists that you once knew and loved. Forget the dynamic characters, the musical theater, forget the whaling songs, the gimmicky lost legionaries, flues, and parapets. The Decembrists
-
-
AndrewDFeb 1, 2007A true masterpiece, the Decemberists have definitely evolved in their song writing capabilities and Meloys lyrics never cease to amaze. Every song is a world of its own that one can step into, a world that they have brilliantly created.
-
-
JoeBJan 2, 2008
-
-
NathanielNov 14, 2006Despite all the changes they've undergone, and even taking into account the occasional misstep, I can't think of a current band that's as consistently wonderful as the Decemberists. I'm tempted to give them a 10 just for "Sons And Daughters." Incidentally, they're just as much fun live.
-
-
ChadMNov 20, 2006Great record, sort of puts me in mind of Neutral Milk Hotel. This is the first Decemberists album I have heard, so I have nothing to base it on when comparing to their previous ones, but this is solid, in my top 15 albums of the year.
-
-
JohnFNov 6, 2006After much deliberation and close examination, I have decided that this is the best album of the year thus far and the best album the Decemberists have ever made.
-
-
stevewOct 22, 2006literate and gripping , a facinating cd that wil surely be one of the best of the year
-
-
MicSOct 23, 2006Different to previous albums but still excellent, a grower.
-
-
PatWOct 24, 2006Minus "when the war came" every song here is spectacular. Best album of the year.
-
-
mattaOct 26, 2006It is good, not as good as Picaresque or Her Majesty, but definitely equal to Castaways and Cutouts. A few of the prog-rock numbers just don't work, and a couple songs are just plain cheesy, but 3-6, as well as the last few tracks are great.
-
-
crabsodyOct 27, 2006a great album. Definitely one of the best of 2006
-
-
MattLeeMOct 29, 2006Awesome album. Track 2 makes me sadder than it has any right to,
-
-
DanielROct 3, 2006I just bought this CD, and it's amazing. Definitely their best. Where they started out with a very Sea Shanty sound, in their first album, and in Her Majesty, and moved more into a rock/pop sound in Picaresque, and used their epic sound in The Tain, this album fuses all of those together in an amazing way. I may not have good grammar, but I can tell that this album still rocks out hard!
-
-
OliverCOct 3, 2006An absolutely wonderful album. Great new sounds from the band. The only reason it doesn't get a 10 is because it unfortuneately has to be compared with some of the greatest albums ever, namely "Picaresque" and "Her majesty"...
-
-
GetMintyOct 3, 2006We like this.
-
-
JulioCOct 3, 2006Not too good as 'Picaresque", but lyrical and strong melodies.
-
-
faustrOct 4, 2006this album is so incredible it hurts. i cant belive a band could pull somthing like this off. i think that : o valencia" is the best song ever made. therefor this album recives a perfect 10.
-
-
EricOct 4, 2006Certainly a Decemberists' album, but there's nothing certain about it being one of their best. Cut Shankill Butchers and we'll talk.
-
-
BenWOct 5, 2006This album is both musically and lyrically brilliant - their best work yet. 9.5/10
-
-
[Anonymous]Oct 5, 2006Simply outstanding!
-
-
CharlesOct 5, 2006Best album of the year, hands down. Last time I felt this way about an album was "OK Computer".
-
-
KeithMOct 7, 2006I didn't think they could top some of their last albums but I've found myself listening to this more than I ever listened to their other stuff. I'm blown away.
-
-
JonathanLOct 9, 2006Beauty
-
-
YaoYaoCOct 9, 2006Certainly the most experimental album by the Decemberists, The Crane Wife is both nothing like previous releases and yet very similar at the same time.
-
Awards & Rankings
-
Oddly, the unconventional sequencing and measured pace of the album make the fragmented mess hold together quite well.
-
Entertainment WeeklyThe jarring faux-metal riffage of "When the War Came" exposes Meloy's limits, but several of these studies in heartbreak and homicide rank among his most moving. [6 Oct 2006, p.68]
-
Most of The Crane Wife consists of rehashes of Decemberists staples and by-the-books, cookie-cutter indie pop that runs the gamut between pleasant enough ("O, Valencia!") and barely tolerable ("Summersong").