Extraordinary Machine
by Fiona Apple
  • Record Label: Sony
  • Release Date: Oct 4, 2005
User Score
8.7

Universal acclaim- based on 221 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 197 out of 221
  2. Mixed: 12 out of 221
  3. Negative: 12 out of 221

Review this album

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. custodiotiago86
    Sep 4, 2023
    9
    Extraordinary Machine" stands as a pivotal milestone in Fiona Apple's career, marking her most exceptional work to date. This album displays a heightened sense of maturity and musical exploration, showcasing her evolution as an artist. With its intricate melodies and profound lyrical depth, it serves as a testament to her artistic growth and innovation. Undoubtedly, it's a remarkableExtraordinary Machine" stands as a pivotal milestone in Fiona Apple's career, marking her most exceptional work to date. This album displays a heightened sense of maturity and musical exploration, showcasing her evolution as an artist. With its intricate melodies and profound lyrical depth, it serves as a testament to her artistic growth and innovation. Undoubtedly, it's a remarkable accomplishment deserving of a well-deserved 9.… Expand
  2. After_peep08
    Mar 4, 2023
    10
    she's such an icon and this is perfect. fiona apple will always be the music industry
  3. All_ButTrU4
    Feb 11, 2022
    5
    solid set of passionate, angry, marvelously produced songs delivered by a singular voice, and it succeeds by following a muse that doesn't just ignore genre distinctions and pop delineations—it doesn't know they exist.
  4. thegetaway
    Apr 15, 2021
    10
    Extraordinary Machine stands as a powerful piece of work by Ms. Fiona Apple and there really is no need to compare it to her other work. The writing and performances still sound as passionate, creative, strikingly beautiful, magical and unleashed as ever, and in my humble opinion, the album is, truly extraordinary.
  5. panzcoolg
    Nov 20, 2020
    9
    Extraordinary Machine is an understated, excellent album in its own right, but the effects of the record label upon this album can be felt today. Apple's genius, however, manages to shine through despite corporate meddling.
  6. Ricko
    Jul 17, 2020
    7
    More often than not, when an album is made and then shelved, it is with good reason. I haven't heard the first, unreleased version of "Extraordinary Machine" but having listened to the official version many times, I wonder was the issue genuinely with the production etc or was the problem essentially down to the material. This is a fine fine album for sure but in comparison to her otherMore often than not, when an album is made and then shelved, it is with good reason. I haven't heard the first, unreleased version of "Extraordinary Machine" but having listened to the official version many times, I wonder was the issue genuinely with the production etc or was the problem essentially down to the material. This is a fine fine album for sure but in comparison to her other work, this is my least favourite album. There is something a bit too straightforward about too much of it if you get me. For a follow up that took 6 years, it sounds dry and lacking in real flavour. It exists, is enjoyable and then is gone whereas much of the rest of her work leaves me obsessively revisiting. Most people would give a limb to write something as good as this but when you've set a standard as high as she has it doesn't quite measure up. Then again, what do I know?… Expand
  7. sweeterman
    Jun 9, 2020
    3
    This album in simple terms describes chaos, even though the production might look like its all over the place its rawness is unparalleled in the grand scheme of her catalogue.Its the opposite of her last album where the lyrics this time seemed a bit dumbed down.
  8. Predy17
    Mar 11, 2020
    10
    This album it's so underrated that hurts!... This work has many amazing compositions... Extraordinary Machine it's one of the most underrated gems of the 2000's!
  9. ultipop19
    Mar 11, 2018
    10
    This was the record that made Kanye West want to be the hip-hop Fiona Apple. Yet during the three years Apple labored over this ambitiously ornate song cycle, fans wondered if the album would ever see the light of day. After recording with producer Jon Brion, she scrapped the results and rerecorded most of the album from scratch. But with the pained, confessional balladry of "O' Sailor"This was the record that made Kanye West want to be the hip-hop Fiona Apple. Yet during the three years Apple labored over this ambitiously ornate song cycle, fans wondered if the album would ever see the light of day. After recording with producer Jon Brion, she scrapped the results and rerecorded most of the album from scratch. But with the pained, confessional balladry of "O' Sailor" and "Red Red Red," Apple sings with enough emotion to make Machine worth every day of the wait.Extraordinary Machine is the #49 best album of the 00s

    HOT TRACKS:

    *Extraordinay Machine
    *Oh Well
    *Tymps
    *Parting Gift
    *Not About Love
    *Get Him Back
    *Watz    … Expand
  10. Vampire25
    Jul 10, 2012
    10
    I've always known about Fiona Apple, but never gave her the light of day. Hype is an evil thing. The hype surrounding this album however is 100% accurate, it's a fantastic album. Every track is sung with such beautiful honesty from Apple that you really can understand what she's feeling and what she's been through. I love this album with a such a passion. A
  11. jyo_tirmaya
    Mar 12, 2012
    8
    I found this album/CD at the record shop in brand new condition. I didn't buy it originally for certain reasons, but now that I have it, I can't stop playing it. I enjoy this album much more than Fiona Apple's previous albums - although those are very good also. There's something about this album that makes for good listening. The overall sound is lighter than her older material, but itI found this album/CD at the record shop in brand new condition. I didn't buy it originally for certain reasons, but now that I have it, I can't stop playing it. I enjoy this album much more than Fiona Apple's previous albums - although those are very good also. There's something about this album that makes for good listening. The overall sound is lighter than her older material, but it has an easy flow which is very enjoyable. Pitchfork needs to loosen up a little. They are so anal - this album is much better than a 6.2 rating. I give it an "8" which stands for almost excellent. I am so sorry I didn't look for this album when it first came out.… Collapse
  12. gagaforever
    Oct 12, 2010
    10
    Such an amazing album!!!!!! I jknow ever word to every song and can hit all the notes...Fiona apple is such a good singer and deserves to be recognized
  13. AlfonsoG.
    Jun 11, 2007
    10
    Omg, this is her vest album to date! Sure tidal was awesome and so was her other one with the really long name that I cant remember for some reason right now. I think this album just pretty much surpasses any expectations she had for her whole career or any one else. I think as each album she makes, she just continues to do better and better and better and so on. The lyrics and just the Omg, this is her vest album to date! Sure tidal was awesome and so was her other one with the really long name that I cant remember for some reason right now. I think this album just pretty much surpasses any expectations she had for her whole career or any one else. I think as each album she makes, she just continues to do better and better and better and so on. The lyrics and just the melodies and the tempos and everything is sooo on the perfect notch! Every single song has so much to look afford to. This Album will go down as awesome!… Expand
  14. AlexisB.
    May 18, 2007
    10
    LITERALLY my all time favourite album, im not here to talk abt which version is better but to talk abt fiona's work and evolvement as an artist, she broke every line with EM. Jon Brion did an amazing work with Not About Love, Red Red Red and Used to Love Him while Elizondo did an amazing work for get Him Back, O sailor (2 thumbs up!) and Window...but i must say that, to me, some LITERALLY my all time favourite album, im not here to talk abt which version is better but to talk abt fiona's work and evolvement as an artist, she broke every line with EM. Jon Brion did an amazing work with Not About Love, Red Red Red and Used to Love Him while Elizondo did an amazing work for get Him Back, O sailor (2 thumbs up!) and Window...but i must say that, to me, some Brion tracks were totally unhearable (get Him back) and cold (Oh Sailor) while Elizondo did his best to make a world out of every song and indeed, he succeeded...amazing album, one of those that u just listen to but cant quite figure out how to criticize it… Expand
  15. RaffaellaA.
    May 8, 2007
    10
    I'm one of the few who prefer the new version to the baroque one she conceived with Brion - I love it actually! The clean sounds leave room for raw emotions, carried by Fiona's outstanding voice. Obsession (Get Him Back) and wiseness (Better Than Fine) live together well in some of Fiona's best lyrics ever.
  16. CLiam
    Apr 28, 2007
    10
    Her every albums are my all time favourite and I give it a 10 too!
  17. RobbieC
    Apr 11, 2007
    5
    An utter disappointment. The original tracks sounded audacious, ostentatious, grandiose! Unlike any other music being made today. In their finished state, she is part Eminem, part Fiona-on-Quaaludes, all weak and compromised. The only reason this album gets so much as a 5 is because two of the tracks are unchanged and two others might have been improved.
  18. Vin
    Apr 8, 2007
    10
    The leaked version of the album is ten times better than the official release. It was more raw and organic. It had more emotion.
  19. Mike
    Mar 6, 2007
    8
    Very good.... But I liked her 2nd album alot more.
  20. JeremyF
    Jan 20, 2007
    9
    Fiona Apple's "Extraordinary Machine" is a work of genius. From her beyond great lyrics, to her fantastic musical compositions, to her rare, low, smoky, throaty vocals, this is album is very very good. However, I do believe that after 6 years of remaining idol since her even MORE wonderful sophomore effort, "When the Pawn..." (recommended over "Machine"), she would've come back Fiona Apple's "Extraordinary Machine" is a work of genius. From her beyond great lyrics, to her fantastic musical compositions, to her rare, low, smoky, throaty vocals, this is album is very very good. However, I do believe that after 6 years of remaining idol since her even MORE wonderful sophomore effort, "When the Pawn..." (recommended over "Machine"), she would've come back to us with a highly impeccable album outdoing her previous works all together. Still, it deserves it's raving reviews.… Expand
  21. JuliaA
    Oct 25, 2006
    9
    all the waiting time was worth it. brilliant,artsy,and such a relief to hear that Fiona hasn't lost her musical touch at all. all the tracks are good,if not superb.she gave us 'Criminal','Fast As You Can',and theatrical piano driven songs like 'O' Sailor' and 'Tymps'.no more to say but WOW.
  22. DB
    Oct 2, 2006
    8
    One can't help wishing most of the tracks were as creative, original and infectious as the title song. It sets the listener up for something different, and when the cliched rock and roll drums kick in on the second track, its more than a little dissapointing. The fact that this is still an excellent album doesn't change the fact that it is frustrating in its unused potential. One can't help wishing most of the tracks were as creative, original and infectious as the title song. It sets the listener up for something different, and when the cliched rock and roll drums kick in on the second track, its more than a little dissapointing. The fact that this is still an excellent album doesn't change the fact that it is frustrating in its unused potential. Mike whatever his name is (the new producer) is obviously an incompetent label slave, and if the songwriter wasn't as talented as Fiona, this could have been a wreck. If you can stand the injustice, the album is rewarding. If not, download "Extraordinary Machine" and save your money.… Expand
  23. Andy
    Aug 22, 2006
    8
    Really damn good.
  24. Alex
    Jul 27, 2006
    10
    Fuckin great. That's all I have to say.
  25. JonathanC
    Jun 20, 2006
    10
    A flawless transition that shows that every one grows up. Fiona Apple's newest album shows that she has matured, but still contains the right amount of edge that makes her a future classic. A upbeat, yet downbeat assortment of songs that contain their own amount of diversity. With her piano and sailor's mouth Fiona Apple proves that six years can be put to very,very good use.
  26. CoryB
    Apr 29, 2006
    10
    An amazing musical and emotional journey. The best pop album of 2005.
  27. ErazuaA
    Apr 11, 2006
    10
    It is like the perfect companion to Elvis Costello's 1982 album "Imperial Bedroom". Strings never sounded better and tales of love never as sweet and bitter at the same time. You can't hum any song on this album. They defy such easy lilting. And that is a art to be admired.
  28. SamD
    Mar 20, 2006
    9
    i love this album. definately in my top ten of all time, it really reminds me of when aimee mann hit big with "bachelor #2"
  29. brookeb
    Feb 20, 2006
    10
    Love it! I like to alternate all 3 pf Fiona's cds to gte an unbelievable mix of music. fabulous!
  30. StephenS
    Feb 10, 2006
    10
    My favorite CD of 2005
  31. ZachP
    Feb 1, 2006
    10
    Honestly, the best album of the year by far. The songs are elequently written. "Extraordinary Machine", " Not About Love", and "O'Sailor" are some of the best songs of the year. I Love This CD!!!
  32. MylisaM
    Jan 29, 2006
    10
    Fiona Apple is Amazing, her voice is near perfect and she's always a creative lyricist. Beautiful CD.
  33. RochelleT
    Jan 10, 2006
    9
    I like a lot of what was changed about this album from Brion's work to Elizondo's...but there are a few elements I miss, which is why I gave the album a 9 instead of 10. Nevertheless, the album is incredible, and I am happy to hear less misery and some lighter feelings in her lyrics. Her voice is amazing and unique. My favorite!
  34. SteveD
    Jan 10, 2006
    10
    A fantastic cd. Nobody writes or sings a song like Fiona.
  35. ChrisW
    Jan 8, 2006
    10
    Amazingly beautiful... The best music I've heard so far... Such a talented personality and such a beautiful spirit...
  36. Levi
    Jan 7, 2006
    2
    An absolute borefest. Yawn.
  37. vladab
    Jan 7, 2006
    10
    EM is great,perfect, especially "Red, Red, Red" and "O' sailor"!
  38. JonH
    Dec 28, 2005
    10
    It's sad that any reviewer missed the brilliance of this album enough to give it a poor review. Taste is subjective, but even Fiona Apple's style of music is not your bag, the genius of the album is undeniable. It is quite possibly the best lyrical album of the past 5 years, with a daring and innovative quality that puts her in a league all to herself. This album is easily in It's sad that any reviewer missed the brilliance of this album enough to give it a poor review. Taste is subjective, but even Fiona Apple's style of music is not your bag, the genius of the album is undeniable. It is quite possibly the best lyrical album of the past 5 years, with a daring and innovative quality that puts her in a league all to herself. This album is easily in the year's top 5, and arguable number 1. It is truly embarassing for people not to acknowledge that.… Expand
  39. LuisG
    Dec 16, 2005
    9
    Its hard to decide on whos side you are when two of your best friends breakup and well.....alanis morissette has one perspective...beck has another and well tori amos tends to slid away...ex. machine is clearly the album i was waiting for not since these artits before had i felt so connected by hate,neglect and disbelief ....slick production and heavy writing...a maginificant album
  40. JessR
    Dec 13, 2005
    10
    Fiona's new apple is fan-f-ing tabulous!!!! She rocked in the concert I just saw too. Let's hope she keeps touring!
  41. KevinM
    Dec 12, 2005
    10
    Love the EM CD/DVD (Dual Disk), and it gets better with each listen as I notice more elements of each song. I bought all of Fiona's CDs the day after her 11/22/05 Portland show and they've been in heavy rotation in my car, home stereo, and at work since the show....nothing but Fiona. The lyrics, Fiona's piano playing and the rest of it are outstanding.
  42. SeanT
    Dec 11, 2005
    6
    very disapointing. she should have spent more time on and released the jon brion version. it was richer and not cluttered at all.
  43. MattA
    Dec 9, 2005
    7
    Apple really blew it by ditching the Jon Brion production. This album isn't a complete letdown, but compared to her last album, and compared to scrapped sessions, it is a little weak. Her worst album yet.
  44. JanetD
    Dec 5, 2005
    9
    As I listened to the first song my first thought was "shes grown up". No more angry girl, not mellow but an adult who has constructed a wonderful album on her own terms.
  45. LeslieP
    Dec 4, 2005
    10
    I believe it is quite sad to see that other users found this album to be anything other than extraordinary. She has changed the way she sings, in scale specifically. Her tunes, while still angry or contemplative, sound much more whimsical and airy. Yet she manages not to lose her depth and connection to a very earthy roots. I urge the listener to contemplate the lyrics like serious I believe it is quite sad to see that other users found this album to be anything other than extraordinary. She has changed the way she sings, in scale specifically. Her tunes, while still angry or contemplative, sound much more whimsical and airy. Yet she manages not to lose her depth and connection to a very earthy roots. I urge the listener to contemplate the lyrics like serious poetry, and to meditate on the undulating melodies. This is a fantastic collection of music and thought, and is definitely up there with the rest of her albums, if not above them. For a female singer-songwriter artist, she's on top of her game. She puts the 'art' and 'music' in "Music Artist" - for to her this endeavor is not merely to produce something catchy.… Expand
  46. BrianB
    Dec 4, 2005
    4
    I wouldn't have even written a review of this if I hadn't noticed that it's on the "best of 2005" list. Are you serious? I adored "Tidal" and "When The Pawn...", but this is...not good. I've read the other reviews, and I have to agree with terms like "overrated" and "unfocused". She had six years to get inspired; to come up with a great record. I mean, it has its I wouldn't have even written a review of this if I hadn't noticed that it's on the "best of 2005" list. Are you serious? I adored "Tidal" and "When The Pawn...", but this is...not good. I've read the other reviews, and I have to agree with terms like "overrated" and "unfocused". She had six years to get inspired; to come up with a great record. I mean, it has its moments (hence, the 4 rating), but her "best album to date"? Please. If you don't have her other albums, get those, and leave this on the shelf (which, coincidentally, Ms. Apple should've done for you).… Expand
  47. uu
    Dec 4, 2005
    10
    Uncomfortably vaudevillian, tenaciously angry, and with tension built between how many different music forces, fiona's new stuff is bizarrely stunning. Hardly a sad, touching moment, it's not like tidal, but certainly a natural progression from pawn. Her maturity seems to come upon strength and attitude from humble and modest, not the usual progression. She does whatever she Uncomfortably vaudevillian, tenaciously angry, and with tension built between how many different music forces, fiona's new stuff is bizarrely stunning. Hardly a sad, touching moment, it's not like tidal, but certainly a natural progression from pawn. Her maturity seems to come upon strength and attitude from humble and modest, not the usual progression. She does whatever she wants, and it cannot go wrong. While I can imagine some may not get what she's doing here, her artistic bravado is undisputed. The intensity and ingenuity of the album is incredible, and her intent- genuine and moving.… Expand
  48. gabrielai
    Dec 2, 2005
    7
    Rare, mostly beautiful to the ears!
  49. PhilT
    Dec 1, 2005
    10
    Best album of 2005 The crisper production (than the bootlegs) allows Fiona's voice to undulate and twist throughout her complex melodies. The ultimate reward comes after a few listens because her songwriting is just a joy to behold. Her way with words has improved exponentially since When the Pawn. Furthermore, I have listened to this album (with some deviations in the form of some Best album of 2005 The crisper production (than the bootlegs) allows Fiona's voice to undulate and twist throughout her complex melodies. The ultimate reward comes after a few listens because her songwriting is just a joy to behold. Her way with words has improved exponentially since When the Pawn. Furthermore, I have listened to this album (with some deviations in the form of some Sufjan) every evening while I've been stoned for the entirety of fall semester. It's been a good one.… Expand
  50. chuckbarrisa
    Nov 29, 2005
    10
    it took me a while to warm up to it. but after a few listens, i think its better than her other two albums, which are also fantastic. something i listen to over and over again, and one of the best albums i've ever heard. yeah, its that good.
  51. jim
    Nov 26, 2005
    0
    yawn.
  52. orieand
    Nov 25, 2005
    4
    Everyone seems to think Sony shelved the album when it was really Fiona who put the project on hold. Despite the controversy, it doesn't really live up to the hype. With the exception of a few tracks, there's nothing too memorable about this album. Waiting 6 years for this is quite a disappointment...
  53. desiree
    Nov 24, 2005
    10
    amazing!
  54. kyle
    Nov 24, 2005
    10
    great cd, better than id ever expected.
  55. SvenK
    Nov 24, 2005
    10
    This is a brilliant CD! Being a Fiona Apple fan, I have to say that this is definitely my favorite of the three. I have listened to the leaked version, but find myself enjoying this reworked edition way much more. While I do admit to loving the leaked "Better Version of Me", I wouldn't condemn the new version as bad. It's simply different, but not less worthy of credit. Most This is a brilliant CD! Being a Fiona Apple fan, I have to say that this is definitely my favorite of the three. I have listened to the leaked version, but find myself enjoying this reworked edition way much more. While I do admit to loving the leaked "Better Version of Me", I wouldn't condemn the new version as bad. It's simply different, but not less worthy of credit. Most songs have gained strength in contrast to the leaked "demos", thus making this her best album to date. Highly addictive!… Expand
  56. MinhN
    Nov 21, 2005
    2
    I am a huge fan of Fiona Apple and I found this album not even remotely as good as her previous works (tidal, when the pawn...) I've listened to it a half dozen times and have found nothing memorable about it. Sterile, lukewarm, and very very overrated.
  57. EminS
    Nov 16, 2005
    3
    Better version of me, the leaked version 4.0 was so much better than the actual released album version. I am a huge Fiona fan but honey this album plays like a party for a letter opening. The people are there, the booze is there but there's nothing to party about. First 3-4 songs are good and the rest I just can not bring myself to care about. Call it introspective, call it artistic, Better version of me, the leaked version 4.0 was so much better than the actual released album version. I am a huge Fiona fan but honey this album plays like a party for a letter opening. The people are there, the booze is there but there's nothing to party about. First 3-4 songs are good and the rest I just can not bring myself to care about. Call it introspective, call it artistic, call it edgy, call it anything you want, this album is just not very listenable. I'm sorry Fiona, better luck next time.… Expand
  58. TomJ
    Nov 10, 2005
    9
    I love this album. It superbly written, beautifully performed and full of suprises; each time it's listened too.
  59. scottO-
    Nov 9, 2005
    1
    overated. period, most interesting thing about the whole album is the producer controversy.
  60. elizabethr
    Nov 8, 2005
    10
    amazing. astonding. breath taking.... raw, emotional, clever... truthfully and honestly... there are no words... all i know is that my music collection would be severly lacking without this cd... and a great part of my saniety would be lost. thank god for fiona apple.
  61. AlanH
    Nov 8, 2005
    10
    This is a great CD! I had only heard of Fiona Apple, but never really listened to her. I decided to risk it and buy the album. If this is at all like any of her other's it's flawless. The smoky voice, dark and meaningful lyrics, and jazzy piano paint a picture worth watching.
  62. MR.Goodbar
    Nov 5, 2005
    10
    Her richest album to date. She's an artist who's really evolving and not repeating herself. I can only wonder what she can do next. Extraordinary Machine is a classic.
  63. joness
    Nov 3, 2005
    9
    Excellent the original. 6 for the released.
  64. Mezzanine
    Nov 2, 2005
    10
    best album of 2005
  65. MaxD
    Nov 2, 2005
    10
    she's the best...
  66. applefan
    Oct 26, 2005
    9
    Lyrically, I found "Extraordinary Machine" decidely weaker than both her previous albums ("Not About Love" being the biggest exception). The listening experience of the album, however, is incredible and does not disappoint. I prefer the more organic feel of the Jon Brion sessions and while I bought the released version, I will view his as the 'right' version.
  67. AustinA
    Oct 23, 2005
    10
    Apparently the turmoil and struggle to release "Extraordinary Machine" was exactly what Fiona needed to make her best album to date.
  68. KatiK
    Oct 22, 2005
    10
    I love Fiona and this album does not disappoint. It's rich with so many well executed musical experiments. I love that she pushes herself to expand herself.
  69. PerspicaciousCritic
    Oct 21, 2005
    4
    Will someone close to Fiona Apple please advise her to stop those lazy, predictable middle 8s in most of her songs? Such beautiful, filmic music -- Extraordinary Machine, Get Him Back, O Sailor, et al. -- ruined by familiar, conventional bridges. I've listened to the album for the third time and now I've had it. To the bottom of the CD pile it goes! To paraphrase Ms. Apple, Will someone close to Fiona Apple please advise her to stop those lazy, predictable middle 8s in most of her songs? Such beautiful, filmic music -- Extraordinary Machine, Get Him Back, O Sailor, et al. -- ruined by familiar, conventional bridges. I've listened to the album for the third time and now I've had it. To the bottom of the CD pile it goes! To paraphrase Ms. Apple, "Please, please, please, no more grating middle 8s."… Expand
  70. TqMoney
    Oct 20, 2005
    10
    lovely. the original is better and I'm not just saying that because it's cool to say it but still love her.
  71. sM
    Oct 19, 2005
    9
    I was weary of buying this one because unlike most of her fans, i'm not a fan of "When the Pawn..", but this one is quite nice. One of the best CD's i've bought this year.
  72. beeb
    Oct 18, 2005
    5
    over produced and overrated. Songs have lots of potential but her man-boxing overshadows them. can i get an "amen"?
  73. KevinC
    Oct 18, 2005
    9
    As lovelorn and contemplative as ever, Fiona Apple makes her long-awaited return with "Extraordinary Machine" and she does make the most of it. Experimenting with dissidence and jumbled melodies, Apple proves that she's not out to win over the pop world. Her smoky, jazz-lounge voice and fiery storytelling just might win it over anyway.
  74. GeriB
    Oct 17, 2005
    9
    The leaked version was better but its still an amazing cd.
  75. LeonardoF
    Oct 16, 2005
    9
    brion's version get the 10.
  76. musicfan
    Oct 16, 2005
    10
    Simply amazing! However, she should've left the orignal "better version of me" alone.
  77. lucyb.
    Oct 15, 2005
    10
    In my opinion, one of the best albums of the year. Beautiful songs, brilliant lyrics... I just love it...
  78. nicoleb
    Oct 11, 2005
    10
    i had to review this cd for my schools paper, and i gave it a very positive review. everyone i know loves this album, or at least likes it. im glad fiona is back in the mainstream.
  79. Ryan
    Oct 11, 2005
    9
    Wow, a top for the year easy! Apple cooks up Jolie Holland, Be Good Tanyas, Lucinda, Joni, Norah Jones. This album is up there with Sufjan Stevens and Clap Your Hands for Best of Show 2005.
  80. MarcP
    Oct 10, 2005
    9
    Can't get enough of this album. I work in a music store and I insist on playing it in the store non stop. Many listens makes it quite addictive. My favorite bit of the album is on "Oh Well" where the vocal work is quite intimidating.
  81. Matt
    Oct 10, 2005
    6
    Not up to the level of Tidal or When The Pawn.. too many songs have a sterile quality, and that's too bad considering her compelling voice. She's best on low-key songs like O' Sailor and Parting Gift.
  82. malloryr
    Oct 9, 2005
    10
    it is obvious that fiona has formed a different perspective.. but ive always been a fiona fan. ive been anticipating this cd for years.. and it is much worth the wait. brilliantly written lyrics and such charm make this album, i believe, her finest yet.
  83. blarea
    Oct 9, 2005
    10
    awesome. horrid compared to brion's
  84. DougH
    Oct 7, 2005
    3
    You people are kidding yourselves. There's barely a melody to remember on this wandering, unfocused, self-indulgent offering. And I like Fiona Apple.
  85. MikeHBC
    Oct 7, 2005
    9
    I have to say that I am a pretty big Fiona Apple fan, but became a much, much, much bigger fan thanks to the bootleg version of "Extraordinary Machine." Both that version and the released version are getting a 9 from me, but are this close to getting a 10. The released version is nothing short of incredible, and the production of both Mike Elizondo and Jon Brion shine through. A lot of I have to say that I am a pretty big Fiona Apple fan, but became a much, much, much bigger fan thanks to the bootleg version of "Extraordinary Machine." Both that version and the released version are getting a 9 from me, but are this close to getting a 10. The released version is nothing short of incredible, and the production of both Mike Elizondo and Jon Brion shine through. A lot of the tracks, mainly the title track (which is probably my favorite Fiona song ever), "Not About Love," "Get Him Back," "Waltz," and "Tymps" (previously known as "Used To Love Him"), would be standouts on any album by any singer-songwriter since Joni Mitchell. Honestly, if you like anything that could remotely be compared to Fiona, you will absolutely love "Extraordinary Machine." And by the way, if you're a fan, it's definitely worth it to pick up the DualDisc version of "Extraordinary Machine." The music video for "Not About Love" with Zach Galifianakis is amazing, and her live performances (which cover songs on the album, past Fiona hits, and rarities) are not to be missed.… Expand
  86. Brian
    Oct 6, 2005
    9
    Thus is Fiona's biggest musical accomplishment yet. Don't let anyone tell you different.
  87. dustink
    Oct 6, 2005
    10
    its fionas most varied and mature work to date. every song has its own signature, all fionas. a much different experience from the leaked version, that sounded like fiona, trapped singing in a jon brion fantasy world.
  88. LesF
    Oct 6, 2005
    9
    Though Elizondo destroys Brion's interpretations of 'Better Version of Me' and 'Please, Please, Please,' the rest of the new versions are surprisingly decent alternative interpretations of Fiona's marvelous songwriting. The new 'Tymps,' 'Red Red Red,' and 'Not About Love' are all standout tracks, and should eliminate any worries Though Elizondo destroys Brion's interpretations of 'Better Version of Me' and 'Please, Please, Please,' the rest of the new versions are surprisingly decent alternative interpretations of Fiona's marvelous songwriting. The new 'Tymps,' 'Red Red Red,' and 'Not About Love' are all standout tracks, and should eliminate any worries about Fiona "selling out."… Expand
  89. Aaron
    Oct 6, 2005
    1
    Wow, is this one overrated. I hated, hated, hated this record. It should have stayed on the shelf. Sorry, but there was a reason she was hesitant about releasing this.
  90. KurtD
    Oct 5, 2005
    10
    This is her best CD yet (which is really saying something). Though some songs are not quite improvements (perhaps better version of me and not about love), all of the songs are at least as good as the Brion version, and mane are extaordinarily better (red red red, window). Keeping Waltz as the Jon Brion version was a great idea, and the LP as a whole is very effective. I haven't This is her best CD yet (which is really saying something). Though some songs are not quite improvements (perhaps better version of me and not about love), all of the songs are at least as good as the Brion version, and mane are extaordinarily better (red red red, window). Keeping Waltz as the Jon Brion version was a great idea, and the LP as a whole is very effective. I haven't heard chord progressions like these in all of my days.… Expand
  91. SaaibF
    Oct 5, 2005
    9
    As much as i waited for this album i have to say its not what i expected...but its still a good work, she's an incredible songwriter, the way she bends her singing...so fresh and playful..but in ocassions it lacks the raw, mercurial emotion of her previous work.I give her props for trying a new direction than getting stuck with her partner John Brion...do i think it was for As much as i waited for this album i have to say its not what i expected...but its still a good work, she's an incredible songwriter, the way she bends her singing...so fresh and playful..but in ocassions it lacks the raw, mercurial emotion of her previous work.I give her props for trying a new direction than getting stuck with her partner John Brion...do i think it was for better?...dont know...time will tell… Expand
  92. StevenS
    Oct 5, 2005
    8
    A few songs have benefitted from more time and effort, but the notable exceptions are "Please, Please, Pleas", "Get Him Back" and "Not About Love", which suffer greatly from Elizondo's irrelevant production. "Please..." has all the life wrung out of it, while the baseline of "Get Him Back" has been hammered into a dull suggestion of the original. And "Not About Love" loses the A few songs have benefitted from more time and effort, but the notable exceptions are "Please, Please, Pleas", "Get Him Back" and "Not About Love", which suffer greatly from Elizondo's irrelevant production. "Please..." has all the life wrung out of it, while the baseline of "Get Him Back" has been hammered into a dull suggestion of the original. And "Not About Love" loses the strings and it's impact. Great songs filter through mediocrity. Thank goodness for the leaked version.… Expand
  93. RaymundA
    Oct 4, 2005
    10
    Maybe the hiatus is a help for Fiona. Her new album sounds great. I haven't bought the album yet, but I've played it over and over again in a free listening party via Winamp. All I can say is that she is sooooo original, refreshing, and downright talented. She should thank her new producer too. The album's release in the Philippines is not simultaneous in the US, which Maybe the hiatus is a help for Fiona. Her new album sounds great. I haven't bought the album yet, but I've played it over and over again in a free listening party via Winamp. All I can say is that she is sooooo original, refreshing, and downright talented. She should thank her new producer too. The album's release in the Philippines is not simultaneous in the US, which I'll have to wait for 2 weeks or so to buy it.… Expand
  94. Roar
    Oct 4, 2005
    9
    The first and last songs on this album are worth the price of the whole. No surprise they are the two Jon Brion productions. The rest of the album often sounds cheap and not because there are synths and drum machines. It sounds cheap because these elements are mixed with piano and "rock" drums. When its straight electronic or hip hop, it sounds great (like the dreamy "Red Red Red" or the The first and last songs on this album are worth the price of the whole. No surprise they are the two Jon Brion productions. The rest of the album often sounds cheap and not because there are synths and drum machines. It sounds cheap because these elements are mixed with piano and "rock" drums. When its straight electronic or hip hop, it sounds great (like the dreamy "Red Red Red" or the Eminemesque "Tymps"). Other tracks sound lame and early ninetiesish. Nonetheless this is a fun album! Buy it and find the original as well.… Expand
  95. NickC
    Oct 4, 2005
    7
    It's still better than most of the stuff out there, but I equate this to DMB lilly white recordings. Both were much better albums, but just didn't have songs that could be singles.
  96. KatW
    Oct 4, 2005
    10
    I loved the leaked version, and I love this version as well. Elizondo brings some songs to life that I skipped over on the Brion version alltogether. There is still depth and feeling to the songs, this is not Fiona Apple "sold out". I agree with those who say both versions should be heard...they are both masterpieces in their own right.
  97. PhineasP
    Oct 4, 2005
    10
    I believe that a work of art has to create polemic and interesting discussions, because a work of art ultimately is extremely complex and exceeds itself. Fiona has done such a thing this time around, and I couldn't be happier of the result. Like a reviewer said, I hope one day both versions of this cd are released together, because they are two different "readings" of Fiona's I believe that a work of art has to create polemic and interesting discussions, because a work of art ultimately is extremely complex and exceeds itself. Fiona has done such a thing this time around, and I couldn't be happier of the result. Like a reviewer said, I hope one day both versions of this cd are released together, because they are two different "readings" of Fiona's most captivating work.… Expand
  98. SteveK
    Oct 4, 2005
    8
    It's a "very good" album, but the release absolutely butchers a few raw favorites from the Brion production (Red Red Red, Please Please Please). Too much heavy drum and bass where piano and strings are called for. O'Sailor trades swingy backbeat for rock and a faster tempo, and loses. Again, it's enjoyable listening, but the version you can't buy knocks the one you can It's a "very good" album, but the release absolutely butchers a few raw favorites from the Brion production (Red Red Red, Please Please Please). Too much heavy drum and bass where piano and strings are called for. O'Sailor trades swingy backbeat for rock and a faster tempo, and loses. Again, it's enjoyable listening, but the version you can't buy knocks the one you can out of the water with taste and emotion.… Expand
  99. JimmyN
    Oct 4, 2005
    8
    It's tragic to hear this version of this album after hearing the lush, Jon Brion produced version. Silly choices were made on some of the tracks replacing lush orchestration with boring percussion (Not About Love). This album gets a 8 solely because it echos the astounding original. If this album didn't have two versions, it would have been a 5.
  100. marinero
    Oct 4, 2005
    10
    Jon Brion's take is the one I'll cherish; Mike Elizondo's I'll happily listen to on the radio
prev
Page:

Awards & Rankings

31
#31 Best Album of 2005
26
#26 Most Discussed Album of 2005
46
#46 Most Shared Album of 2005

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
84

Universal acclaim - based on 27 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 26 out of 27
  2. Mixed: 1 out of 27
  3. Negative: 0 out of 27
  1. Entertainment Weekly
    100
    The cleaner take on Extraordinary Machine is like a trip to a less cluttered haunted house, and Apple's more nuanced delivery sticks the knife in, but slowly. It's both charming and devastating. [7 Oct 2005, p.72]
  2. The New York Times
    90
    There's a new layer of perspective on her magnificent third album. [3 Oct 2005]
  3. Billboard
    80
    With a less confessional and more confrontational attitude, this long-gestating album has lost the tenderness found on "Tidal" and some of "When the Pawn . . .," but her execution still commands attention. [8 Oct 2005]
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »