Surprisingly complex and unexpectedly mature for a group of early twentysomethings, it's more often that their post-"O Brother Where Art Thou" sexy banjoing brings the surprises. [Winter 2010, p.64]
Feb 5, 2011I suppose I am like the majority of people who's eyes (and ears) where recently opened to Mumford & Sons. Maybe if I were more privy to the world of "alt folk" I would I would not think so much of this album, judging from the scores provided by people with a broader knowledge of this genre. What I can say is that if this is the worst, blandest and emptiest that this genre has to offer, then those of you who are "in the know" are at best very lucky people and at worst very cynical and pretentious.
For the average music lover who's Ipods contain artists ranging from Jon Mayer to Bun B to maybe even Eva Cassidy, this album is a breath of fresh air. Maybe it's because the perspectives of the 2 camps are so different that most will either love it or hate it. Personally, I loved it.… Expand
Sep 27, 2012This is an album that truly changed my perspective on music. Such passion seems to be put into every chord and every word, I am in shock that anyone could not have fallen instantly in love with this band. People need to sit down with this album and really appreciate its message.… Expand
Jan 30, 2011Dear MadJ: You sound like a douchebag. You are exactly the kind of person I hate: The kind of person who doesn't really care that much about music, they just want to sound smart on the Internet. The kind of person that will agree and worship at the feet of Pitchfork. This is an amazing album, a great sound, soulful vocals, and it's just generally a crowd-pleaser. I'm 16 years old and I love it; so does my 55-year old mother. In summary, I point to the two reviews you have written: the one for this album, and one for MBDTF, giving it a 10. Which both happen to be the same scores Pitchfork gave them. Pitchfork publishes their own reviews, we don't need to read the summaries from you.… Expand
Sep 21, 2013There they are, Mumford & Sons. The band I've come to (lovingly) refer to as either folk-pop-rock or pop-folk-rock. It's the best label for this band and their 2 albums. Sigh No More & especially the song "The Cave" exploded this band into, pretty much, worldwide-fame. A thing which breeds hatred in the elitist hipster circles of anything "Indie". So bashing is expected with anything they will do & did from this album on.
But here's a shocker for those people.. It's a great album! They will laugh at that of course, and call them possibly me) names, to afterwards go back to their thumbs-up-asses circle-jerk over "real" (indie)folk bands. Until those get popular of course.
Why is that important to put in front of my review? Because once you realize how that elitist wannabe-intellectual driven part of the music world works, you'll know how to spot & filter it from the "general opinion".
Now onto the actual review.
Sigh No More starts slow & gentle, lamenting over sparse guitar accompaniment. Until about half-way through it becomes an upbeat statement on love, repeated lyrics with building up music. It's a great starter, and will get the feel of the album started.
Let's be real.. everyone knows The Cave. That song was a complete summer hit. And rightfully so, it's got the vibe that fits sunny weather. That may sound odd, but those weird little things are important to me. I don't listen to a song if the "vibe" isn't right. And the Cave (Mumford & Sons in general) and sunny weather go hand in hand.
It truly is a great song.
Winter Winds, ironically, is also a very warm and "sunny" song. Picture a sunny day in early Fall.. such an image goes perfectly with this song. Granted that you don't live in a lifeless place, in that case "point missed".
White Blank Pages is a song of lamenting love, with increasing accompaniment & harmonization. It moves the album to a more minor sound. It's a very good song,
I Gave You All, the first of the 3 darker songs on the album. It's pure heartbreak & searching for as to why it came to that point. Towards the end it treads lightly into the land of rock. This song is one of the highlights of the album.
Little Lion Man is another very well known song from this album. It's not really a favorite of mine, but it's a good song.
Timshel is the gentlest song on the album. It's stays soft during the entire song. It appears to be a song of support, of comfort. "You are not alone in this".
Thistle & Weeds is one of my favorites. It's a song heavy in metaphor, and alludes to two persons who deal with some form of trauma. But where one seems to have abandoned all, the other picks up the pieces of him & himself. It's very atmospheric.
Awake My Soul is kind of gospel-folk with an anthemic build-up. It works, it sounds very good. Can't say it's a favorite, but it a good song.
Dust Bowl Dance is an atmospheric revenge tale, that also alludes to the Grapes of Wrath. It goes into full on rock territory as the song progresses. It's an absolute favorite.
After the Storm is another favorite! It's slowed down & sounding very open. Filling the space with Marcus's vocals & some sparse guitars, and later in the song increasing accompaniment of ambient strings & accordion, and soft (well placed) hits on the toms. It's a very "soaring" song, despite it's slow tempo.
It's a great album, it really is. If you like anything that ranges from rock, folk, singer-songwriters or generally have a wide taste in music, you should definitely give it a show. I would give it an ~8.5/10 but that's not possible here, so I'll stick to 8/10.… Expand
OrenDec 14, 2009Very nice album! Grows on you quickly.
|Lucinda Williams [Reissue] - Lucinda Williams|
|American Radical Patriot [Box Set] - Woody Guthrie|
|Miles at the Fillmore - Miles Davis 1970: The Bootleg Series, Vol. 3 - Miles Davis|
|No Depression [Legacy Edition] - Uncle Tupelo|
|The Satanist - Behemoth|
|Goodbye Yellow Brick Road [40th Anniversary Edition] - Elton John|
|Spaces - Nils Frahm|
|St. Vincent - St. Vincent|
|High Land, Hard Rain [30th Anniversary Edition] - Aztec Camera|
|Moondance [Deluxe Edition] - Van Morrison|
|Bottle Rockets/The Brooklyn Side [Reissue] - The Bottle Rockets|
|12 Stories - Brandy Clark|
|There's a Dream I've Been Saving: 1966-1971 - Lee Hazlewood|
|Memorial - Russian Circles|
|Under Color of Official Right - Protomartyr|
|Haiti Direct: Big Band, Mini Jazz & Twoubadou Sounds, 1960-1978 - Various Artists|
|Rooms of the House - La Dispute|
|The River & the Thread - Rosanne Cash|
|Workbook 25 [Deluxe Edition] - Bob Mould|
|Slow Me Down - Sara Evans|