User Score
Mixed or average reviews- based on 413 Ratings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 190 out of 413
-
Mixed: 87 out of 413
-
Negative: 136 out of 413
Review this album
-
-
Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.
-
-
Submit
-
Check Spelling
- User score
- By date
- Most helpful
-
Feb 8, 2014Drum sounds really AWFUL!! Repetitive, simple and boring riffs; no SOLOS and terrible vocal. Forget thrash, it's not even metal. That's all I can say about this failure. DO NOT LISTEN IT!!!
-
Dec 22, 2012
-
JackS.Sep 13, 2008Just noise.
-
-
AdrianL.Jan 5, 2008Painful to listen to, this album just could have been so much more.
-
-
ElpoA.OJul 9, 2007I love metallica, but this CD is really bad in comparison with EVERYTHING they've done before, even Load and Re-Load.
-
-
Mar 8, 2013I can't believe it. I can't even listen to this album without a break. Are we sure that it is by Metallica? Drums sounds like spoons hitting a pot. And it's difficult to find one good song. Horrible.
-
RobASep 6, 2004
-
-
BenJJun 6, 2006St Shite!!!!!
-
-
Sconf2Mar 3, 2007Metallica is dead T.T
-
-
RickycJun 12, 2003
-
-
seanoJun 17, 2003good god this album sucks something fierce!
-
-
CharliePJun 19, 2003Regardless of what the diehards want you to believe - this Met Diehard speaks the truth - this album is NOT good - not by anyone's standards. I just cashed mine in today at CD Exchnage - so save some money and go there first if you really want this load of garbage.
-
-
AxlRoseJun 19, 2003This is absolutely the worst Metallica album ever. I don't get the good reviews.
-
-
steveyJul 5, 2003
-
-
AndresMAug 7, 2003Horrible, a let down for metallica fans, and bob rock fans, a far cry from coherent, swimming in a sea of twisted noise and chaos. THEY DON"T EVEN USE "THEIR" E and F chords that they SUED TO PROTECT. TERRIBLE, NOT EVEN WORTH DOWNLADING
-
-
miezoNov 9, 2004Use this CD when you're out of toilet paper. It's also a good frisbee. If the CD is for sale, don't buy it. If you can download the CD, don't do it. It will be the worst experience of your life.
-
-
Steven-oNov 9, 2004This ain't METALLICA. This is crap. Retire or get back making real music!!!!
-
-
someguySep 8, 2004this is a piece of fucking shit with only 2 good songs: Frantic and Purify, don't waste your money on this, just download it if you REALLY want it. Oh, by the way, Lars has a receeding hairline and is going bald
-
-
KeithAMay 4, 2005One of my favourite bands (I've been a fan since 1985) - but this is soooo bad. Lars sounds like he's hitting a tin can with a twig. And the "songs" are dire. Very little to redeem this album. Even the live shows were poor - I ended up walking out in despair. Still, the kids liked it.
-
-
MikeOct 17, 2006Garbage
-
-
philbJul 31, 2006St. Rubbish
-
-
KevinH.Feb 6, 2007Possibly the worst album ever made, how a band who made albums like Ride the Lightning, Master of Puppets, and Kill Em' All made this garbage is beyond me.
-
-
YoYoJan 30, 2008Hated it.
-
-
JamesBJul 20, 2009About as bad as music gets, all things considered.
-
-
KevinM.Jun 14, 2003
-
-
billhJun 17, 2003Bizzarre drum sounds, hollow, annoying. no lead GUITARS or melody
-
-
"Morbid"AngelJul 23, 2003Well... I don't know what the hell happened with Metallica after the Black Album. They lost the path. Bad change for me. Made me sick.
-
-
stephenyoJul 25, 2003To address all those people who say that Metallica has changed and evolved...you are only half right. Metallica has certainly changed...but in the wrong way! They have devolved!! If you guys want to hear a real metal band, then check out Iced Earth. They have a much better chance of saving metal than these grumpy old men who are just shadows of their former selves.
-
-
LarsAll-richAug 22, 2003Pure Shit !!! Sounds like bad Pantera!! The drum and guitars are TERRIBLE!!! Where did Metallica put the fuckin' money they made!??? Certainly not in the CD production! I've been following Metallica FOR YEARS, and now, believe me, this is definitely OVER! These assholes pissed me off during the Napstergate, and are not f***ing able to make a godamn good song! DIE METALLICA DIE!!!
-
-
TonyCAug 3, 2003
-
Awards & Rankings
-
MojoThis is miffed and exemplary metal. [Jul 2003, p.108]
-
UncutAgainst all odds, St. Anger constitutes the cutting edge of commercial yet aggressive heavy rock in 2003. [Aug 2003, p.106]
-
The production on St. Anger is abysmal.