American Songwriter's Scores
- Music
For 1,814 reviews, this publication has graded:
-
50% higher than the average critic
-
5% same as the average critic
-
45% lower than the average critic
On average, this publication grades 0.8 points higher than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Average Music review score: 74
Highest review score: | Rockstar | |
---|---|---|
Lowest review score: | Dancing Backward in High Heels |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 1,458 out of 1814
-
Mixed: 352 out of 1814
-
Negative: 4 out of 1814
1814
music
reviews
- By Date
- By Critic Score
-
- Critic Score
It’s hard to follow any Ry Cooder assisted act, but Outlaw coalesces around his own, more intimate sound. We can always use an honest, unpretentious Sunday morning album to enhance the usually easygoing mood, and for those moments Sam Outlaw’s unassumingly enjoyable Tenderheart hits the mark.- American Songwriter
- Posted Apr 13, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
No fear on this album, none. It's an all-out emotional outpour, from the ballads to the rockers, a focus that makes sense in its own way.- American Songwriter
- Posted Jun 14, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
These are not recognizable as songs in the traditional sense; there aren’t choruses, verses and bridges, or really much structure. Rather they are pieces, seemingly of a theatrical play for the ears, where Burnett waxes poetic and philosophical on a variety of disturbing topics.- American Songwriter
- Posted Apr 9, 2019
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
And so it goes for nearly 40 minutes. Clearly, this is not easy listening, but neither is it impenetrable either. Rather, Oberst’s naked presentation and generally obtuse concepts feel genuine and are worth mulling over for a deeper understanding of his expressive and largely enticing thoughts.- American Songwriter
- Posted Oct 13, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Ultimately, Second Nature finds Lucious at a precipitous point in their combined career, a reckoning of sorts that calls for reconciliation and resolve. Then again, if they can keep grooving on propulsive momentum, there’s a good chance they’ll succeed through sheer willpower alone.- American Songwriter
- Posted Apr 19, 2022
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Some may prefer an even more stripped down approach but these tunes benefit from a bit of polish which also helps distinguish Williams from her family’s gruffer music.- American Songwriter
- Posted Feb 25, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
The CD chops out the voluminous chatter, which is one of the strengths of the 1 3/4 hour DVD, but works just fine for on-the-go playback of a dynamic concert.- American Songwriter
- Posted Nov 28, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Nothing breaks four minutes with each selection displaying not just catchy, crisp hooks but production (by him) that captures these songs with a sneaky sheen and rather slick polish. He is most convincing though when the music shifts towards a tougher gospel/swamp vibe as on the self-referential “Take a Long Hard Look.”- American Songwriter
- Posted Mar 14, 2023
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
It maintains an unblemished feel overall, one that stays true to Lund’s traditional template.- American Songwriter
- Posted Jun 20, 2022
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
For all of his disparity, he still holds to some basic pop precepts and a style and stance that find him staying within the realms of a giddy musical motif. There’s little not to like, and those that appreciate abject originality plied from a generally left-of-center persona ought to find K Bay a mostly pleasing proposition.- American Songwriter
- Posted Sep 9, 2021
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Far from coming off as a dry and didactic exercise in replicating an ancient style of playing, Carolina Chocolate Drops has instead reinvigorated old-time music for 21st-century ears.- American Songwriter
- Posted Mar 12, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
This Loud Morning offers an irresistible balance of pop and rock to satisfy existing fans and entice new ones to Cook's musical camp, especially those oblivious to Cook's season seven Idol win.- American Songwriter
- Posted Jul 12, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Perhaps the greatest strength holding The Olms debut together is it’s total lack of pretense: it is what it is... just because. And on that level, it works just fine.- American Songwriter
- Posted Aug 2, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Sun Midnight Sun, which deftly combines all these forces--bluegrass, folk, indie rock, pop, country--into something that sounds smooth and comfortable in its identity, where others might just sound jumbled.- American Songwriter
- Posted Jun 29, 2012
- Read full review
-
- American Songwriter
- Posted Feb 1, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Despite, or perhaps because of, the scattershot musical smorgasbord, Calexico delivers a fitfully enjoyable album, one with enough artistically entertaining moments to make it worthwhile, even if its overall approach is more unfocused than festive.- American Songwriter
- Posted Dec 2, 2020
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Van feels fed up and disgusted, intense and focused, on Born To Sing: No Plan B, but unfortunately, the songs, more often than not, end the conversation there, leaving just a few hard knock lessons and some pretty jazz.- American Songwriter
- Posted Dec 14, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
For all the eccentric performances and approaches, it’s hard to warm up to these songs.- American Songwriter
- Posted Aug 4, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Existing fans won’t be terribly disappointed since there are just enough high points spread throughout the 11 songs to keep the faith. But even they might agree this is far from the act’s best work and even a few notches below its more creatively stimulating predecessor.- American Songwriter
- Posted Jun 4, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
There are highlights here but not enough to leave all but the most rabid Black Crowes fans hoping for much better from a once riveting frontman who can’t seem to consistently catch that ever elusive groove he so effortlessly used to harness.- American Songwriter
- Posted Jun 18, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
God Willin', while a pretty record and certainly head and shoulders above so much of what has been released this year, it is nearly completely bereft of the emotion that we've come to expect from LaMontagne.- American Songwriter
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Coming in at six songs and a lean 22:30 run-time, Blake Shelton's All About Tonight is what I imagine being in the studio audience for an average sitcom would be like.- American Songwriter
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
This will be a good record for backyard barbecues and beers, but not for much serious listening.- American Songwriter
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
When Wayne is on, he's one of the best in the game, but on Human Being he's just killing time with sub-par versions of his far more popular songs – this is a completely superfluous release that lacks the relevance and immediacy of his mixtape works and the quality-control of his albums.- American Songwriter
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
See My Friends proves, if nothing else, that there's simply no force on Earth malevolent enough to destroy a good Ray Davies ditty.- American Songwriter
- Posted Apr 1, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Ultimately the album is easier to appreciate as an unusual, occasionally successful and diverting artistic project that tries to make sense of Davies’ love and apprehension about America, than it is to enjoy.- American Songwriter
- Posted Jun 27, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
The verbal intensity and reaching for the back rows attitude seldom pauses long enough for the listener to catch their breath.- American Songwriter
- Posted Aug 13, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
A predominantly lush, lovely rendered debut that is never less than pleasant. Unfortunately, it’s seldom more than that either as these amiable tunes drift on a dreamy haze that threatens to slide into a memorable chorus or melody, but seldom does.- American Songwriter
- Posted Oct 29, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Production by the professional but slick and synth loving Jeff Lynne sands off the rough edges where Walsh used to thrive.- American Songwriter
- Posted Jun 6, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
It’s far from prime Rundgren and there’s little doubt that most of this would sound better with a full band instead of Rundgren’s “I’ll do it alone and save some money” keyboard dominated music.- American Songwriter
- Posted May 11, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Regrettably, Break The Spell never fulfills its mission of delivering an unabashed rock effort and genuine nuggets of musical magic are few and far between.- American Songwriter
- Posted Nov 30, 2011
- Read full review
-
- American Songwriter
- Posted Jun 12, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
From the album’s clunky title which is simply a list of all 13 tracks with no punctuation, to its incessant use of a brittle, dated drum machine (could Doughty not afford to hire a live drummer with the money he raised from fans to finance this?), most of this feels calculated, deliberate and stiff.- American Songwriter
- Posted Sep 27, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Buffalo Killers aren’t offering you anything you haven’t heard countless times before. Whether or not you want to pick up the phone to have that conversation again will be determined by how much you value novelty.- American Songwriter
- Posted Jun 4, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
As much as the veteran musician should be complimented for his work ethic, he can do better than the overall competent but unexciting Tomorrow’s Daughter.- American Songwriter
- Posted May 24, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
The bulk of these songs feature clichéd lyrics and arm-waving call and response construction.... That said, there is talent and maturity in the song craft, production and playing.- American Songwriter
- Posted Jan 15, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Only rabid Dan/Fagen fans need apply. Everyone else should hang onto their money and spin the still timeless and definitive original recordings.- American Songwriter
- Posted Nov 11, 2021
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Nobody's asking the Killers to restock their eyeliner, but if they insist on making everything so over-the-top, it would serve them well to crack a smile every now and then.- American Songwriter
- Posted Sep 18, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
It's such a disappointment when something you hope is going to be great is, well, such a disappointment. That's the case with Dreams, the latest album from Neil Diamond.- American Songwriter
- Posted Nov 9, 2010
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Where Cale would experiment with horns, vibes, female backing vocals and even restrained orchestration, these tracks stay rooted in a respectful if rather heavy lidded closet.- American Songwriter
- Posted Jul 28, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Overall the Haden Triplets don’t bring enough of anything special to these songs to make the album an overall success.- American Songwriter
- Posted Feb 6, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Matthew Sweet is a journeyman musician whose impressive resume speaks for itself. On the nearly solo Catspaw though, his insistence on being a one-man-band, seemingly dismissing input for songs and especially production, would benefit from other objective ears.- American Songwriter
- Posted Jan 15, 2021
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
As it stands, it’s another entry in Young’s bulging catalog that, like Storytone, Greendale, Le Noise and others, you might play once or twice to see what he’s up to, then return to far more listenable classics like Rust Never Sleeps.- American Songwriter
- Posted Jun 30, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Nothing here hasn’t been done many times before, and much better, by either the original artists (do we need a shockingly feeble-voiced Willie Nelson dueting with Lauper on his “Night Life”?) or others closer to the country aesthetic.- American Songwriter
- Posted May 6, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
As it stands though, Foxygen bit off more than they can chew, leaving ...And Star Power as an occasionally interesting failed experiment.- American Songwriter
- Posted Oct 7, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
It’s hard to imagine anyone other than extreme DM reactionaries finding anything here essential besides the abovementioned tracks [“Soft Touch / Raw Nerve” and “Soothe My Soul”], the stirring “Secret To the End,” and the mid-tempo “Broken.- American Songwriter
- Posted Mar 27, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
The songs are pretty, well-written and well-constructed, but the album as a whole lacks the vitality that would give it necessary variety.- American Songwriter
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Ultimately, it takes a real curmudgeon to dislike this often enchanting, rosy-cheeked, harmony laden alliance, even if you wish it was better. It also does little to display the vocal talents of Kelly Jones who has a handful of terrific albums under her own name but whose own style gets lost here.- American Songwriter
- Posted Apr 12, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Though it’s by no means essential, McCartney 3 will likely still win over legions of compulsive Macca collectors.- American Songwriter
- Posted Dec 18, 2020
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Lovett sounds so tired on all of these songs. All those years with Curb weigh heavily on him, which makes Release Me less of a triumphant good-bye and more of an unceremonious shuffle out the door.- American Songwriter
- Posted Mar 6, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Tiger Suit wears a different skin than her previous recordings, and the highs and lows are obvious.- American Songwriter
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
The veteran guitarist's 36th album is a predominantly instrumental set that tries too hard to do too much over its hour long length.- American Songwriter
- Posted May 24, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
As far as this legendary foursome's new offering, Content, is concerned, well, at least they're not simply cruising on the laurels of their formidable back catalog, and to be fair, Content is no worse than other recent comeback albums by fellow post-punkers Mission of Burma, The Buzzcocks, and Wire.- American Songwriter
- Posted Jan 25, 2011
- Read full review
-
- American Songwriter
- Posted Jan 25, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
More often these tracks wander in search of melodies that seem frustratingly out of reach.- American Songwriter
- Posted Feb 12, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Grey and his band’s drive, energy and enthusiasm go a long way to selling this music but at nearly an hour the effect is diluted. Leaving a handful of the weakest cuts in the vaults and honing the best parts from some of the others would have resulted in a stronger outing.- American Songwriter
- Posted Mar 3, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
There aren’t many hooks to latch onto, his emotional tenor is difficult to gauge, and although his four-piece band works hard to vary its sonic palette, no amount of electronic drums, thickly-layered synths, Spanish guitars and theremins can cover a humdrum set of songs.- American Songwriter
- Posted Oct 8, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
While we give Young a pass for getting new music out, and worthwhile moments are scattered throughout these 10 tunes (that don’t break 40 minutes), just as often you’ll lunge for the track-skip button in exasperation of hearing a major talent and unquestioned cultural icon who has spread himself too thin.- American Songwriter
- Posted Dec 5, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
This whole idea might be a little overdone for everybody by now.- American Songwriter
- Posted Oct 20, 2010
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
While it doesn’t come close to their best work, there is enough spunk and pluck on Mystery Glue to provide the Parker faithful with confidence that better work remains in him.- American Songwriter
- Posted May 20, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
If you buy Bingo! expecting to hear some burning blues, or to hear another of the Miller hits that may have excited you in the '70s, you'll be disappointed either way- American Songwriter
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Give Mayer credit for keeping his languid country pop organic and as rootsy as someone with his honeyed voice can sound. Yet that only reveals the mediocre quality of the bulk of this material and is no excuse for his sleepwalking performance of it.- American Songwriter
- Posted Aug 19, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Ultimately, Back To Land is a little too much “vibe” and not enough “oomph”--a not unpleasurable 40-minute cruise, but one which sometimes feels lo- American Songwriter
- Posted Nov 14, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
The lack of thematic diversity strikes another blow. Certainly, songs about being unhappy with relationships are nothing unusual. However, the ability to write anything meaningful or refreshing about the subject is quickly exhausted on Mine Is Yours.- American Songwriter
- Posted Feb 1, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
A few moments almost save this from moving into the “better luck next time” pile.- American Songwriter
- Posted Nov 11, 2021
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Writing this review would be so much easier if you didn't seem like such a nice dude and if you hadn't had such a disaster fraught year so far. we'd totally let into you about that Miley Cyrus duet and probably scold you for including that atrocious remix of the Rock of Love theme, but frankly, we can't. Not now anyway.- American Songwriter
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
In one sense, it’s commendable that The Strokes are so willing to branch out and take on different styles, yet the effort often sounds overplayed or undercooked.- American Songwriter
- Posted Mar 25, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
In its original, and here remastered, 10 track format (a somewhat superfluous if clean 5.1 remix, audio only DVD is also included), it’s every bit as memorable, timeless and nearly as entertaining if not quite as challenging as Astral Weeks.... But hearing so many working versions of these songs can be a trying, time consuming yet occasionally enjoyable experience.- American Songwriter
- Posted Oct 23, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
The album’s first five songs are dire and depressing—somber, sobering, dark, and downcast. ... It remains to be seen if his audiences will want to sing along in order to maintain Mellencamp’s misery.- American Songwriter
- Posted Jan 31, 2022
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
The Chili Peppers try to strike that same balance on their latest, I'm With You, which may turn out to be a minor installment in their canon but still accomplishes the impossible.- American Songwriter
- Posted Sep 13, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
The lack of the Spector-ish sound, while understandable--Ronnie’s marriage to Phil was legendarily troubled--along with material that is far more powerful and enjoyable in its original form, makes this an experiment that fails on most levels, in particular from Scott Jacoby’s ill-fitting production and sonic approach.- American Songwriter
- Posted Apr 19, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
It’s inoffensive, unobtrusive, innocuous and difficult to hate. But it’s also hard to get excited about as these songs quietly fade into the background like the music of the generally forgotten acts of the ’80s Rouse tries to emulate.- American Songwriter
- Posted Apr 13, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
It shows his restless ambition as an artist, but not his ability to make a great, lasting musical statement.- American Songwriter
- Posted Apr 20, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Ultimately this is a missed opportunity to either unearth obscure, under the radar gems from this era or push Krall outside her comfort zone with challenging interpretations that reveal new meanings in songs we already know by heart.- American Songwriter
- Posted Feb 3, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
There are no crescendos, no peaks or valleys. It's a straight line all the way through, which, as we all know from watching medical dramas on TV, can only mean one thing--the lack of a pulse.- American Songwriter
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Despite two new numbers near the end of this album, New Blood feels, despite it's occasional avant-garde touches, like another holding pattern from an artist who has not been particularly prolific since his 80s commercial heyday.- American Songwriter
- Posted Oct 10, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Noah and the Whale are a fine band, but they seem to have lost their direction.- American Songwriter
- Posted Mar 29, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
If this underwritten, over produced debut for Capitol (after being affiliated with Columbia since 1973) is the best he can muster up in six years, it’s sad to say, it’s time to consider retirement.- American Songwriter
- Posted Oct 21, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
These indie rockers chug along with sufficient energy but few have memorable melodies or hooks. Tucker’s words, while well meaning, are often simplistic and preachy.- American Songwriter
- Posted Apr 30, 2019
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Like his recently unpredictable behavior, it departs from what we’ve come to expect of him: gut-born artistry which connects on a human level. With this LP, he comes off concerned with fitting into an ideological mold, leaving no room for honest feelings and guided prose.- American Songwriter
- Posted Oct 30, 2019
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
North seems destined to forever relegate Matchbox Twenty into the next generation of unremarkable dad rock.- American Songwriter
- Posted Sep 5, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
On Indie Cindy, there’s not a lot of danger, or passion--or excitement for that matter.- American Songwriter
- Posted May 5, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Taken individually, the songs resonate better. But lumped together the effect is claustrophobic and cheerless.- American Songwriter
- Posted Jun 3, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
The end product is an incoherent jumble of occasionally pleasant soft folk with mind-numbingly aimless pieces that seem arbitrarily constructed with little direction or focus.- American Songwriter
- Posted Jun 17, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
The problem is that the band seems to want to go mainstream as it stood in 1995. As a result, they've lost a lot of what made them unique.- American Songwriter
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Rather than sticking to his bread and butter, Busta had his sights set on bold instrumental choices that he didn’t mesh well with, trendy samples that came across as tacky, and far too few awe-inspiring or substantive performances. And because of that, Blockbusta fell short of what it claimed to be.- American Songwriter
- Posted Nov 28, 2023
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Another Country has far too many moments that will have them lurching for the track-forward button while admitting this once talented songwriter needs someone to tell him when his reach exceeds his grasp.- American Songwriter
- Posted Oct 23, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Bridges' rough baritone talk/sung voice just doesn't connect with songs and production that seem lazy, if somewhat less self-indulgent than other successful actors who try to make their mark as singers.- American Songwriter
- Posted Aug 22, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
It's all pleasant and inoffensive but with production that sounds phoned in based on market research, little is memorable.- American Songwriter
- Posted Aug 22, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
This is a tough listen and not in a good way. Most of the songs are little more than unfinished sketches, most just over a minute long, waiting for more inspiration to be completed.- American Songwriter
- Posted Sep 10, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
As 25 Years proceeds, the music grows fussier and increasingly self-impressed in its jazz and world music flourishes, yet even as Sting's voice grows slightly deeper and more textured over the years, he never really evolves or develops as a solo artist.- American Songwriter
- Posted Oct 26, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Farrar’s emotionless approach and the muted instrumentation--issues that thread through all of Union--stultifies any sense of urgency, leaving the listener neither moved nor motivated to do anything other than drift off to sleep.- American Songwriter
- Posted Mar 27, 2019
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Elsie sounds like a step down from his Gaslight Anthem fare, lacking the emotional and regional details that make that band's songs sound so lived in.- American Songwriter
- Posted Sep 22, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
The Green Album ends not with that bang, but with the whimper of Matt Nathanson's "I Hope That Something Better Comes Along" and Rachel Yamagata's "I'm Going to Go Back There Someday."- American Songwriter
- Posted Aug 24, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Dancing Backward sounds more like a Buster Poindexter album than a Dolls one.- American Songwriter
- Posted Mar 15, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Critic Score
Young's idea of fun is based on an uneasy mix of cheap valedictory philosophizing and infantile daydreaming.- American Songwriter
- Posted Sep 14, 2012
- Read full review