- Critic score
- Publication
- By date
-
It’s grandly impressive and points to potentially greater things in the future.
-
Friend and Foe follows through on the potential of their unique sound, proving their wildly great debut was no fluke.
-
The line between cheese and accessibility can be thin, and whistling or handclaps or a hidden track or an overt songwriting method can all reek, but Friend and Foe has, just as ostensibly, no wasted space. The hinge is in the balance the band manages with every inkling of sound or production seeming both spontaneous and stultifying, both labored-over and cast off.
-
Friend and Foe may be part unbridled energy, part thoughtful arrangement, part innovative experimentation, but it's the synthesis of these that makes it so fantastic.
-
Friend and Foe compensates for its occasional melodic malaise with its vigorous, exploratory prosody.
-
No filler, not one outtake, Friend and Foe succeeds in living up to the hype of Menomena's first LP by growing wiser with every loop of sax and blast.
-
Ranging from the epic to the understated, Menomena manages to be innovative and accessible.
-
There are subtle shifts at work with the band, and most allow their shady songcraft to emerge from overt experimentalism--perhaps too aware of its own inventiveness--into the realms of "art-pop."
-
"Friend and Foe" might be the first truly great record of 2007.
-
Hard to describe but easy to recommend.
-
There's a sort of magic in the way this Portland threesome balances structure and chaos, pop and noise.
-
It sounds like a campfire sing-along at the most evil band camp in the underworld.
-
While they are not afraid to bang the drums and rock out, Menomena keep the majority of this album behind a beautiful mask of complimentary melodies.
-
Menomena now has to be regarded as one of today's more intriguing rock outfits.
-
Now that Menomena's technique feels less jarring and daring, though, the group has done a decent job of pouring its euphoric weirdness into bruised, beautiful songcraft.
-
Under The RadarThere is nary a weak track here. [#16, p.93]
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 46 out of 52
-
Mixed: 4 out of 52
-
Negative: 2 out of 52
-
AndrewC.Aug 31, 2008
-
NicolasB.Feb 14, 2008
-
JayKJul 20, 2007