User Score
Generally favorable reviews- based on 334 Ratings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 269 out of 334
-
Mixed: 35 out of 334
-
Negative: 30 out of 334
Review this album
-
-
Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.
-
-
Submit
-
Check Spelling
- User score
- By date
- Most helpful
-
bbOct 23, 2006
-
-
RichSDec 4, 2006Good CD, different than first one so some may not like it. It has a good variety of songs.
-
-
ameliaOct 25, 2006Loved it. It may not be Hot Fuss and does take 2 or 3 listens to appreciate it but so worth it. Thankyou Mr Flowers for a great album :)
-
-
JohnBOct 3, 2006It's not Hot Fuss, but it's still the quality I expect from them. Definitely hints of the Cure and Simple Minds. Some critics just seem to want to hate on them, taking shots at the song writing and such, but the one thing I think they overlook is that the Killers appeal stems primarily from how they make you feel. I just want to turn it up, sing along, and shift into fifth.
-
-
DenmarkJOct 3, 2006I don't get the reviews that say it is not as good as Hot Fuss. Sure, there is no sequal to Mr. Brightside, and I'll admit that I misssed that at first. But it is such a stronger album track for track, and unlike Hot Fuss, gets strongest toward the end. Thanks Killers!
-
-
drewrOct 3, 2006i love this band and i love this album
-
-
EricWOct 3, 2006Ouch. Watch The Killers crash and burn, blue-collar style.
-
-
SBOct 3, 2006While this album makes me wince at a couple of points, i still can't help but be so stoked. They had me at "When You Were Young".
-
-
ToddWOct 3, 2006
-
-
DarenWixsonOct 3, 2006I just bought the CD on-sale, I'm on track 7, had to see the reviews on Metacritic right-away anticipating a great review! Much Better then the 63 the critics gave! I agree with Mojo "An action-packed blockbuster.", we it grow on you, we'll have to wait and see!
-
-
MattD.Oct 3, 2006Not quite as good as Hot Fuss, but no sophomore slump. The Springsteen/U2 sound, when combined with the Killers' new wave touches, makes Sam's Town more than just a copy. The album's end is a little weak, but by then you've had a fun time.
-
-
BrendanMOct 3, 2006Brilliant
-
-
SamanthaOct 3, 2006I really like this album. Its alittle different then there first album 'Hot Fuss' (which I love) but, I think the songs are great and catchy. And Brandon Flowers has an amazing sound. All and all, I love their music, lyrics, and there whole musical style.
-
-
JonSOct 3, 2006not as good as hot fuss. what would be? not really hearing the springsteen influences. hear some simple minds, and u2, and more obscurely - the the. definite 80's type of vibe being dished out. good. more mature than hot fuss...i dig it more each time i listen to it.
-
-
AndrewR.Oct 4, 2006ouch, tough to listen to. I didn't "enjoy the show", and frankly "Sam's town" should only have a population of 3.
-
-
SvenOct 4, 2006
-
-
DanielMOct 4, 2006A rock Opera masterpiece. 80's, Springsteen inspiration and The Killers at their best.
-
-
CarlosVOct 4, 2006Perfect!
-
-
IanOct 5, 2006Sure, it thinks its more important than it is and the lyrics aren't revolutionary. But that doesn't make the music, Flowers' voice or the overall experience any less remarkable. Better than Hot Fuss, and kudos for a band willing to grow a little.
-
-
jimhOct 5, 2006no me gusta
-
-
ConorWOct 6, 2006
-
-
trimmOct 7, 2006im sorry but this sucks.
-
-
PatriziaOct 9, 2006Absolutely great!!
-
-
RyanLSep 19, 2006From the 30 seconds I've heard on each track, yeah. This is Hot Fuss #2, but it doesn't have a single hole. Can't wait to hear the rest.
-
-
PaulOct 12, 2007Awesome album. One of my favourites of 2006.
-
-
DinoMDec 4, 2007This one grew on me. Great album, definitely worth getting, most of the songs are content filled and each with unique appeal. The indie feel is still this for this huge mainstream band. Instant classics which are not easily forgettable. Do yourself a favour and get this album.
-
-
ReviewBoy15Jan 26, 2007The lyrics are'nt amazing at first but it's the way that they combine the lyrics into their instrumental music that gets you hooked. It's not as good as "Hot Fuss" but it's a great record nonetheless. Kept me hooked for weeks on end.
-
-
JohnF.Dec 7, 2007it's a massively under-rated album, probably my favourite of all time.
-
-
ScottWApr 13, 2007This album is not perfect but it is better than "Hot Fuss." While it's true the band sounds more bombastic, they have every right to be with the great songs on this album. The best song is "Bling (Confession of a King)" and the worst is "Bones."
-
-
JimDApr 14, 2007Took about 500 listens for me to comment - I LUV this album. Sprinsteenian lyrics, sweet ambitious songs that demand your attention. The best of music evokes thoughts and images and that's just what this album does.
-
-
CoolKidApr 24, 2007Good record. Key idea though is that each song ranslates VERY VERY well to the live show. See them live.
-
-
HermiaJApr 26, 2007Strong follow up to Hot Fuss that shows growth and more complexity in both the music and lyrics.
-
-
GarethLMay 27, 2007I loved Hot Fuss ! I love Sams Town ! Why do so many people expect artists to churn out the same stuff, album after album ? Musically fantastic ... can't stop listening to it ... cant wait to see where they go next time ! Just LISTEN !!!!
-
-
TrishL.Jun 25, 2007Mediocre album. As a huge fan of Hot Fuss, this was a bitter disappointment.
-
-
SulH.Jun 28, 2007A solid album (albeit a bit too much grandeur) that really grows on you with every spin..
-
-
Guidov.Jun 30, 2007I really don't get this band and their rising popularity. What's special about this? It's pretentious, it doesn't really rock the balls out of your pants and the musicians are nothing special.
-
-
CarlBJul 19, 2007Very mediocre. I do not understand why this band are so popular when people like Mark Lanegan are hardly noticed.
-
-
OligamiSep 11, 2007It is worse than Hot Fuss for sure.
-
-
PaulBNov 21, 2008Awful, was expecting a better album than the last one which was only half good but amazingly this is rubbish all the way through.
-
-
JWFeb 4, 2008One of the most important albums of this decade.
-
-
AnonymousAnonMar 20, 2008Very underrated, vocals are almost god-like at times.
-
-
LoriellMay 1, 2008I think this is a great album....... all of these people that give them bad reviews really need to stop because they are one of the few bands that actually have meaning behind their songs.
-
-
LoriGMay 1, 2008Okay this is really rediculos that some people are giving the album a bad review because brandon flowers speaks his mind! he is one of the few artists of this decade that actually has a brain and he is intitle to a freaking opinoin! And compared to the crap in the radio like freaken Hannah Montanna I think they are the best thing in 20 years!
-
-
BernieG.Feb 26, 2009Give it a few years. Sam's Town will be considered one of the greatest albums of all time. It gets better with each listen.
-
-
SuleimanM.May 18, 2009The best album from the The Killers as of late. (My two cents.) Sam's Town has it's fair share of slow songs, as well as the up beat style that The killers are known for. While it's most certainly different than Hot Fuss, and more or less strays from the formula they are known for, it still manages to be an incredible album. Most certainly recommended.
-
-
DerekBNov 11, 2006
-
-
LukeMNov 1, 2006
-
-
TravisBNov 1, 2006Ughhhh, how can you go from a catchy pop-rock album to this? I laughed out loud at the first track and I don't laugh easily. It's like they aren't sure what made them so damn likeable on "Hot Fuss" so they just throw in all that plus more. Making for a muddled and terribly overzealous composition.
-
-
AJLoomanOct 11, 2006
-
-
VaderisOct 11, 2006I was surprised to see the mixed reviews for this album. I think the melodic vox keyboard and the metamorphasis of Flowers' vocalizations from Hot Fuss were nothing short of breath-taking.
-
-
JMNov 13, 2006
-
-
MadeineHNov 18, 2006Great Album...best tracks are Bones, Read my Mind, When You Were Young,and For Reasons unknown. The Killers have made their follow up album to hot fuss with great sucess!
-
-
ericsOct 12, 2006Does not even compare to Hot Fuss... WAY too much hype. Too much filler; this cd could have been cut down to maybe 2-3 tracks and the rest sounds bland and pointless. The Killers have let me down.
-
-
SonnyOct 13, 2006
-
-
mikes.Oct 14, 2006
-
-
BrentOct 15, 2006Kind of like Green Day's American Idiot, this is a big mainstream rock album that is pretty damn good but will be hated by prestigious rock critics like Pitchfork. OK Computer its not. But I am having more fun listening to this than the new Sonic Youth for Frank Black album for sure.
-
-
Brandy-LeeKOct 16, 2006Awesome album, not better than hot fuss, but not worse than hot fuss either, just much different. Great enterlude and exitlude aswell.
-
-
TheCoffinRobberOct 18, 2006
-
-
joejDec 1, 2006The whole record is in a key that doesn't suit Brandon's voice. He sounds like he is struggling throughout. Musically lame and lyrically the same. Posturing significance doesn't give significance. Disappointingly weak.
-
-
davebDec 11, 2006
-
-
JeffreyHDec 14, 2006
-
-
JosephFOct 22, 2006VERY GOOD...THE killers are great band and the deserve this rank
-
-
ScottMDec 31, 2006Great sophomore effort. With ballads such as "Bling", "Read My Mind", and others The Killers have certainly evolved from their last album, adding a little more rock and subtracting some of the digital pop from Hot Fuss. It will be interesting to see where this will lead.
-
-
ccguyOct 26, 2006Although their musical style has gone through a makeover along with their appearance, The Killers have kept the lure and grandeur of Hot Fuss while creating wonderful dance rock songs that sell. Most of the tunes on this album are exceptional, catchy, and attractive to listen too. This time around, though, the songs are more arena rock friendly and easier to listen too.
-
-
JonHOct 27, 2006
-
-
GarethROct 31, 2006First play - not all that impressed. Second play - still not sure. Third play - actually, it's not at all bad. Fourth play - I can see why the more reliable music press has given it good reviews. Fifth play - really good, probably better than Hot Fuss. The more you play this album, the more it reveals itself and I think it will ultimately prove a more rewarding listen than Hot Fuss.
-
-
derekrSep 28, 2006
-
-
shmittysSep 29, 2006A great album, with a less electronic, more 'American' style sound. I am as much a fan of Hot Fuss as I am of this album. Get out and buy it.
-
-
JonC.Oct 28, 2007It's a acquired taste, but in the end it's a really good and well made album. It also helps that they write this music for a reason, and back up the things they have to say; Brandon Flowers criticized Green Day's "American Idiot" for being anti-American, and then creates "Sam's Town", which clearly says how great America is, no matter what political stance you have.
-
-
MarkJMar 31, 2007A fantastic album! There truly isn't a bad song on the album. Its a better album than Hor Fuss for sure.
-
-
JimP.May 25, 2007This album takes a while to warm up to. The first time I listened, I found maybe two tracks that I liked. But I found the more time I spent with it, the more I liked it. Probably also helped that I saw the Killers live somewhere in the mix. A much better album than what the metascore would have you believe.
-
-
TessaJan 24, 2008This album is packed with amazing tunes. Although I must admit t reminds me of the first one but I'm a fan of everything they do. They rock!
-
-
djcdjcMay 14, 2009I can understand why people may be annoued at the ever present bruce springsteen influence on almost every track. But overall this album is undeniably good. The critics who loved hot fuss mawled this but that shouldn't stop you if you like the killers than i don't see what you shouldn't like about this.
-
-
jacobmNov 16, 2006exellent production, I normally dont listen to this sort of rock that I consider to 'whine' a little, but this album is fantastic
-
-
PCNov 19, 2006
-
-
NickGNov 23, 2006
-
-
dermotmNov 27, 2006cracker-kicks the last ones ass-by the way if you go to c them make sure its not the last show of the tour
-
-
stevebNov 21, 2007
-
-
NicoleGNov 23, 2007absolute garbage
-
-
SebHNov 14, 2008
-
-
Feb 3, 2012
Awards & Rankings
-
UncutThe problem... is that size seems to be used as an excuse for the lack of musical ideas. [Nov 2006, p.102]
-
Crucially, Sam's Town sounds like a complete collection, with a far better strike rate than its predecessor.
-
It is very good.