Shine - Martina McBride
Metascore
67

Generally favorable reviews - based on 8 Critics

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 5 out of 8
  2. Negative: 1 out of 8
  1. For a taste of the power of positivity, look no further than Martina McBride's splendid new album, Shine.
  2. This is a solid, consistent date all the way through that is evidence of McBride's long chart success.
  3. The 42-year-old Kansas native continues to mine that vein on her 10th studio album, "Shine," but although her singing is still strong, polish and predictability are its defining traits.
  4. Working with Nashville hitmaker Dann Huff, this good-time country gal lays on the mid-'80s soft-rock cheese a bit thick on Shine. She fares better when she strips down.
  5. In relying so heavily on a phalanx of Nashville songwriting pros--these 11 songs are the product of 32 credited writers--there's a music-by-committee quality that inevitably creeps in.
  6. 60
    The lungs are in good shape here. [Sep 2009, p.86]
  7. The restraint that she shows in both her vocal performances and her song selection are a refreshing change of pace. Unfortunately, she still lacks the instincts of some of the genre's superior interpretive singers, especially with regard to choosing quality material.
  8. The production is predictably overblown, the lone bright spot being the tender, acoustic 'I’m Trying.'

There are no user reviews yet.