User Score
Generally favorable reviews- based on 117 Ratings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 82 out of 117
-
Mixed: 7 out of 117
-
Negative: 28 out of 117
Review this album
-
-
Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.
-
-
Submit
-
Check Spelling
- User score
- By date
- Most helpful
-
May 6, 2011I grew up with GC. I love them. This cd is my childhood. It's there best cd and they will never come abck to this stuff again. They just won't. This cd is deep and sad. it's a beautiful album and i will not stop loving it. No matter what GC is today.
-
AndreaAug 4, 2009The record has bad songs, I could save only three-four tracks. Not the best by this band, only a commercial product.
-
-
PaulNov 24, 2007
-
-
SimonBJun 1, 2007
-
-
josephaMar 19, 2007a really good album. i just wanna live is a great song
-
-
DavidHSep 24, 2006Pop OR punk, it's bloody awful.
-
-
kylefAug 28, 2006not a bad album could ave been better
-
-
AndrewVJun 9, 2006
-
-
Anika-May 6, 2006SWEETTTTTTTT
-
-
SpikeApr 21, 2006This CD is good and I've listened to it a lot. I still like their first CD, the self-titled album a lot better. And for other stupid poseur morons, it's not the sound that makes it punk, it's the lyrics. Punk's about not falling in line and being yourself. They are punks.
-
-
ffsfssdfsdMar 10, 2006this cd is the best gc cd ever!
-
-
JoeWDec 27, 2005its more of a book then a cd , bt i like it and i think its good bt could be alot better. long time since ive heard any good charlotte nd this was a sad reminder lol
-
-
LaurenPDec 18, 2005chronicles was a real growth from thier last album.it's more serious therefore it made me take them more seriously.the young and the hopeless was much too poppy to truly be considered punk.this album.....i would NOT call it punk but more of alternative rock.
-
-
SofiaNov 24, 2005Some songs are in the cd just for enlarge the cd but any songs aren't without sense...Songs like predictable, meet my maker, walk away, the truth, s.o.s....Generality is a great cd...But young&hopeless is better than this
-
-
TylerANov 18, 2005Good Charlotte are no talented punk wannabes. They do ugly music and they dress punk when they are nowhere near it. They are posers basically who don't do any good music and woulkdn't know proper punk if it was right in front of them. Listen to good music like Bad Religion, NOFX, Blink-182 and Rancid.
-
-
AhmedEOct 24, 2005It's been a while since I heard an album that captivated me this way. Chronicles is definatley a giant step from where they previously were.
-
-
BenSOct 8, 2005Hmmmm, there are some moments worth savouring but they are few and far between. 'Just wanna live', although vaguely hypocritical has spirit and infectiousness and several others are enjoyable enough but really some is torrid. 'chronicles of life and death' is dull and frankly embarrasing while 'predictable' grates
-
-
JemOct 6, 2005This strayed from their previous albums, but showed that Good Charlotte has matured a great lot. Their songs have meaning to them, such as the war, and Joel and Benji sing with such emotion that it reaches your heart. I give this album 10 out of 10.
-
-
SamDOct 3, 2005no talent, and no originality worse than simple plan!
-
-
billbSep 17, 2005wow, just plain bad. use ur money on something less painful, like getting castrated.
-
-
CarlosPSep 7, 2005Cheer up emo kids.
-
-
MeGaNSep 4, 2005i loved their old albums, but it was time for a little change in the way they sang their songs. i think they can sing anything and they'll sound awesome! but loved all their albums even the chronicles.
-
-
JBAug 19, 2005more tattoos than talent...
-
-
Thyz,theAug 19, 2005IT sucks. they cant play instruments, he cant sing and theyre just a total gimmick
-
-
AdrinaAAug 14, 2005the album was nice but i still prefer the old album
-
-
janesAug 8, 2005this album was passable, they had a few good songs in the beginning, but they don't have nearly enough emotion as i thought they would, i think gc should stick to happy music
-
-
GreenDayFanJul 7, 2005
-
-
VezAJun 29, 2005I love the music, its so motivating.
-
-
JACOBFJun 24, 2005Now one of my favorie bands of time. There last CD was better but this one wasn't that bad.
-
-
HannaBJun 13, 2005Good charlotte rocks!! This is real music!! Good Charlotte's songs have meaning, and that I think is imporant- Especially I like The Truth, In this world and Walk Away. But all in all. THEY'RE GREAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
-
-
JesseBMay 8, 2005This is the best album ever !!!!
-
-
kaseysMay 2, 2005i luv good charlotte. theyhave aaweosme sound and beat. i luv grinding to i just wanna live even no its not the best.but i luv the song predictable aonther good gringing song.
-
-
IsabelleApr 21, 2005
-
-
MarieCApr 17, 2005I love the feeling each song portrays. They go from depressingly sad, to deleriously happy, and then to really mature. Good Charlotte is so awesome. Joel looks so cute and then when you add in his compassion for animals, it makes him all the cuter! I love the whole band, though. They're all so different ,yet all so alike.
-
-
siobhanaApr 3, 2005
-
-
kresosMar 21, 2005I just love the "i just wanna live!" song... straight to the point. Good work!
-
-
JoeRMar 7, 2005
-
-
AmberOMar 2, 2005i love the new cd, it shows how they have grown as musicians and writers, the whole cd is different, from song to song, and i think thats an aweosme idea that alot of other bands should try.
-
-
AndrewWMar 2, 2005Well .... this cd has a few good songs... few good riffs.. but other then that I think gc really screwed them selfs over... even though theyve always been pop/emo/punk.. I actually thought The Young and Hopeless was a decent cd... but this cd sucks...Benjamin H pretty much summed up everything I was gonna say... Rock on man!
-
-
ScottHFeb 13, 2005Very good album, some verry classic stuff.
-
-
tylernJan 9, 2005More BS from the leaders of the MTV "pop-punk" bandwagon who believe in the "Lil' Punk Bad Girl" image rather than actual punk. Just thinking about them makes me sick.
-
-
DanielSJan 9, 2005
-
-
krystigDec 26, 2004This CD is awesome! I love almost every song on this CD. Good Charlotte has matured & has a darker side & this CD showed it.
-
-
JillFromTheCrookedHillDec 23, 2004
-
-
bobsDec 22, 2004good charlotte r musical master minds and thats all i can say
-
-
Susan!!!!Dec 22, 2004i really like this album... i have liked all good charlottes music it rocks
-
-
DKDec 20, 2004Good Charlottes AWESOME! This CD is a bit darker then some people are used to, but alot of people will relate to this a lot more then some of their songs, this is definitly their best cd yet!
-
-
peggylDec 16, 2004OMG... i just can´t take the freakin´people who don´t like GC!!!the CD is soooooo cool (hells yeah guys u did a great job again!) it rox specialy mountain n s.o.s. n walk away n of course predictable!
-
-
KarlBDec 12, 2004Its an ace CD the best yet, there not pop rock there punk. best band out.
-
-
ACDec 12, 2004Takes quite a while to get into ... but once you do its really good, not their best album but still wicked !!
-
-
JonODec 10, 2004Hell yeh! This cd is sik just like their other 2 albums. If u don't like the cd nobody is makin u listen 2 it, so instead of criticizin just dont listen 2 it. makes sense 2 me and i am an idiot!
-
-
MattHDec 6, 2004
-
-
jettaoDec 5, 2004good charlotte rox and if u dont think so well thats u
-
-
rifrafDec 2, 2004this cd is a lot like human feces. sure it TASTES good -- but is it nutritional?
-
-
karyDec 2, 2004the second album was the best one ever. this one had songs i did like and some i didnt.
-
-
samANTHAwDec 2, 2004i am GC's #1 fan an u no it!!! GC mixes perfect, awesome, and enlightning guitar riffs!!! I know how to play soooo many of their songs on the guitar!!!! Berk u r the biggest loser ever to live if u hate them!!! I went to their concert and man did they rock live!!! Benji u r the hottest guy living on the earth I LOVE YOU SOOOO MUCH!!!!!!!! What could b better then GC???
-
-
FergalKDec 2, 2004Rubbish - this gang are one of the thousand power-pop/punk clones infesting the rock music scene at present - same boring boring riffs....come up with an original sound!!!
-
-
BenjaminHNov 29, 2004
-
-
EmiNov 22, 2004The second GC album was the best, but this album is worth buying-the mountain, track 10, and chronicles of life and death are my favs. love the rant in Predictable
-
-
kathleensNov 21, 2004This c.d is 1 of there best 1 but i like them all so its all good lol, i love them so much and every one of there songs have a beening to it and you can tell what they are going throug....and i hope they will never stop playing music :).......I LOVE GOOD CHARLOTTE.......
-
-
carolynNov 21, 2004Very good,good charlotte has saved so many lifes!!!
-
-
anisapNov 20, 2004its good, a lot better than Y&H. there's a lot more depth, really good
-
-
KcG.Nov 15, 2004I luv Good Charlotte and i think this is an awsome album!!! i got the death version and its da bestest!! If u said that this album sucks then f**k u!! i luv Joel Madden!!! ~lata
-
-
ShavondaMNov 10, 2004If you get the "Life" Version, wait 5 minutes after the song, "Falling Away", and see what happens.
-
-
michellebNov 10, 2004I LOVED this alburm. it was good charlottes best alburm that has been released. the best songs were 'i just wanna live' and 'world is black'. Good charlotte fans wont be dissapointed
-
-
EvEDNov 9, 2004I absolutly LOVE IT!! I own both the life and death versions and i listen to them every day!!! Good Charlotte is growing up.
-
-
Berk_-_-_Nov 6, 2004Terrible ! Avoid at all costs ! Check out The Hives, The Strokes, The Faint and The White Stripes for REAL music.
-
-
DOOMHAMMERNov 6, 2004
-
-
gchaterssuckNov 4, 2004album is awsome love all the tracks on it both versions rock, n 2 all u gc h8ers F*** YA'LL GC IS GONNA B AROUND 4 A LONG LONG TIME!!!!!
-
-
AngelaH.Nov 4, 2004This album ROCKS! The lyrics are so much better and they are so much more deeper than the previous albums. The song S.O.S, This World is Black, and Ghost of You are my favorites so far. Thanks GC!
-
-
marielOct 31, 2004It was okay, but I think the main reason they got into darker rock was to prove they aren't fake teeny-poppers. Little too depressing for my taste. But they did have some okay songs.
-
-
KelOct 25, 2004
-
-
DavidBOct 25, 2004wow! just look at the first single predictable. predictable that they would release an alblum like this, the whole album btw sucks
-
-
boxcarracerOct 23, 2004Get the death version its awesome!
-
-
BobBOct 23, 2004The E! Online review is pitiful...
-
-
heidiheidiOct 23, 2004this album ROCKS go Good Charlotte
-
-
JPOct 22, 2004Most haters wrote their review BEFORE they listened to it. This is a great CD.
-
-
GoodCharlotteSucksOct 21, 2004This album doesn't even diserve to be rated because good charlotte is the worst band ever their music sucks and it always will
-
-
DanniWOct 21, 2004It Rocks, its not as good as the first, but certainly better then the second, i really like the songs on it and you can tell it took alot to put this together, i cant wait to attend their concert in Grand Rapids Michigan and Nov. 10th 2004 =D
-
-
[Anonymous]Oct 20, 2004IT'S AMAZING! (How such crap can be sold)
-
-
RhettSOct 20, 2004GC have the gift of being catchy and melodic while being capable of great levels of depth. Green who?
-
-
janegOct 17, 2004it sucks.
-
-
jesswOct 16, 2004its a great follow up to "the young and hopeless", it really captures what is going on in there lives,its utterly brilli!!!
-
-
MarkPOct 15, 2004Even their old fans won't like this one...
-
-
TrinaCOct 13, 2004very different. very good. awesome music and great lyrics. :)
-
-
RandehOct 11, 2004This is utterly, the shit, and I mean that in the worst possible way
-
Awards & Rankings
-
The band takes its proven peppy rock sound to new heights.
-
Good Charlotte's confessionals are typical teenage moans, and their music second-hand Green Day.
-
New Musical Express (NME)Half the time, Good Charlotte sound like Blink-182 after the snip, the other half they sound like the Backstreet Boys without the songs. [16 Oct 2004, p.48]