User Score
Universal acclaim- based on 790 Ratings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 708 out of 790
-
Mixed: 19 out of 790
-
Negative: 63 out of 790
Review this album
-
-
Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.
-
-
Submit
-
Check Spelling
- User score
- By date
- Most helpful
-
nuraDec 1, 2006all the songs in this album are superb! i like the new MCR! keep up with the good work, guys!
-
-
BrendanDDec 27, 2006
-
-
JoseROct 23, 2006This album will very quickly become the soundtrack to your life.
-
-
JoshHOct 23, 2006Very, very impressive.
-
-
GerardWOct 23, 2006hope you all like it!
-
-
LindsayA.Oct 23, 2006I love this album!
-
-
JasonwDec 4, 2006awesome album, a little differnt taste then their first , which at first dissapointed me, but now i can't i can't stop listenning to the music, its AMAZING. great job guys on producing another great album.
-
-
JoeAOct 24, 2006
-
-
JamesJOct 24, 2006MCR have made one amazing album here. Pure sonic joy in all of its absurd and over the top brilliance. One of the top 3 albums this year.
-
-
kirstyhOct 24, 2006i think this is a very good album and it should be number 1 on the charts
-
-
JohnB.Oct 24, 2006Reminiscent of Green Day's "American Idiot," but more ambitious. It overreaches itself at times, but overall an excellent record.
-
-
LouDec 5, 2006Anyone else think these guys sound like Styx meets Dashboard Confessional?? Its Arena meets Emo. I dub this new genre - Arenamo!!
-
-
FreddyFOct 25, 2006CLASSIC album. They have far reached what I think anyone thought they could do. TEENAGERS and MAMA are instant classics. Who ever gives it a 2 definitely hasn't heard or given the album a chance and is just biased against the bands for no reason, except for being a critical D*ck. Pretty much discredits them. This album is a MUST PICK UP!!!!! I applaude MCR vision.
-
-
rafaelasOct 25, 2006its a very good album!!!
-
-
JulesEOct 25, 2006Just what we needed - meatloaf meets green day. I read an interview with MCR and they namedropped Rocky Horror as major influence - now if only they had more Dr Franfenfurter and less meatloaf...either way the whole 'new generational music' tag from Los Angeles Times is laughable or perhaps just sad
-
-
SyarufIOct 25, 2006The Best Album In The World
-
-
nickmOct 25, 2006who ever thinks this is crap is thinking too hard, not everything has to be refered back to your glory days
-
-
TomHOct 25, 2006Sorry bout being a old school MCR fan i was really hoping to see more punk sound from them cos i heard they were completely changing their sound but didnt realize they'd do a damn britney spears on us and produce nothing but pure pop trash. This album could quite possibly be the worst album of the year, even the lead singer sounds more gay
-
-
DanielMOct 25, 2006It is very disturbing that this got a better review than Mastodon's Blood Mountain. Not bad, but certainly not as good as its rating suggests
-
-
JustinTOct 25, 2006Great 3rd album. Happy with how good it is. Definitely a good sound, sounds like MCR.
-
-
NickSDec 6, 2006MCR has definitley proven themselves as musicians, I really cant compare this album to the first one. First one in my opinion blows it away. A lot of good songs on this album, but not a hit album, they might get 2 singles out of this one.
-
-
M88Oct 26, 2006I'm not a fan of this "type" of music. But i find this album extremely addictive. And to say this band's new cd is just "emo-pop" is kind of a cop-out.
-
-
CarlOct 26, 2006
-
-
coreysOct 26, 2006two glaring omissions from everyone's "spot the influences". cheap trick and the marvelous 3. nobody writes a hook like cheap trick and the marvelous three is just as underrated. just like "american idiot". don't think too hard about it, just enjoy it. it's rock n roll.
-
-
joanthansOct 26, 2006
-
-
LeNlEnahbastaDec 6, 2006oh my god this song really unbelievable its really amazing woah ang ganda super!!!!! hehehhe its a perfect song for a rebel one!!!!!!!!!
-
-
jimOct 26, 2006if you love music, than you will hate this. and btw nme: american idiot is not a good album.
-
-
CassandraOct 26, 2006
-
-
MaxLOct 27, 2006I have to say that I am a little surprised at the quality of this album. I wasn't a fan of their last record, but they poished themselves silly on this one. It's really quite fun, and at times, a little beautiful. And really, this is rarely the sort of thing I like. I'm shocked.
-
-
MikeNOct 28, 2006The fact that this record and Sgt. Pepper are even mentioned on the same page makes me break out in hives. This is emo-pop high school bombast and self-indulgence dressed up with second rate def leopard hooks and queen histrionics. How is this so well reviewed, I feel like I am taking crazy pills here!?!
-
Awards & Rankings
-
The most bonkers album of the year, but one of the best.
-
Alternative PressThe Black Parade is MCR's whole raison d'etre rolled up into one mega-decibel calling card. [Nov 2006, p.179]
-
They've created the Sgt. Pepper of screamo.