User Score
Universal acclaim- based on 170 Ratings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 141 out of 170
-
Mixed: 20 out of 170
-
Negative: 9 out of 170
Review this album
-
-
Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.
-
-
Submit
-
Check Spelling
- User score
- By date
- Most helpful
-
PatrickMDec 20, 2005
-
-
ScuzzBucketJun 14, 2005While most of the songs top everything from "One By One," it sounds like Dave is trying to hard to be epic. Please Foo Fighters: Go back to writing songs like 'Weenie Beenie' & 'For All The Cows.' We can only take so much of the personal crap. 2 STARS deducted for the copy protection b.s.
-
-
seanJun 15, 2005first disc reliably good. second disc has a few good moments, but geez is that norah jones duet awful!!!
-
-
Jan 28, 2011
-
Nov 9, 2013
-
AndrewGJun 29, 2006
-
-
Sep 28, 2011Half of the songs are great and the other half feels filler and a bit boring. A really ambitious project and I applaud them for that.
-
TomBJun 15, 2005Whatever Dave and Co. have used to sucker millions of people into thinking that this music is anything more than bland, tuneless, boring, pointless music, I will pay gladly to get the secret. My God people, what do you see in this? Grohl is incapable of writing a song. So what, then? He's a great guy, I'll buy all his records? Bleh.
-
-
TboneMJun 29, 2005Wow this is total rock schlock. The screaming is a desperate plea for relevancy. I could only force myself to listen to the first album once, thank buddha I didn't buy it.
-
-
[Anonymous]Jun 27, 2005Bland Bland Bland, the only thing that shines is Dave's voice.
-
-
PaulHJul 11, 2005Some of the reviews say that there's a great one disc album buried in these two discs, i disagree, maybe a good ep, maybe.
-
-
JohnNMay 16, 2006
-
-
AndrewL.Jun 29, 2007I have to agree with Tom B. I like their older albums but I'm disappointed with "In your hornor".
-
-
Feb 6, 2021
Awards & Rankings
-
The New York TimesThe rock CD overpowers the acoustic one. Yet among the quieter songs, there are enough supple melodies and hypnotic guitar patterns to suggest fine prospects for a follow-through album that would dare to mix plugged-in and unplugged. [12 Jun 2005]
-
Los Angeles TimesLoud, anthemic, joyous and bitter, it's easily the best Foo Fighters album in a decade. [12 Jun 2005]
-
It is clean, polished rock with a vaguely punk edge that stays within a clear set of boundaries but in doing so manages to appeal to indie-kids and metal-lovers alike.