- Critic score
- Publication
- By date
-
Major General finds us with an accomplished and very steady collection of songs.
-
Alternative PressNicolay serves it up hot, no matter what musical milieu is on the menu. [Feb 2009, p.106]
-
Fine writing, then, and there’s musical variety, too.
-
Apart from those ['Hey Dad!,' 'World/Inferno vs. the End of the Evening,' 'Dead Sailors'] and the relatively slight 'Do We Not Live in Dreams?,' though, Major General hits some massive highs and nary a single crushing low.
-
Lyrically, Major General can ride shotgun with Nicolay's most-famous band....Elsewhere, Major General's arrangements are ragged, or worse, distracting.
-
For the most part, Major General comes off like a respectable sampler of regional singer-songwriter music.
-
In the end, the album has more good than bad, and is worth a listen for curious Hold Steady fans.
-
Q MagazineIn other words, the man's a ham, but a terrific one. [Aug 2009, p.109]
-
Outside of the few moments of innovation, though, very little will strike one as all that inspired.
-
Stepping out solo, the energetic multi-instrumentalist--assisted by guests including Dresden Dolls' Brian Viglione--does fine when he keeps things forceful. But when Nicolay decelerates, his weaknesses (cheesy croon, misguided piano) emerge, resulting in over-earnest, loungey balladeering.
-
MojoMajor General plough's The Hold Steady's punk-pop narrative furrow almost to the point of surrealism. [Sep 2009, p.92]