User Score
8.5

Universal acclaim- based on 5097 Ratings

User score distribution:
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this album

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
  1. Jun 16, 2020
    5
    As many improvements as this album have compared to his last 2 records, at the same time he counteracts them with flaws that undermine these improvements. The features are very good, most notably juice wrld and don Toliver, but the album is still really long for no apparent reason. His last record, Kamikaze, spent most of the time insulting 'mumble' rappers and those who were vocal on howAs many improvements as this album have compared to his last 2 records, at the same time he counteracts them with flaws that undermine these improvements. The features are very good, most notably juice wrld and don Toliver, but the album is still really long for no apparent reason. His last record, Kamikaze, spent most of the time insulting 'mumble' rappers and those who were vocal on how bad Revival was. Claiming they all had similar flow and bad lyrics. Yet this record has some lyrics worse than that on songs like Gucci Gang. Distasteful remarks about the tragedy and murder of innocents by extremists at an Ariana Grande Concert, downright corny and cringe like 'I'm a candle, I'll go out if you blow on me'. It isn't anything special and leaves plenty of room to grow. at this point, Eminem is a different person to the one he was 6 - 20 years ago and should be treated like a relatively new artist. this album feels like a sophomore record from a newish rapper. Nothing special, but not terrible either. Expand
  2. Mar 13, 2021
    10
    Good album. I like the album. Album good. Nice album. Epic album. Dope album
  3. Nov 23, 2022
    10
    the goat for a reason. Kanye, Nas, Kendrick etc. are nothing compared. period.
  4. Nov 29, 2022
    10
    absolutely amazing. i enjoyed side b more but this one is still a banger......
  5. Dec 6, 2022
    10
    fantastic, 10/10. The goat back at it, at what he does best: putting bangers out there. Loved it from the very beginning.
  6. Jan 18, 2020
    8
    Em's latest fixes some of the biggest problems with his recent output. Whilst his lyricism has never left, his consistently-angry delivery has had a negative effect on much of his comedic writing. 'Music to be murdered by' has the best of both worlds, and Em sounds rejuvenated and actually seems to be having fun behind the mic again.

    His voices range from comical cartoon characters to
    Em's latest fixes some of the biggest problems with his recent output. Whilst his lyricism has never left, his consistently-angry delivery has had a negative effect on much of his comedic writing. 'Music to be murdered by' has the best of both worlds, and Em sounds rejuvenated and actually seems to be having fun behind the mic again.

    His voices range from comical cartoon characters to philosophical and depressing introspectives and everything in between.
    Expand
  7. Jan 30, 2020
    10
    Eminem got murdered on his own track by who????? Young ma my ass. All eminem does on this album is murder. He murders every beat. Every lyric and murders anyone who's featured on the track with him. Slim shady in the buildin
  8. Jan 21, 2020
    9
    One would assume that after all those years critics and some people would know Eminem. Yet they get offended by few edge lines. It`s just his rhyming and wordplay, do they really think he is okay with what happened in Manchester? He matured after sobering up. And as for the critics. They had it coming. They criticize everything he does these days. M2BMB is one of his most consistentOne would assume that after all those years critics and some people would know Eminem. Yet they get offended by few edge lines. It`s just his rhyming and wordplay, do they really think he is okay with what happened in Manchester? He matured after sobering up. And as for the critics. They had it coming. They criticize everything he does these days. M2BMB is one of his most consistent albums. I for one love Encore, it has gems but inconsistency is the problem there. This is pure quality. He is not going to do another SSLP or MMLP accept it. This is strong. Good beats, hooks and featurings. In Darkness there is a great use of a sample and it might be one of his finest tunes ever. He`s not fastrapping on every track like in recent years. I liked Revival and Kamikaze at first but the replay value wasn`t high. I like this album more with every listen and rate it really high. 16 of 17 songs I don`t skip. He did great! Expand
  9. Jan 25, 2020
    10
    EMINEM is baaack!!! Very good album i love it! Beats are great and lyrics amazing as always.
  10. Jan 20, 2020
    10
    This is one of the best releases in a few years and it had to be Eminem the one who's put it out. Yeah, the lyrics are not up there with his first releases but what he's trying to spread with this effort goes beyond what we usually expect from his releases. His previous one Kamikaze was a wake up call to those who criticize him and this one is the final touch on those who still won't getThis is one of the best releases in a few years and it had to be Eminem the one who's put it out. Yeah, the lyrics are not up there with his first releases but what he's trying to spread with this effort goes beyond what we usually expect from his releases. His previous one Kamikaze was a wake up call to those who criticize him and this one is the final touch on those who still won't get over the fact the didn't drag Ariana Grande in one of the songs on the album nor mocked the situation she'd been through in Manchester. This album has got replay value and let me tell you it gets better with each listen. Expand
  11. Jan 21, 2020
    10
    One of eminem's best work overall, amazing beats, great content, incredible hooks, the flow, cadence, voice on this project is off the chain. Don't get me started on the double entendre, metaphors, similes, rhyme schemes. Geez
  12. Dec 20, 2020
    8
    This proves once again that conceptual music is what a great artist can come up with, but then again Eminem did this all of his career, so it's not a surprise that he murdered the competition with this sneaky release of intelligent lyrics and good production.
  13. Jan 24, 2020
    9
    Amazing album. I have been listening to it in a loop since it dropped. There is a lot of depth to explore and the track order enhances the experience.
  14. Jan 20, 2020
    7
    Why is Unaccommodating down as a top track on the album page??? It isn't. This album is decent. It's being hated on by many elsewhere who wouldn't know good spittin' if it crawled out of them because no one does it anymore.
  15. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    I'm a fan of his speed and storytelling. The shocking bars aren't really a problem, to me. The content was there and it also had great length. This is something I can play on repeat. He also had a lot of fun with it. I'm enjoying all the ad-libs.
  16. Sep 27, 2021
    7
    Some of the songs just feel too much like Eminem is messing around and not caring about what he’s putting out. There was quite a lot of insignificant theming in the album that wasn’t really saved by lyricism. However, the album also does have some wonderful messages at times and some brilliantly crafted verses that remind us all who he really is. At times it made me question whether or notSome of the songs just feel too much like Eminem is messing around and not caring about what he’s putting out. There was quite a lot of insignificant theming in the album that wasn’t really saved by lyricism. However, the album also does have some wonderful messages at times and some brilliantly crafted verses that remind us all who he really is. At times it made me question whether or not it was a significant addition to his discography, but in the end it does pull it off. Expand
  17. KAG
    Jan 21, 2020
    10
    Eminem gave me everything I could ask for in MTBMB... clean/ Dr. Dre production, Marshall-sung hooks, experimental & trap-sounding beats, introspective & personal subject matter, Em’s signature rapping/ flows/ rhymes/ wordplay and even a Black Thought feature. Thank you Em!
  18. Jan 24, 2020
    10
    THIS is hip hop. Top tier MC features and all-round great bars from all of them. Very diverse tracklist with each track having its own sound and tone. Album has great depth and, with a less angry Em on it, is great to listen to.
  19. Jan 28, 2020
    4
    Eminem answers criticisms of his recent work by delivering another album that’s indistinguishable from his other recent work. More songs about being the greatest, more rehash of the past, more conflicted tales of dysfunctional relationships... Throw in some awkward chorus transitions (or just plain old lousy choruses and hooks) and no-rhyme-or-reason 180 degree turns in style and tone, andEminem answers criticisms of his recent work by delivering another album that’s indistinguishable from his other recent work. More songs about being the greatest, more rehash of the past, more conflicted tales of dysfunctional relationships... Throw in some awkward chorus transitions (or just plain old lousy choruses and hooks) and no-rhyme-or-reason 180 degree turns in style and tone, and you get a disjointed mess that we’ve all heard before. He gets points for ‘Darkness’, which is an incisive and raw look into the mind of a mass shooter. Everything else is reheated leftovers. Expand
  20. Jan 23, 2020
    10
    This album is so sick. I've had it on repeat since it was released. A couple of songs had to grow on me (Stepdad & Leaving Heaven) but after a few listens I really like them now. I'd probably give it a 9.5 as it isn't as good as SSLP, MMLP & TES which are all 10's. Make sure you give it a listen.
  21. Jan 21, 2020
    8
    While not on par with the classic trilogy or MMLP2, it's definitely felt like a breath of fresh air after Revival and Kamikaze (albums that I personally disliked). A few annoying beats and questionable verses here but a lot of highlights can be found here, like Darkness or Stepdad.
  22. Jan 24, 2020
    10
    Masterpiece. Is there any debate he is the GOAT now?
    Nobody can spit so many hard bars with incredible rhythm and cadence.
    Lock It Up is the most underrated track.
  23. Jan 22, 2020
    9
    Definitely a modern day classic ..............................................................................
  24. Jan 18, 2020
    9
    Coooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooool album very cooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooool
  25. Apr 15, 2020
    9
    Em has still got lots to say and this album proved it to me. Lyrically he is second to none (when you take into account how consistent he has been at this). The beats on this album range from some more new age slappers to some old school dre beats. I have been consistently listening to this album since it launched and dont see it leaving my tape deck any time soon. I am still catching newEm has still got lots to say and this album proved it to me. Lyrically he is second to none (when you take into account how consistent he has been at this). The beats on this album range from some more new age slappers to some old school dre beats. I have been consistently listening to this album since it launched and dont see it leaving my tape deck any time soon. I am still catching new double entendres and metaphors. Expand
  26. Jan 22, 2020
    6
    Not bad but definitely not great, at least it's an improvement upon Kamikaze since that album was really bad... I don't have much to say because I'm not an expert but I didn't like some of the flows and the songs sometimes felt kinda boring...
  27. Jan 19, 2020
    9
    Just amazing, this album get me exited eminems music again. !! Keep it going king
  28. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    Absolute perfection. Perfect balance of Eminem, Marshall Mathers and Slim Shady, and the album is obviously made for Stans like me, seeing the gap between the critic score and the user score
  29. Jan 22, 2020
    8
    Great album by Eminem. He still got it (as he showed in Kamikaze) this takes it up a notch.
  30. Jan 23, 2020
    10
    nobody cares about ratings so let it just be 10 out of 10 cuz eminem really reserved it
  31. Jan 22, 2020
    9
    His best album since Relapse! Fantastic production, his delivery superb and his musicality on true form!
  32. Jun 4, 2022
    7
    Solid effort by Eminem. He rides the beats in a very unorthodox way but it's still fun. could've done without the love songs and step dad.
  33. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    It’s not that often one can listen to a whole album, especially one that long, without at least skipping a few songs, but this album every song is a hit. The beats and production on this one is sick! Em’s flow is perfect. I love the album!
  34. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    Best album of 2020! Stop with the negativity, be unbiased for an hour, forget about everything u heard on social media and listen to it, dig it, analyze this **** then you will wat a masterpiece it is ....
  35. Jan 23, 2020
    10
    This album seems like the result of an introspective journey Em has had to go through musically, he has looked back at what has worked on Revival (Believe, Castle, Arose) and Kamikaze, and attempted to craft an album based on those results. For the most part I think he did a good job here, while he is still trying to overload us with his unrelenting wit, not all songs suffer from thisThis album seems like the result of an introspective journey Em has had to go through musically, he has looked back at what has worked on Revival (Believe, Castle, Arose) and Kamikaze, and attempted to craft an album based on those results. For the most part I think he did a good job here, while he is still trying to overload us with his unrelenting wit, not all songs suffer from this issue, and some that do are actually enjoyable to listen to (Godzilla). I also enjoyed listening to Em step out of his comfort zone, and rap over some more upbeat trap instrumentals, and thanks to his spectacular flow he is able to pull it off (unlike DOOM in Keys to the Cuffs).

    Of course you still have the unavoidable “love” songs that need to be stopped, by any means necessary, since for every 5 of these songs Em makes, maybe 1 is smi-good (Good Guy). Where the album truly shines is on the leading single Darkness, on this track is where we get a glimpse of Em’s incredible song writing ability. The song was very well paced, the punchlines and double entendres were clever and served an overarching purpose, and Em’s story telling ability is as sharp if not sharper than on Stan.

    Overall this was an entertaining listen, the guest verses were great (Royce, Joel, Crook) and Em got murdered on his own track by the great Black Thought. The hooks were pretty good (Anderson Paak, Juice Wrld), and the beats were very well crafted, for the most part, especially the You Gon Learn beat. Hopefully Em continues down this trajectory, focuses more on quality, finds new and interesting content to write about, and continues to evolve his writing ability.

    I would give this album a solid 7, but I'm rating it a 10 just to offset the haters, lol
    Expand
  36. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    It's a great album that realy it highly enjoyable and intelligent at the same time

    Eminem keep proving that he is one of the GOATs if not the GOAT
  37. Jan 21, 2020
    9
    Best album since TES, easily. Kamikaze was a damn good album, but wasn't well rounded, this album uses the style from Kamikaze, while improving the overall delivery and lyricism. Production is also amazing and sees Dre come out from the rock hes been under, as well as some production from Royce of all people, which somehow manages to be as good if not better than Dre's. Great album,Best album since TES, easily. Kamikaze was a damn good album, but wasn't well rounded, this album uses the style from Kamikaze, while improving the overall delivery and lyricism. Production is also amazing and sees Dre come out from the rock hes been under, as well as some production from Royce of all people, which somehow manages to be as good if not better than Dre's. Great album, extremely consistent. Expand
  38. Feb 11, 2020
    10
    Very good album by Eminem once again. Nearly every song on this album is I enjoyed and even the ones that I liked a little less were great.
    There is really nothing else to say except it's Eminem and he nailed it. And when he nails he NAILS it.
    Listen to this album you wont regret it.
  39. Jan 25, 2020
    9
    Exactly the kind of album we needed from Eminem after Kamikaze. He is on the right track. While we know that he has never lost his technical lyrical ability, the overall result in most of the tracks in Revival was pretty much negative, due to his turning to a rap-rock style and going for that poppy production style and features. Kamikaze showed signs of the return of an angry Eminem, butExactly the kind of album we needed from Eminem after Kamikaze. He is on the right track. While we know that he has never lost his technical lyrical ability, the overall result in most of the tracks in Revival was pretty much negative, due to his turning to a rap-rock style and going for that poppy production style and features. Kamikaze showed signs of the return of an angry Eminem, but then it was more of a response to critics and haters rather than a proper album (and the filler tracks like Nice Guy and Normal were underwhelming). Then he drops this gem of an album. Well structured, production right on point, great beats and an overall better choice of features and overall sound of it was better. Keeps getting better the more you listen to it. About that Ariana controversy, well, that's Slim Shady for you: he's not new to controversy and this is nowhere near the extent of the controversial stuff he used to say in the early 2000s. He clearly wasn't 'mocking' the bombing, he was simply referencing it.

    Overall, most of the tracks got better the more I listened to it. People may complain about how he 'raps too much' or has 'too many words' but that creates replay value: every time you listen you catch a new bar or two. Some of them are so unexpected they made me smile or chuckle. I don't disagree on the fact that there are perhaps a couple of bars that might be corny or cringe, but that comes with every album by any artist.

    Only reason why this doesn't get a 10 is because of some flaws, especially in the tracks 'Marsh' and 'Stepdad', the former being mostly corny and having an autotuned chorus and both having annoying choruses in general. The hook on Yah Yah also ruins the otherwise great track. It's a shame since despite these shortcomings these songs still had some good bars. However, hooks on songs like Never Love Again and Farewell were beautifully sung and sounded great. Skylar Grey's chorus on Leaving Heaven sounded a bit empty but doesn't do too much damage. Royce was showed his lyrical prowess and performed well in all his features while Anderson .Paak and the late Juice WRLD both had fantastic features. Production on all tracks was top-notch, on songs like Farewell, Premonition, Unaccomodating, Lock It Up, and especially Godzilla. Godzilla's beat was sexy. I've heard people complain that Eminem doesn't need to rap fast but he fast-rapped only 30 seconds in the whole 64 minutes of the album, and I don't see a problem in that. 30 seconds of demonstrating your fast-rapping ability? Not a problem in my book.

    Eminem is older and sober now, unlike his young self on drugs. His songs are therefore less motivated than how he used to be: he used to rap about drugs, how he hates his mom and ex-wife, etc. However, he's grown out of these issues and therefore it should be a notable point that while he is attempting to "bring Slim Shady back", this is not entirely possible to the level of effectiveness in his three classic albums, SSLP, MMLP and TES. Therefore he's more focussed on using his immaculate ability to create double entendres and multi-layered bars, while sacrificing a little bit of content quality. Despite this, Eminem managed to psycho-analyse Paddock in Darkness, effectively on the most part. This has to be lauded. And the tracks on this album that were entirely double entendres: the tracks that could apply both to relationships and drugs equally. Complete genius. While Eminem has definitely changed; he's not the rapper he used to be, yet he still displays his technical ability most effectively. Now with MTBMB, he's definitely on the right track. He's showed us that he can still make amazing music.

    This is his best album since Recovery. Hopefully his next album is even better.
    Expand
  40. Jan 24, 2020
    8
    El álbum esta muy bueno, me gusto bastante. Las arirats jamás podran cancelar al Rap God ni en sus sueños xD
  41. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    I think that every new Eminem album is better lyrically, 'MTBMB' is a different Eminem from decades with the best hooks in a long time; Good production, good samples, flow always on the spot, verbal energy, the new generation of hip hop, the old generation of Rap, Slim Shady, Eminem, Marshall, all in one album. Eminem excels at each new year.
  42. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    You gotta listen to the album and see for your self how well done it is, and I'm so glad that Em is at his best peak on this
  43. Jan 18, 2020
    7
    Most reviews are unrealistically high or low. Giving it a 0 or 10 with no criteria to follow is as biased as it comes. However I won't branch off into an extremely abstract review, I'll just keep it simple for future listeners.

    Production: A- Structure: C Message: C Lyrics: A Creativity: B Overall Grade: 7 of 10 (6 low ball & 8.5 high ball) Biggest Praises: -Periodically
    Most reviews are unrealistically high or low. Giving it a 0 or 10 with no criteria to follow is as biased as it comes. However I won't branch off into an extremely abstract review, I'll just keep it simple for future listeners.

    Production: A-
    Structure: C
    Message: C
    Lyrics: A
    Creativity: B

    Overall Grade: 7 of 10 (6 low ball & 8.5 high ball)

    Biggest Praises:
    -Periodically fixed his streak of weak production choice regarding quality beats and choosing ones that synchronize well with his organic sound.
    -Has flashes of covering significant introspective hardships and significant problems in society.
    -Maintains a consistent balance from start to finish.

    Biggest Criticisms:
    -Unnecessary tracks (filler) that don’t contribute much if anything to the overall message and development of the project.
    -Forced a slew of literary devices.
    -Fairly unrefined delivery in some instances due to a choppy flow.

    Key Tracks: Unaccommodating, You Gon’ Learn, and Godzilla.

    Final Thoughts: This album exceeds his last couple of efforts by a substantial margin and fix several flaws while the remaining ones aren't nearly as glaring. A great one time listen for casuals who gravitate to the singles and a cult hit for those who have trained their ears for his uncanny and unique sound.
    Expand
  44. Jan 20, 2020
    10
    Eminem is back again with more heat. The bars are on point and he delivers 100%. With some introspective and heavy tracks like Darkness and In Too Deep, as well as some classic fast, impressive verses that can be found in Godzilla, Yah Yah, and the intro (Premonition), he shows yet again why he is the greatest rapper alive.
  45. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    This is almost his best work yet. It's like the first Matters LP, you never get bored listening to it. Flawless.
  46. Feb 3, 2020
    7
    Good but not the same sound as before. The song "I Will" is probably the one who reminds me the most old Eminem on this album.
  47. Jan 19, 2020
    9
    Probably his best since Recovery.
    Production and hooks has slightly improved since Revival, also verses are great alongside with features.
    Solid album 9/10.
  48. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    Flow, beats, rhymes, metaphors, double/triple entendres, featuring etc. Everything about this album is amazing! Thanks Marshall Mathers, my ears are blessed.
  49. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    Beat album Eminem has released since Eminem Show! So many awesome tracks on this and despite the various sounds the album flows well. Eminem has mastered rap!
  50. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    This is the best project Em had put out in recent years. Production is impeccable and goes well with all the flows.
  51. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    Best work of Eminem since a decade!
    Bars are so heavy on this album that some ye fans might find it going over their tiny little heads.
  52. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. It really is a good eminem record, i would say it is as good as mmlp2. For me it feels like a good combination of the relapse, Kamikaze, Recovery and eminem show style in a modern package. Expand
  53. Jun 8, 2020
    6
    This is definetly a step in the right direction for Em, it has some awful tracks, especially the one with Ed Sheeran, but overall, this is better than his previous albums. Darkness is the kinda track that convices me that the old Em that wrote Stan still is alive and well in Marshall. Godzilla is on the other side of the spectrum, fun and fast. I like both sides of this. My major complaintThis is definetly a step in the right direction for Em, it has some awful tracks, especially the one with Ed Sheeran, but overall, this is better than his previous albums. Darkness is the kinda track that convices me that the old Em that wrote Stan still is alive and well in Marshall. Godzilla is on the other side of the spectrum, fun and fast. I like both sides of this. My major complaint with this album is the amount of tracks that aren't that good, and the fact that the title and skits try to tell you that this is a dangerous album and "music to be murdered by", when in fact, there are only a few songs on this thing that reflect this theme. The posse cuts on this thing are amazing though, and You gon' learn especially captures the theme of this album pretty well. All in all an album that is okay to listen through, no awful tracks, just some that are painfully mediocre Expand
  54. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    So **** good. I just like it, better than the two last albums and Recovery. Same good as MMLP2 and Relapse
  55. Feb 17, 2020
    7
    ( 70/100 )

    Cerca de ser un muy mal album, Eminem se enfoca en todo el dolor, la hostilidad y violencia que lo rodeo mientras crecía y estipula que eso realmente no ha cambiado y por eso su voz es tan poderosa ahora como lo era antes. La producción, de más de 15 personas, es muy floja, genérica e invisible en quien solo Tim Suby aporta algo decente al álbum. Near to be a pretty bad
    ( 70/100 )

    Cerca de ser un muy mal album, Eminem se enfoca en todo el dolor, la hostilidad y violencia que lo rodeo mientras crecía y estipula que eso realmente no ha cambiado y por eso su voz es tan poderosa ahora como lo era antes. La producción, de más de 15 personas, es muy floja, genérica e invisible en quien solo Tim Suby aporta algo decente al álbum.

    Near to be a pretty bad album, Eminem focuses on all the pain, hostility and violence that surrounded him while growing up and stipulates that nothing has really changed, that's why his voice is still as important now as before. The production, of over 15 people, is very lazy, generic and invisible in which only Tim Suby puts in something decent in the album.
    Expand
  56. Mar 25, 2020
    10
    Очень крутой альбом! Его мрачная и одновременно крутая атмосфера делает альбом еще более приятным! Добавление фраз Альфреда Хичкока - это просто гениально! Я бы хотел отметить 3 трека, которые мне очень понравились: Darkness, Unaccommodating, Godzilla. 10 из 10.Очень крутой альбом! Его мрачная и одновременно крутая атмосфера делает альбом еще более приятным! Добавление фраз Альфреда Хичкока - это просто гениально! Я бы хотел отметить 3 трека, которые мне очень понравились: Darkness, Unaccommodating, Godzilla. 10 из 10.
  57. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    Literally the only song I don’t like is little Engine the rest ranges from good to masterpiece

    Favourite songs: Darkness, Leaving Heaven, premonition, Godzilla and No Regrets

    Least Favourite song: Little Engine
  58. Nov 26, 2020
    10
    MTBMB has left me speechless honestly. And on constant loop of listening to the album over and over again. I loved Kamikaze, but I think this album is one of my favourites already, because I personally think it is so versatile, fresh, has great replay value and I just can´t get enough of it. I feel like there is something for everyone on this album and that Em really appreciates his fans'MTBMB has left me speechless honestly. And on constant loop of listening to the album over and over again. I loved Kamikaze, but I think this album is one of my favourites already, because I personally think it is so versatile, fresh, has great replay value and I just can´t get enough of it. I feel like there is something for everyone on this album and that Em really appreciates his fans' opinions by giving people what they want. I just cannot give anything under 10 for this album, there is not a single song I would want to skip. And about the mixed reviews I think these lines form Unaccommodating are spot on:

    They said I'm lyrically amazing
    But I have nothing to say
    But then when I put out Revival and I had something to say
    They said that they hated the awake me
    I lose the rage, I'm too tame
    I get it back, they say I'm too angry
    I need to get me some Dre beats
    No, I should hook up with Tay Keith
    Fans keep on pulling me one way
    Haters pull me in another
    Expand
  59. Jan 24, 2020
    10
    This album is Eminem's best work in years, I mean all his albums are great but this, this is what had been waiting for. The intro alone builds the hype for the whole thing and it takes you on a crazy ride.
  60. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    Excellente album, excelentes beats, excelentes colaboraciones.
    Los criticos pueden decir lo que quieran para mi es un 10.
  61. Dec 28, 2020
    9
    This Album Was Amazing!!!!
    I Love This So Much I Think Godzila and Stepdad are The Best Tracks In This Album
  62. Jan 28, 2020
    10
    Me encanta este álbum, es fantástico y no puedo dejar de escucharlo. Amo cada un de las canciones.
  63. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    Todo lo bueno, no esperaba este concepto de album, pero la verdad cumplio demasiado. Mejoro todo lo que tenia que cambiar (Producción, Estribillos, Inclusion de raperos nuevos, etc.)
  64. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    Eminem's ability to still rap at this high level well into his late 40's is beyond impressive. His passion for music is evident in the work he put into this project. This album is easily my favorite album since MMLP2. Bravo Marshall Mathers!
  65. Jan 23, 2020
    10
    The fact that the media itself wants to lambast an album that is just shy of perfect just goes to show the world we now love in, where PC culture is the way to live with one hand on your mouth incase you say something that might offend the snowflakes out there. All I see is complaints about a 1.5 second reference to the manchester bombing yet the same people are quick to forget that EminemThe fact that the media itself wants to lambast an album that is just shy of perfect just goes to show the world we now love in, where PC culture is the way to live with one hand on your mouth incase you say something that might offend the snowflakes out there. All I see is complaints about a 1.5 second reference to the manchester bombing yet the same people are quick to forget that Eminem himself help raise over 2 million for the same cause. The album itself is great any Stan such as myself will love this, especially those who appreciate great lyrics. It also has a hint of Eminem show mixed with the MMLP sprinkled in, is it as legendary as those albums? Only time will tell but I can honestly say we are witnessing a master of his craft at work, features from Anderson paak, and justice wrld are excellent. And Darkness is a masterpiece at work where you are getting 2 stories at once, if only the media were clever enough to catch on to the genius rather than taking it all at face value and trying to nitpick the song to death. Expand
  66. Jan 22, 2020
    9
    The album is a bit like "Revival", but that doesn't make it bad! "MTBMB" took on the aggression of "Kamikaze" and the drama of "Revival"! It turned out very well !
    From the top tracks I can note: Godzilla, Darkness, Yah Yah, Step Dad, Those Kinda NIghts!

    9/10
  67. Jan 22, 2020
    8
    his best album since 2013. A very solid album all the way through that takes a couple of listens to fully appreciate it. Lyrically impressive
  68. Jan 18, 2020
    10
    It's a instant classic best album of the year the return of the greatest
  69. Aug 14, 2020
    8
    Guess who's back, back again
    Shady's back, tell a friend
    Guess who's back, guess who's back?
    Guess who's back, guess who's back?
    Guess who's back, guess who's back?
    Guess who's back?
    I've created a monster, 'cause nobody wants to see Marshall no more.
  70. Apr 2, 2021
    9
    It is my first Eminem album that I listen to in its entirety and it gave me one of the best experiences of my life, it made me reconsider the rap genre and I love it
  71. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    Great improvement from his previous ones. Production is amazing, features are incredible. Tracklist is little bit long and some songs are not needed. 8/10 but gonna post 10 to piss of nerds
  72. May 11, 2021
    0
    Great beats coupled with the best features of any Eminem album and his tightest flow since MMLP2 make this a great project. However, the album is bogged down by some questionable tracks that feel more like filler to reach the hour mark. But songs like "Darkness" and "You Gon Learn" showcase Em as one of raps greatest lyricists. "Godzilla" and "Yah Yah" cement Em as the most technicallyGreat beats coupled with the best features of any Eminem album and his tightest flow since MMLP2 make this a great project. However, the album is bogged down by some questionable tracks that feel more like filler to reach the hour mark. But songs like "Darkness" and "You Gon Learn" showcase Em as one of raps greatest lyricists. "Godzilla" and "Yah Yah" cement Em as the most technically skilled rapper the game has ever seen. Expand
  73. Jan 23, 2020
    10
    This project murdered everything.
    Critisisem.
    Haters.
    Any one try to diss eminem.
    And all you media give him abad score
  74. Feb 3, 2020
    8
    Em never truly justifies his record's excessive length, and his continuing to rage against "Revival" haters two albums later feels increasingly childish, but richly evocative beats keep the album functioning as a mood piece if not a fully coherent listening experience, while immaculate flows and strong storytelling across the LP's standout tracks result in a handful of songs that rankEm never truly justifies his record's excessive length, and his continuing to rage against "Revival" haters two albums later feels increasingly childish, but richly evocative beats keep the album functioning as a mood piece if not a fully coherent listening experience, while immaculate flows and strong storytelling across the LP's standout tracks result in a handful of songs that rank among his best work from over the last 10 years.

    Choice Cuts: "You Gon' Learn", "Godzilla", "Darkness"
    Expand
  75. Jan 18, 2020
    8
    This is simply a really good album don’t get the undeserving hate towards it
  76. Jan 29, 2020
    10
    This album gave me a rush of endorphins I didn't think could be achieved through music. The songs that really make this album a gem are the heavy hitters like Godzilla, I Will, and You Gon' Learn. This album sounds like Eminem took his old style and his new style and blended them to create a new and improved Marshall.
    As soon as I saw the notification for the new album I thought to myself
    This album gave me a rush of endorphins I didn't think could be achieved through music. The songs that really make this album a gem are the heavy hitters like Godzilla, I Will, and You Gon' Learn. This album sounds like Eminem took his old style and his new style and blended them to create a new and improved Marshall.
    As soon as I saw the notification for the new album I thought to myself "there's no way he can top Kamikaze," and boy was I wrong.
    This album is an absolute masterpiece, and any objective person will recognize the genius.
    Expand
  77. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    Ggúuuuggerrreffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff
  78. Jan 26, 2020
    10
    Has to potential to be one of the best album of 2020. Though it's at the same level of KAMIKAZE & it was excluded from any awards. Sad .
  79. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    The album has no bad song, the production is also really good it is better than any album I've heard in the past year
  80. Jan 18, 2020
    7
    Eminem works well with all the features and strengths many soft spots from Kamikaze.
  81. Jan 17, 2020
    7
    Certainly a comeback for Eminem, liked the production and whole kinda spooky, Alfred Hitchcock theme he was going with, very nice. Also good to see that he is able to adapt to the changing landscape of rap. Strong release.
  82. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    Great album, don’t care about those mfs rating this 0 just so the score goes down. Losers. Em stays winning.
  83. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    Best one since MMLP2, absolutely astonishing.
    The production is top notch, his flows are incredible, the features are GODLY, there is nothing not to like about this album
  84. Jan 22, 2020
    9
    Very good album. Eminem has great lyrics as usual and the beats are great as well.
  85. Jan 27, 2020
    10
    This is just the best album from Em, the perfect mix of eminem and slim shady
  86. Jan 21, 2020
    10
    First classic of the year/decade. Em raised the bar really high for the music and hip-hop in specific. A CLASSIC!!
  87. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    It's an amazing album with a good mixture of new school and Eminems un touched lyricism. The only reason it's not rated a 10 is because losers are making accounts just to trash the album to drop the rating. Eminem is the greatest and this album is good the only thing that isn't good are the features, some people that were featured weren't the best.
  88. Apr 5, 2020
    8
    Amazing album. People are only hating because its eminem. If the MMLP dropped today people would hate it. Whether you like it or not eminem is a GOAT.
  89. Jan 21, 2020
    7
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Essentially, this is a return to form for Eminem. If you thought that Kamikaze was controversial, you will be thoroughly shocked, frightened, and/or disturbed by many of the lyrics contained on this album. While it's still not quite the horrorcore of Eminem's very early days, Music To Be Murdered By is incredibly violent, and gleefully contains some of the most clever lyrics since MMLP2.

    Yet Eminem is, as he has always said he is, cognizant of the brutality of many of his lyrics. Throughout, many references are made to the epidemic of public shootings, most prominently in the track "Darkness", for which I must give Em credit for being more artistically creative and respectful than other such charged songs as "Campaign Speech" and "Untouchable". (Spoiler: On a side note, the way he uses vague lyrics on that track to appear as though he is playing himself, only near the end to reveal that he is playing an entirely different character, with a much different and sinister intent, is well done. Think the first few verses of "Bad Guy" from MMLP2.)

    Unfortunately, the second half of the album (essentially after "My Stepdad") loses the momentum and creativity it starts with. "I WILL", one of the 3 (wow) tracks which Royce da 5'9" is a guest on, does provide a nice conclusion to the album with giving a subtle but classic middle finger to Eminem's critics of the last 2 albums , yet it seems that Em simply relied on lyrical formulas already used and disappointing basic hooks, probably just to meet a quota of tracks demanded upon by Interscope Records for most of the album.

    Odds are that if you are an OG Eminem fan, you will probably like the tone of the album, viewed through Em's lyrical wordplay. "Godzilla" is my favorite track off of the album, and will most likely be the most popular as well (sorry "Darkness", but you're no "This Is America"). It contains a very catchy chrous by the late Juice WRLD and a finale at which Em raps at "supersonic speed", which I have a feeling is faster than the notorious "summa lumma" verse of "Rap God". The first 2 tracks also provide a great introduction to the Music To Be Murdered By

    With Eminem seeming to murder his pop ways (but that's not to say his relationship and career with Ed Sheeran is dead), Eminem seems to be playing the "Do-whatever-will-please-the-fans-and-make-money card". But it seems to work, for now. This album will hopefully make atonement for his less than typical, sub-par work from Revival and Kamikaze, restore our faith, and provide Em the opportunity to continue to reinvent himself in whatever way he decides next. If you wish to just casually listen, I recommend "Unaccommodating" "Godzilla" and for its importance, "Darkness", and maybe just try jumping around the first chronological half of the album.
    Expand
  90. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I think after mmlp2 this is the first time we can say slim shady is back at his full potential. Never heard such hardcore bars from him. So consistent and barely any filler songs. Solid work. Expand
  91. Jan 21, 2020
    10
    Album of the year for sure! Love everything! The production, bars, the collaborations and the theme of course! Brilliant! Great job Em!
  92. Jan 30, 2020
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Mais um excelente álbum para sua invejável discografia. Music to Be Murdered By - é um álbum crítico, social e muito necessário. A escolha de Darkness como lead foi precisa. O clipe mais parece uma obra de arte de tão bem feito. Mais de 20 anos de carreira e o Eminem segue de provando genial e necessário. Expand
  93. Jan 17, 2020
    7
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. From the second the album starts there is this feeling of "Eminem is back baby!". This feeling is so suddenly because of the first track "Premonition-Intro" which consists of Eminem rapping about how everyone thought Kamikaze was terrible and now he's back and better. The theme of this album is that the listener is listening to the album and by the end will be murdered. This is explained through a series of spoken word interludes titled "Alfred" where a person impersonating Alfred Hitchcock talks. The beginning of the album is very good except that the references to guns and violence became a bit excessive, especially on the track "Unaccommodating", a trap banger, where Eminem compares himself to several controversial figures, terrorists, and serial killers (Saddam Hussein, Ayatollah Khomeini, Osama bin Laden, John Wayne Gacy) and makes pointless, unnecessary references to the bombing at the Ariana Grande concert and 9/11. On the track "Darkness" Eminem puts himself in the shoes of the Las Vegas Shooter to make a point about gun violence. While I think his heart is in the right place, I don't think the way he did it was the best. There are bad features by Ed Sheeran and Juice WRLD on "Those Kinda Nights" and "Godzilla", respectively. The gun theme becomes very excessive with the over-the-top use of gunshot instrumentals. By the middle of the record, the tracks become increasingly rock influenced with songs like "Yah Yah" a good song but with a grating refrain, and "Stepdad" where Eminem describes an abusive stepfather who ends being beaten to death by his stepson. This song has a very catchy chorus and is one of my favorites. On the track "Marsh" there is some masterful wordplay which is very entertaining. I was looking forward to Anderson .Paak's feature when is saw it on the tracklist because Anderson is one of my favorite artists, but it utterly disappointed on the track "Lock it Up" Don Toliver has a great feature on the song "No Regrets" towards the end of the album. And finally the last track " I Will" which was good but not anywhere near the best on the album. In the Outro the Alfred Hitchcock character tells the listener that we actually imagined some of the album and that if we are still alive "better luck next time". This is a haunting note to leave off on. While this record is better than Kamikaze and Revival by leaps and bounds, it still has its flaws

    Favorite Tracks: You gon' learn, Darkness, No Regrets, Stepdad,
    Least Favorite Tracks: Those Kinda Nights, Lock it Up
    Best Features: Royce da 5'9'', White Gold, Skylar Grey, Don Toliver
    Worst Features: Ed Sheeran, Juice WRLD, Anderson .Paak
    Expand
  94. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    Its one fine album except for that ed sheeran feature and couple of love songs
  95. Jan 17, 2020
    10
    Amazing with top notch features and pulls off the axe weilding Afred Hitchcock theme
  96. Jan 22, 2020
    10
    I mean maybe you are not gonna love all the songs like any other album, but the ones you love, you are gonna f......ng love it, have it heard it all closely it's a 10, My top songs: Little Engine, Premonition, Unacommodating, Darkness, Marsh, and favorite Godzilla.
  97. Jan 25, 2020
    10
    Bringing back the "slim shady" eminem does the best in his music. Great rhymes, great beats and always mentioned horrible facts playing the bad guy. Even if people find it bad taste, whether or not it is the truth.
  98. Jan 19, 2020
    9
    Great return to form from over-gated rap legend. Eminem’s best album since 2013’s Marshall Mathers LP 2 and arguably more appealing to larger audiences with modern beats, flows and features. At the same time it successfully pleases long time fans with plenty references to Eminem’s past and recent events in his life, such as the passing of his father. Darkness the standout track of theGreat return to form from over-gated rap legend. Eminem’s best album since 2013’s Marshall Mathers LP 2 and arguably more appealing to larger audiences with modern beats, flows and features. At the same time it successfully pleases long time fans with plenty references to Eminem’s past and recent events in his life, such as the passing of his father. Darkness the standout track of the album, tackling the issues with the current gun laws in America. Expand
  99. Jan 17, 2020
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Definitely worth a listen It captures that Eminem we have been missing Not too angry but the perfect type of anger Expand
Metascore
64

Generally favorable reviews - based on 17 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 7 out of 17
  2. Negative: 0 out of 17
  1. Feb 11, 2020
    60
    He clearly cares about his output, but “Music To Be Murdered By” is, unfortunately, another mixed bag of tricks, propped up by lyrical acrobatics and underwhelming production.
  2. 70
    If they look hard enough, any artist could find criticism of their work online. That’s sort of the curse of the Information Age. But not everyone overreacts quite as much as Eminem does. But if his fears grow tiring, his lyrical ability can still give you something to admire, even if the album is somewhat uneven.
  3. Jan 27, 2020
    55
    It is not, strictly speaking, a good record—Eminem hasn’t made one of those in a decade—but it boasts enough technical command and generates just enough arresting ideas to hold your attention.