- Critic score
- Publication
- By date
-
Alternative PressThe words are as bleak as ever, and the songs still cut like coal-black shards of anti-pop bitterness. [Apr 2006, p.204]
-
A deeply satisfying work of storytelling through pop.... What Are You On? is emotionally complex in a way that few of the more prosperous songwriters of Cornog’s generation are capable of producing at this point in their careers.
-
This is right up there with his best.
-
Present are the hints of early Guided by Voices, spotty Who outtakes and country-tinged acoustics that make East River Pipe so beloved, but here these influences tread, weighted, underwater.
-
BillboardSongs of losers and loss tempered by only a taste of wry humor.
-
UrbLuckily he counteracts offbeat, sad sucker storytelling with endearing Casio tones and token indie rock chords. [Mar 2006, p.123]
-
Like every East River Pipe album it’s blemished by imperfections, but Cornog’s lonely, home-recorded drabness goes beyond the "sun, sun, sun" of other retro-oriented musicians to remind us that sunlight reflecting off slabs of urban concrete remains as bleak in 2006 as it was in 1974.
-
What Are You On? bristles with unchecked bitterness that often curdles into condescension.
-
There’s little doubt that Cornog is an excellent songwriter, his sense of melody and hook is impeccable, but What Are You On?, despite some fine moments, feels distracted and too brief with 13 songs in just over 35 minutes.
-
His tried-and-true lo-fi routine is still there, and die-hard Pipe fans will probably gobble up this release, but these thirteen smoggy ballads are like that week-old liter of Grape Fanta: you know, flat.
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 6 out of 6
-
Mixed: 0 out of 6
-
Negative: 0 out of 6
-
DaveJFeb 26, 2006
-
DougPFeb 19, 2006Beautiful sadness. Or sad beauty. Hits you in the bottle.
-
EricRFeb 15, 2006An underrated gem. I'm new to Cornog