- Record Label: Kill Rock Stars
- Release Date: Sep 9, 2003
- Critic score
- Publication
- By date
-
Alternative PressA thrilling listen. [Dec 2003, p.140]
-
No one else is making literate, story-based pop this good.
-
Under The RadarIt's as though The Decemberists have been able to somehow summon that mystical muse that allows for all of the wonder of the musical world to open. [#5, p.100]
-
MagnetOn [Her Majesty...], the whimsy and multicolored narrative threads that represented the best of the Decemberists' terrific first album are given room to breathe. [#60, p.96]
-
Meloy's words stir your insides like good poetry, his imaginative tales climb into your mind, set up camp and stay awhile. But without the enchanting, heart-wrenching and totally affecting power that is the consequence of The Decemberists' music, the words would not have ever found life.
-
A glorious triumph.... The Decemberists deserve to become your new favourite band.
-
Her Majesty rewards repeated listenings, ultimately revealing itself to be a deeper, subtler work than Castaways.
-
Colin Meloy's songwriting makes them one of the strongest bands working today.
-
Underneath the surface of these grand productions lies hidden undercurrents of malice, disgust and social commentary- all things that would seem to be at odds with a beautifully constructed pop song.
-
Clever without being pretentious.
-
The Decemberists are stuck in the past while innovating with an eye on the future.
-
This all may sound ostentatious or showy, but it isn't: Her Majesty aims high and hits a difficult mark, delivering glorious, sometimes fantastic tales without ever getting boorish.
-
Her Majesty the Decemberists is distinctive, where the good parts are so good that it's easy to overlook the not-so-good.
-
Even though Her Majesty isn't quite as striking and full-formed as Castaways and Cutouts, it's still a consistently charming album that finds the band coming into its own.
-
Appealing and slyly catchy.
-
The band's newfound willingness to experiment leads to overkill.
-
UncutSongs, without exception, are well crafted but more often than not collapse into cloying jauntiness. [Dec 2004, p.153]
-
BlenderStaggers under the unbearable preciousness of donkey-voiced singer Colin Meloy. [Sep 2003, p.122]
Awards & Rankings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 38 out of 45
-
Mixed: 2 out of 45
-
Negative: 5 out of 45
-
Dec 15, 2012
-
Apr 11, 2011
-
VincentHMar 19, 2007