Metascore
79

Generally favorable reviews - based on 28 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 25 out of 28
  2. Negative: 0 out of 28
Buy Now
Buy on
  1. Again and again, Antony gestures toward a light: a crying light, a swanlight, a luminous impossibility that beckons, ultimately serving only to illuminate the sadness of this world.
  2. Dec 21, 2010
    85
    Swanlights may not be the best of his works, but it is a welcome excursion along the path of his career.
  3. Even when Swanlights doesn't always take corporeal form-that looseness also means several of its melodies simply fade into the shadows-Antony's voice remains a spectral wonder.
  4. 80
    The styles that parade their way onto Swanlights would probably be the most noticeably diverse change from what happened on previous albums.
  5. 80
    Swanlights is seemingly effortless - the mark of a master at work.
  6. Swanlights reveals a portrait of the artist looking upward and onward beyond anguish.
  7. Swanlights, the fourth full-length by Antony and the Johnsons, reveals that 2009's The Crying Light was a stepping stone that furthered his sophistication as a songwriter, arranger, and singer.
  8. On Swanlights, Antony takes a cue from Hamlet: the purpose of art is to hold a mirror up to nature.
  9. Swanlights succeeds exactly where you might not expect it to: Hegarty sounds content, revitalised. This is a record that revels in a sense of joy.
  10. 80
    From yellowed headlines, nature-magazine clippings, marker scribblings, torn paper, even Kurt Cobain's visage, Antony extracts a poignancy that beautifully matches his music.
  11. Uncut
    80
    All the elements of old are there--his voice, those lyrical hankerings to melt away from the limits of life. [Oct 2010, p.85]
  12. It's a difficult accomplishment, encompassing pop and the avant-garde while also featuring a particularly striking element (in this case, Hegarty's voice); all three are well-represented here.
  13. With his fourth album Swanlights, Antony Hegarty has created his most arresting set of songs to date.
  14. Mojo
    80
    Death, love, the ghosts they leave behind: these are grand themes, and Hegarty channels their spirit with magical grace. [Nov. 2010, p. 100]
  15. Q Magazine
    80
    He'll always be too mannered for mainstream acceptance, but there's unarguable brilliance here. [Nov 2010, p.105]
  16. 78
    A remarkable work overall, Swanlights proves-yet again--that this odd duck has always known true beauty.
  17. Swanlights might be Antony's richest album yet, with musical and thematic charms that take their time to take their hold.
  18. Dec 23, 2010
    75
    He captures the otherworldly more often than not. Occasionally, though, the songs overreach or miss some central point.
  19. On Swanlights, Hegarty's fourth album under the Antony and the Johnsons moniker, the darkness lifts, and the singer sounds almost buoyant.
  20. The Wire
    Dec 22, 2010
    70
    Fans are unlikely to be disappointed, but if you're expecting a new direction, look somewhere else. [Nov 2010, p.52]
  21. Oct 27, 2010
    70
    Swanlights is less straightforward than his other records and more operatic. It's still astonishingly beautiful.
  22. Hegarty's fourth album strictly follows the template laid down by his previous records: fragile, sombre and wistful, always dominated by that extraordinary tremulous voice, seemingly forever on the brink of bursting into tears.
  23. The challenge for Antony Hegarty is just how best to use that quivering, purring, sobbing, ecstatic, altogether original voice.
  24. A record of beauty and balance, Swanlights cements Hegarty as the transgender: artsy and challenging enough for the Guardian chin-strokers, but with enough hushed melodic wallop to seduce all-comers.
  25. Familiar themes still surface, with the natural world continuing to loom large in Antony's conscience, but much of Swanlights is ambiguous and less easy to decipher.
User Score
8.1

Universal acclaim- based on 32 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 26 out of 32
  2. Negative: 2 out of 32
  1. Oct 11, 2011
    9
    Swanlights, the fourth studio album by the New York artist, is what fans might have expected: a string of beautifuly composed and orchestratedSwanlights, the fourth studio album by the New York artist, is what fans might have expected: a string of beautifuly composed and orchestrated haunting songs about yearning, dealing with death and alienation, finding your own place in this unstable world. Antony sings as good as ever, and the songs feel lighter and more cheerful than the last time around. Perfect record for long, dark autumn evenings. Full Review »
  2. Oct 22, 2010
    9
    After the rather glum and subdued "The crying light" Antony turned again to death, womanhood and the earth. However, for the first time, thisAfter the rather glum and subdued "The crying light" Antony turned again to death, womanhood and the earth. However, for the first time, this album is much lighter in tone. The arrangements sparkle and shine, rarely has he seemed more at peace. A masterful album. Full Review »
  3. Jan 31, 2014
    8
    lures you into a fog of beautiful melody
    To say this is a mellow affair would be putting it mildly. The sound Antony and his buddys create is
    lures you into a fog of beautiful melody
    To say this is a mellow affair would be putting it mildly. The sound Antony and his buddys create is difficult to describe and you really have to listen to them to understand what I mean by this. Can you really label their music pop? The music is dished up in equal measures of beauty and weirdness. The songs are artfully and intricately put together and there is obvious craft gone into the record. There are no bad tracks and the worst I can say about the record is that the title track, while it has its moments, is a bit long winded and I'm not sure if it ever gets to a point. "Ghost", "Flétta" and "Salt Silver Oxygen" are the stand outs.

    If I was to try and describe the mood of this record, it's like the listener is lured into a fog of beautiful melody only to find themselves falling into a bog and not being able to get out.
    Full Review »